Getting down to it. Pattern vote for 2009 forum knife.

Getting down to committment: 2009 Pattern for forum knife

  • Barlow

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Serpentine Jack

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Swayback Jack

    Votes: 0 0.0%
  • Other - please indicate in your post.

    Votes: 0 0.0%

  • Total voters
    0
Status
Not open for further replies.

Bastid

Goat herding fool and resident vermin breeder.
Super Mod
Joined
Feb 27, 2001
Messages
26,713
The idea thread was good. I appreciate the input.

Steven has volunteered to help me this year and his contacts in the industry will surely be great to use on this. I have no doubt that we will end up with a better knife due to his offer to help. We may draft Ken Erickson (pattern examples) and GigOne (as a backup to me for collection and distribution (in case I get hit by a goat cart). I will make sure Gig has access to our fundage once we have it gathered although it will be my responsibility 100%.

I am going to boil it down to a few patterns that were mentioned the most.
Do not vote in this thread if you are not going to play. :D. If your pattern is chosen, you are 3/4 committed.

Go ahead and post your blade steel and type preference here also. Keeping in mind that much of that will depend upon the company we work with.

The pattern will be what the majority decides. Since all these patterns lend themselves to 1 or 2 blades we will take a look at that keeping in mind the final price will be below 100.

Edited to add. Tough vote for me. I would be happy with any of the three patterns and the Barlow would lend itself to us having a BFC mark on the bolster rather than the blade, even though I voted for a swayback. In short I'm 100% in for two of whatever we decide.

For those who have not participated before. We will collect the total cost of the knife and then place the order. It takes at least 5 to 6 months from the time we send in the money. No profit for the organizers is involved so we usually get the knife at a price decently below what would be represented by the street price of the regular pattern run. Members outside of the U.S. are more than welcome to get in on this, but the postage will run a little more.

Each year we chip in a get a knife for a forum member. That adds a couple of bucks to the price and takes care of who gets serial number 1. I would like to send one this year to Charlie (Waynorth).

Charlie shares much of his knowledge here, with a great sense of humor and caring for this place. I know he has helped a lot of folks out directly and indirectly and thought this would be a great way to acknowledge his contributions in a small way.

P.S. If the knives come in during the first half of December, they may not be mailed until after Christmas. The typical wait at the Bastidville P.O. is at least 40 minutes. I am not going through that again. ;). So if you are not a patient soul, it might be better for you to opt out. :D.

If you have someone else we should consider, by all means post it.
 
Last edited:
I vote for a Barlow with BFC on the Bolster(deep), with a Clip main in carbon (preferably with swedges), and saw cut bone scales. :thumbup:

Peter
 
Regular barlow, two long 1095 or D-2 blades, BF signature bolster.
Thanks for all the effort guys!
Simultaneous posts! Nice choice stockman!!:thumbup::D
 
Barlow with "BladeForums" bolster; carbon main (clip or spear) with swedge and long pull; sawcut bone.
Many thanks for getting the ball rolling:thumbup:.
[EDIT]Number 1 for Charlie/Waynorth sounds like a good idea to me!
 
Last edited:
While I voted for swayback, I'd be content with any of the three ... so I'm in, no matter what.

I think I'd like to see this one with a nice carbon steel.

Handle? Perhaps it's time for a good, dense wood ... Bastid' choice.:D
 
I voted Barlow, but would take this one.:)
attachment.php
 
I've never cared much for Barlows, probably because I've never had a good one, but I'm in for one if it is chosen. I'd rather see a carbon steel swayback. I'd be in for a couple of those, especially if we can get them a little bigger, say 3 1/2" closed or more.
 
I voted Barlow but the Swayback sounds great also. I am in for either in 1095 or other carbon steel. Any that you choose count me in.:thumbup:
 
I agree with Charlie, he has contributed much to the forum.
 
Last edited:
I voted for the Barlow, carbon steel or D2 would be fine.
I believe Waynorth is an appropriate choice for #1 knife. (We already did Jackknife) :thumbup:

Dave
 
I voted for other; Peanut.

And I think Uncle Alan would be a great choice to give a knife to.
 
Voted Barlow.

Preferences:
carbon
2 blades
a spear blade
like swedges!
like long pulls!

Seconds choice would be a swayback.
 
I don't know of any other USA cutlery co. that produces a sway back Jack other than Case. I don't know if Case will do a small run? I voted for a Barlow. Queen Cutlery makes the best Traditional IMHO ie Schatt & Morgan, Robeson. I would like Ebony scales, D2 or ATS-34 blade steel. Clip Master blade, long pull with swedge. If we choose a second long back blade rather than a pen, I would rather see a spear blade with a swedge rather than a spay. These are my thoughts and choices, and hope not to bore others...

Thanks...
 
Barlow with the forum logo on the bolster, swedged spear point, sheepsfoot or pen second blade. jigged bone would be nice in a root beer color.
 
I voted "Other".

Other = Trapper pattern

Steel = Carbon

Blades = Single (Clip or Skinner)

Swedges are nice.

Waynorth -- Charlie is numero uno in my book and I applaud Gus for nominating him for that spot in this years run.:thumbup:


Anthony
 
Regular barlow, two long blades, BF signature bolster.

That 2 blade Barlow for me too! :thumbup:

At least 3.5" would be nice, 1095, or ATS34, and I like bone.
I'd love to say no swedges, but that will never fly around here. :rolleyes:

I think it'd be sweet if it came out to be Charlies' barlow idea, and then we send him #1 :thumbup::thumbup::thumbup::thumbup:

G.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top