A follow-up to this:
Around a week ago, I was given a new Fixation Bowie by a friend, and I took it outdoors for some light (and I do mean light) work. Hacking through tomato stalks, cutting rope, and the like. No batoning or even cutting wood. Well, the thing broke. I dropped it on the ground (a thin layer of dirt over harder dirt) and the blade broke just like the one pictured. I couldn't believe it; is this knife so fragile that it will break if dropped in the dirt?!
So I called SOG's warranty department and explained what happened. It was explained to me that batoning voids the warranty. I told her:
a) that's mentioned nowhere in the warranty that came with the knife, nor on SOG's website, and
b) I said I wasn't batoning with it. I dropped it. On dirt.
She said they'd send me the relevant paperwork on why batoning voids the warranty, and that a knife like this is made in China and isn't made for hard use. I explained, again, that I didn't use the knife hard; I cut things with it briefly before dropping it in the dirt. She said that dropping the knife isn't enough to break it, and I need to send it in so they could evavluate it. At this point, I gave her my address for the paperwork on why batoning voids the warranty, and hung up.
Fast forward to today, and I got my warranty paperwork. It's the same five-page warranty statement on their website, with the following portion highlighted (the portion underlined is underlined in marker on the paperwork I received):
This guarantee is voided (as determined by SOG) by misuse, abuse, improper maintenance, or alterations of the product and does not cover any normal wear and tear that may occur.
I'm still not clear where batoning fits in here. Misuse? Abuse? How? How does batoning an outdoors knife constitute abuse? Or am I missing the point, and "as determined by SOG" is the magical phrase that makes my warranty claim void? If this is the way the company is treating warranty claims, then I consider it a big "F*** you!" to the customers.
So, what's going to happen if I decide to spend money on sending the other Bowie in? They're most likely going to look at it, tell me it was abused or misused, or that dropping it is improper maintenance or an alteration, and then charge me to send the broken knife back. Or they can say that the knife doesn't meet any of this criteria, but it was voided in some other way "as determined by SOG". Ideas?