... for cutting only limes

What I'm getting at is, what steel is my ideal lime knife made of?!
I think we are getting pretty far away from answering the original question. Think ideal steel, not just settling, best you can do.

I love the Vic paring knives as well. There's always one in our knife drawer. That said, the steel is far from ideal. An $80 420hc knife? Probably will work just fine. Ideal? Not in my mind.

I'll stick with my answer that LC200n would be the ideal steel for a lime cutting bar tender's knife, IMO of course. Water way would be great!

zBabgqzh.jpg

38AESTMh.jpg

xLwqCtCh.jpg

QBpnGslh.jpg
 
I don’t know what it takes to spend $160 on a knife strictly for cutting limes (waterway) but I’m glad it isn’t something I’d consider.
 
I use one of these that I got from 1SKS. It's really thin and slicey and makes short work of limes.

I rinse it off, which I find really effective for reducing lime-related degredation.

It was insanely inexpensive.
53t4p.jpg
 
I don’t know what it takes to spend $160 on a knife strictly for cutting limes (waterway) but I’m glad it isn’t something I’d consider.
Well, the only one at our restaurant that makes more cuts than me is the prep guy in the kitchen. And his cuts aren't as precise. I'm doing tons of uniform garnishes and twists, etc. And I have to look cool doing it since I've got 10 people (who pay my bills) usually watching my every move. I definitely want the best, which is why I brought it up here.

Of course that scenario was pre-Covid. Now there still limes to cut... but nobody's watching. I guess I'm wishful that it gets back to somewhat normal soon.
 
Well, the only one at our restaurant that makes more cuts than me is the prep guy in the kitchen. And his cuts aren't as precise. I'm doing tons of uniform garnishes and twists, etc. And I have to look cool doing it since I've got 10 people (who pay my bills) usually watching my every move. I definitely want the best, which is why I brought it up here.

Of course that scenario was pre-Covid. Now there still limes to cut... but nobody's watching. I guess I'm wishful that it gets back to somewhat normal soon.
Makes sense. It's a tool you're going to use all day on the job and it should last years if not indefinitely. A couple of hundred $$ or more for the best tool you can get makes sense to me. Maybe consider a custom fixed blade?

My wife is a first responder and carries a $300+ folder at work. She tried dozens of of knives and this one was just "it" for her once she had it in her hand. It's not what I would carry, but it works well for her. (Every firefighter, cop, and medic simultaneously give her crap about it and want to know what it costs and where to get one.)

I get that you want the best tool you can get for your job and that it's not going to be what other people would use.
 
I got a bag of limes for $2 at the grocery store and tried several knives, including the Spydero Z-cut. I tried two small kitchen knives (shaped sort-of like chef's knives, but smaller), two paring knives, a Spyderco Mule (LC200N), a "utility" knife that is essentially a larger paring knife.

I didn't do a lot of cutting - maybe 2-3 minutes per knife. I did mostly lime slices and wedges with a little cut in the center of the wedge. They all worked fine.

Best knife: small kitchen knife with some heel (essentially a small chef's knife, often called a "petty"). Thin spine, thin behind the edge, good handle, good balance. I could cut with it all day (and have). Probably an inch longer than needed for lime cutting. A slightly shorter one would be better. This one does not have a stainless core. It would work, but not recommended.

2nd best knife: The larger kitchen knife (180mm). Nice knife that is also thin. Much larger than necessary. It works well, but is just too big.

3rd: Spyderco Mule. I was surprised by this. It doesn't have kitchen knife shape and has no heel. I didn't expect it to work this well. It cut limes really nicely and is easy to handle. Heavier than needed for lime work. Something lighter is probably better.

4th: North Arm paring knife. This is S35VN, but of course the limes don't care about the steel. Nice handle and good balance. This would work really well. Heavier than most other paring knives but not too heavy. Quite stainless and will stay sharp a long time.

5th: The Z-cut. As somewhat odd and interesting knife. They offset handle works really well for cutting because it positions your hand above the board naturally. It did fine on the factory edge. Cut like a razor when I took it to 12 degrees. The issue with this one is that it's all belly. I would be frustrated ensuring all my cuts were complete. A flatter would be better for this purpose, imo. Very light, flexible blade. I got the one with a blunt tip. Should have gotten the pointy one. Not quite what best use is for this one. (Getting the Z-cut to 12 DPS took longer than I expected. I used my 80 grit diamond stone on the EdgePro and was grinding away on it for a while.)

6th: Henckels utility knife. It was fine. It cuts well enough. Decent handle.

7th: Victorinox paring knife. It cuts. Not much more too say. Small and very light. I would not be happy using this all day.

xxhvmwf.jpg


4h5yqfF.jpg


Left all the stainless ones with blades inserted into lime pieces and more limes on top for ~3 hours. No staining or discoloration with any of them.

6BR7eog.jpg


After this experiment my recommendation would be to find something like the Carter petty knife in a stainless steel with good edge retention. I doubt you'll see much difference between steels corrosion wise. If you can't fine one, it should not be too expensive to get one made in AEB-L, or you could step up and go with M390 for more edge retention or LC200N for more corrosion resistance.
 
Last edited:
I saw a post on Instagram from Robert Erickson for a knife he calls "the Lemonator" and it reminded me of this thread. Robert is an excellent custom maker and this knife looks great. I tried to PM the OP but could not do so. This knife may be exactly what he is looking for.

I'm guessing Robert could make this knife with any steel you want. This blade in LC200N for corrosion resistance or M390 for corrosion + edge holding would be amazing. I'm sure the N690 is also very good.

https://bladeforums.com/forums/for-sale-kitchen-knives.890/?order=view_count&direction=asc
 
I saw a post on Instagram from Robert Erickson for a knife he calls "the Lemonator" and it reminded me of this thread. Robert is an excellent custom maker and this knife looks great. I tried to PM the OP but could not do so. This knife may be exactly what he is looking for.

I'm guessing Robert could make this knife with any steel you want. This blade in LC200N for corrosion resistance or M390 for corrosion + edge holding would be amazing. I'm sure the N690 is also very good.

https://bladeforums.com/forums/for-sale-kitchen-knives.890/?order=view_count&direction=asc
Thanks I'll check it out!!
 
Spyderco makes a fantastic serrated paring knife that slices fruit effortlessly.
Earlier in the thread OP expressed a preference for plain edge. "For limes I've found that Sharp plain edge > serrated > less than sharp plain. Serrated wins for consistency. But again... the long push-pull sucks."
 
S90v is my favorite steel. I use it for everything. Wipe the blade off and its fine. Using my s90v Native chief to cut up some potatoes here shortly
 
Perhaps many don’t know how fast lime will actually corrode the sharpest edge away.
Wiping and cleaning naturally helps, but must be done soon after each lime cutting.
Doesn’t seem it will do the trick with OP’s situtation.

Craytabs suggestion of LC200N Spyderco looks perfect.
 
View attachment 1553717 View attachment 1553718 I like Stellite blades for citrus work. The David Boye Dendritic Cobalt folder uses Stellite 6-B. I reshaped the blade from leaf to a clip. The 3-D printed knife is in the kitchen to strain spaghetti.
The George Young custom paring knife uses Stellite 6-K and Blackwood. The blade is .028" thick.
 
I recently picked up a Quiet Carry Drift with Vanax Superclean blade steel. Thing is a laser, and virtually corrosion resistant
 
Perhaps many don’t know how fast lime will actually corrode the sharpest edge away.
Wiping and cleaning naturally helps, but must be done soon after each lime cutting.
Doesn’t seem it will do the trick with OP’s situtation.

Craytabs suggestion of LC200N Spyderco looks perfect.
See my post above about leaving those knives in contact with limes for 3 hours. No issues, but perhaps not a long enough test. I have previously tested Victorinox kitchen knives with 3-6% salt water. No discoloration, staining, or edge issues after hours of being sprayed with salt water.

I could do similar testing with lime juice. Maybe make a few cuts per hour into a lime and never wipe the knife off? Would be interested to see how some stainless steels hold up.
 
I always recommend Dexter Russel sanisafe knives for kitchen/food use especially in a commercial setting.

Cheapest solution is the serrated Dexter Russell 3.5" net knife.

AMAZING!

I've also used my Spyderco Salt2 for a lime in the guac and then used it as the best steak knife I've ever used....

It's a great folding option.
 
Back
Top