.45acp,
Your first assessment is correct. It is all just a bunch of mud slinging.
It all started when a Neil Blackwood decided that Paul had a hand in creating a copy of his design without checking the facts first. Once the facts were presented, that thread dropped like a hot potato! This one was then started by Steve, who I guess has a personal problem with Paul.
I first met Neil Blackwood at this years Blade Show. From everything I can tell, Neil is a man of great integrety that unfortunately presented a theory and got caught up in the moment when a bunch of guys who can't check out anything decided to create a lynching mob.
Paul was just a small business owner whose sales style was irritating to some people. Paul also has some physical problems that some intolerant, bigoted people (who unfortunately frequent these and other forums) just can't seem to get past. Combine both and he becomes an easy target for those people.
I have not met Steve Pryor, but I suspect he too may have got caught up in the Paul bashing.
Unfortunately, these threads combined with the economy, caused Paul's business to go under. Fortunately for a number of people on these forums, Paul never considered suing.
If he is bringing Circle P back, I wish him all the luck in the world.
Pam