Agreed, elegance is subjective. According to google "the quality of being graceful and stylish in appearance or manner; style." and "the quality of being pleasingly ingenious and simple; neatness." which somewhat summarizes what I find elegant.
-I prefer thinner slicing blades, but not razor blade thin.
-Short blades are usually more appropriate than 5" blades for light duty pocket knives, but I also don't mind carrying long blades.
-I usually don't find really tactical knives to be too refined looking.
-Narrower blades are also usually more elegant, especially on shorter blades.
-I find knives with thin, pointy tips to be more refined.
-Simplicity is excellent but not "over simplified." I'm don't consider myself a minimalist nor am I interested in simplicity for it's own sake.
-I usually find linerlocks more elegant than framelocks and lockbacks more elegant than slipjoints.
-I find my Opinels very elegant and refined in both form and function, just love them.
-I find my PM2 to be highly refined in function but not as highly elegant in form. Love my Spydercos but I don't carry them around town and the office as often because I can carry a much more beautiful looking knife such as my case pocket worn mini copperlock with blue bone. Feels very watch-like in hand.
-I am not interested in precious metals,stones, or materials whatsoever.
-I usually prefer plain, beautiful satin rubbed steel to damascus and "overly" ornate high art knives. A blend of art and practicality is the right balance for me. a lighthearted knife!
-I usually prefer something like resin composites or wood to a mostly metal handle.
So yeah I'm not as interested in big Ti framelock Medfords and Hinderers at the moment.
It all depends on the individual knife, really.
-Love- all of those knives justsomedude! That Loerchner is the thing of dreams, I would love to carry that thing around in a pocket pouch. I would probably never pay what they're asking, though, I can just tell it would be in the territory of "inappropriate for a pocket knife" lol. When people start asking thousands I start thinking of some really sweet opportunity costs lol. I'm not a millionaire.
Just look at that Mnandi, it is clearly an elegant and refined impressive knife in both form and function. Perfect for small cuts, but at a very high price. The Sebenza with the vine design is awesome.
That Rockstead with the ironwood scale is clearly highly refined in it's cutting and looks, very beautiful. But honestly I find the Dunlap pictured with it to be even more refined and elegant. I would probably rather open a package or cut an apple and an orange with the Dunlap if I had the choice.
The cheaper the better but very high quality is often very expensive obviously. Whether it's worth the asking price is up to me, or you haha. I probably don't want a more expensive knife when I could have a less expensive option.
But these are all my preferences, really I prefer to hear your suggestions on what you all think is both elegant and refined in both form and function. A large variety and outside the box recommendations are welcome. If a knife strikes you as elegant and refined in appearance but functionally silly or low quality than I'm just as disinterested as you haha. If a knife strikes you as refined in function but reminds you more of your mom than of Taylor Swift...well I frankly want Taylor!