The traditional is a Great Eastern Cutlery #42 Missouri Trapper w/ natural stag. It's my favorite pattern of traditional knives--I have one w/ Cocobolo too (which happens to be my true edc, along with what every else strikes my fancy for the day).
Pictures of the GEC 42 or it hasn't happened.
Seriously, would love to hear about how well the 42 carries in the pocket compared to, say, a Buck 500 Duke.
Why?
A quick story from yesterday. I took my Buck 500 to church as I had recently found that a buddy there carried a Buck and, frankly, I wanted to show off my Duke, which is a fine looking knife. [If anybody wants to point out the irony of taking material possessions to church to show off, I'll take the hit...]
We got home and grabbed stuff for a picnic lunch.
I instinctively swapped the Buck 500 for my Opinel 9.
Why?
The issue for me is blade shape.
It's all about the blade. And this is where the Buck 500 falls short.
The Opinel blade is longer and able to cut larger subs in half and reach deeper into a chicken. But it does this with just the right balance of length and belly. It's not too big spine to edge. Nor is it too shallow in this respect. It is
not true that you can spread peanut butter with any knife. When the blade is too pointy or doesn't have enough belly, it's like spreading jelly with a nail.
As for the issue of using a pocket knife for food prep and more personally...
One reason I backpack (and stuff like that) is to occasionally reduce life to something much more simple. Which sweater will I wear?
The sweater that I have. The single sweater. No choice. Make do with what you have and bring things that are the most versatile.
My Opinel is a mental reminder of that mind set for me. I *could* find other knives in the kitchen. But I have
the knife. The single knife that I need already. No choice needed.
Add to this, knowing that I have a food capable knife with me changes what food I take for lunch.
Getting back to the blade shape, repeatedly, having any other knife that I've used and using it with the Opinel near at hand, I repeatedly find the Opinel's blade shape better suited for nearly all food prep tasks.
(Thinking about the 42 as it has a similar shape.)
Opinel by
Pinnah, on Flickr