glock 19 accolade

Depends on many factors, including where one wishes to survive. Katrina? Peru? Revolvers tend to be more reliable than autos. If you would like put a small critter in your belly, a Ruger 10/22 might be a good one. So it all depends.

I suspect this will get moved the correct forum shortly. :)
 
Let’s see if we can find the right forum …
attachment.php
 
Stubai said:
Is the glock 19 the most perfect auto pistol for the survivalist?
Click to expand...

Auto-pistol + Survivalist...yeah, the Glock would rank up there. I would personally go with the 17 but I prefer the full size. Tough and durable and holds lots of ammo.

But, all things considered, I would prefer a revolver for a handgun in a survival situation. And beyond that I would prefer a shotgun or a 22 rifle. But, it is kind of hard to pack those in an emergency pack.
 
depends. the glock, any model, is an excellent pistol. needs very little maintenance, is very reliable, and wont rust.

the glock is relatively light, but still not the most concealable handgun. it is fairly thick in the grip and the slide is boxy.

if its going to stay in a pack or bob, id recommend a small revolver.
 
Glocks are great combat weapons and I couldn't ask for a better than my M23. Been carrying this one for about 12 years now; never a malfunction.

However, I don't think it would be my first choice as a "survivalist" weapon; at least as I envision that term.

I think I'd want more than one....
 
9x19mm is heavy. .22LR is not. bowning buckmark pistol with optional stock. if it must be semi. there is not a land mammal still on this planet that has not been taken with a .22 LR or .22 short. just a thought
 
The 19 is one of my favorite Glocks. I just prefer a 45 for my edc, so I carry a 36.. To me reliability is first. I would take the Glock. The Glock will still work if dirty, won't rust and holds more rounds than a revolver. Do you need more than 6 rounds? Probably not, but if this is a True Survival gun, more is better. I also like the fact that if for some unknown reason a spring breaks in the Glock I can fix it. Always have spare springs just incase and know how to replace them. I also love the 1911's and carried them for years. They are almost as easy to work on as a Glock and there are only a few components that can break. The problem with some of the newer 1911's is that they are built to such tight tolerances that a little dirt or gunk can make them not function reliably... Revolvers are reliable and simple, however they are not easily repaired in the field. True this is an absolute worst case, but survival is not going to be under ideal conditions...
 
gadgetgeek said:
9x19mm is heavy. .22LR is not. bowning buckmark pistol with optional stock. if it must be semi. there is not a land mammal still on this planet that has not been taken with a .22 LR or .22 short. just a thought
Click to expand...


Rhino? Elephant?

Hate to be a smart ass...but I can't help myself.

I think survivalist needs a better definition. End of the world? No modern manufacturing? I'd go with something i could have a ton of ammo for or reusable (Bow)


Paul
 
9mm , 45 acp ,22 lr ,12ga , 223 ,7.62 x 39.Are all great choices . For practical reasons and easy to find ammo a handgun , shotgun (combo ex. savage 223/12ga ) in these round would be my first choice . Most of this ammo is available world wide . What every gun you're most comfortable with shooting and knowing how to fix in a pinch would be my choice . Glock , S&W ,most single ,overunder combos , pump shotguns .Last but not least an AR or AK-47.
 
pcnorton, it has been documented, I myself have not witnessed this, but it comes from reliable sources. My dad's uncle killed a black bear at 25 yards with a single shot .22 short. of course the bear ran for nearly a mile. would I recommend elephant hunting with a .22? no, has it been done? I believe that it has
 
Stubai said:
Leanwolf: what would you select?
Click to expand...


Stubai, as Powernoodle stated, there are far too many factors in a "survival" situation for me to think that one handgun is perfect for all situations I might encounter. (I feel the same about "the perfect survival knife." ;))

I.e., what type of "survival" are you talking about?? TEOTWAKI?? Just being lost out in the boonies for a couple or three days?? If so, what kind of "boonies??" Mountains and their locations? Deserts?? Swamps? Deep woods back east??

Survival in the city?? What kind of emergency??

So many scenarios and not enough time! :)

I can think of at least a half dozen or so handguns I'd choose depending on the "scenario." Also, if it's long term survival, can I reload, or am I limited to factory ammo??

See. Too many variables for me to choose "just one."

Good luck.

L.W.
 
I've put almost 20,000 rounds through my 19, and I have to say it is my favorite handgun of all. All guns are a compromise to some degree, but with the 19 you have a gun that is large enough to grip well, but relatively compact enough that it's not that hard to hide if concealment is a consideration. Glocks tenifer finish is very corrosion resistant, and the Glock 9mm's are legendary for their ability to digest high round counts without breaking down. How a gun feels in your hand varies from individual to individual, but I think the grip on the 19 makes it one of the most shootable guns on the market. I can do stuff with that gun that sometimes amazes my friends (although I do admittedly shoot more than the average person). Everyone I've ever handed the gun to has displayed at the very least acceptable accuracy with it. On top of everything else, parts and magazines are very reasonably priced. I actually think it is at the top of the heap for a one handgun survival battery.
 
i own three revolvers and one 1911, and from my *small* collection i favor my glock 19 for every day carry. I carry my 19 concealed and have no doubts about its reliability.


for a survivalist, i'm not sure what you're talking about. would i choose this weapon in a woodland survival-type situation? yes. would i choose this weapon in an urban survival-type situation? yes. would i choose this weapon over a rifle in either type survival situation? probably not.



but for concealability, accuracy, reliability, and simplicity, the glock 19 can't be beat.
 
I had a glock, but I am selling it. Did not point well at all, felt like a brick in my hand. and the trigger is long/heavy/crappy. Sure you can get it modified, but it will still retain the crappy ergos. The best pistol is one you can shoot well with. In my case, the Glock just doesn't work.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top