- Joined
- Dec 2, 2005
- Messages
- 69,750
Nice to hear other people are still using neat's-foot oil on leather. Some people claim it dissolves leather, though the can says it preserves leather. I've never found it to dissolve leather.
Really?


The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is ready to order! See this thread for details:
https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/bladeforums-2024-traditional-knife.2003187/
Price is $300 $250 ea (shipped within CONUS). If you live outside the US, I will contact you after your order for extra shipping charges.
Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/ - Order as many as you like, we have plenty.
Nice to hear other people are still using neat's-foot oil on leather. Some people claim it dissolves leather, though the can says it preserves leather. I've never found it to dissolve leather.
I think someone on the forums has said that, and when I told a non-member dealer in scandinavian knives that I was going to dip the sheath of my incoming puukko in NFO, he said "hold thy desperate hand!", or words to that effect.
I've never used neats foot oil but I did post earlier that the coconut oil worked great on the leather softened it right up and smells good too. Andr8shell that picture you posted the top knife I really like,I bet it's very comfortable to use. I'm going to look it up later.
There's a whole Ettrick thread Keith - https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/what-is-the-definition-of-ettrick.1119303/ (posting the link because the new BF Seach function is so useless!)![]()
Thanks jack looks like I'll be reading tonight
Nice to hear other people are still using neat's-foot oil on leather. Some people claim it dissolves leather, though the can says it preserves leather. I've never found it to dissolve leather.
That is so strange... Considering that neatsfoot oil is still sold in leather shops and is recommended for the conditioning and preservation of leather, I find it rather bizarre that someone would claim it dissolves leather...
Rest assured though, it does no such thing, I've been using it for many years on sheaths, holsters, belts, bags, boots, etc. It is readily available and effective!
(Lambsfoot content, I snapped a pic on lunch today)
![]()
Yeah, I also know people who've been using it for decades. Come to think of it, I have!![]()
Very cool pic Dylan, some nice colour to that horn![]()
Hey, do you take your lunch-breaks in the Emerald Forest?!![]()
![]()
![]()
![]()
Andr8shell that picture you posted the top knife I really like,I bet it's very comfortable to use. I'm going to look it up later. Also the patina you have going is great working on mine as I type cutting a apple.
There's a whole Ettrick thread Keith - https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/what-is-the-definition-of-ettrick.1119303/ (posting the link because the new BF Seach function is so useless!)![]()
Thanks for the reassurance, Dylan!Not at all, GT! I use neatsfoot oil on all of my leather stuff, including regular application on my boots. The Guardians Slips received a couple of coats of the stuff before being shipped out. But being that it is vegetable tanned leather, with the drying effects that dyes have on it, it is certainly prudent to keep it well treated with oil. Regular use and the occasional oiling will keep that slip in good condition for a lifetime.
Your Guardian Lambsfoot gets plenty of photos with your "signature" watery backgrounds, Jack!LOL!It wasn't quite a traditional English breakfast my friend
You guessed right enough though, the potato cake thing was a rosti
I'm not sure why they've started putting baked beans in pots here, I had another breakfast today where they did the same
Great-looking pic there my friend, I can't wait to get my Guardians pocket-slip
![]()
Thanks for the tip Dylan, I've used neatsfoot oil in the past
Just throwing in a gratuitous Lambsfoot pic
View attachment 793807
Nice to hear other people are still using neat's-foot oil on leather. Some people claim it dissolves leather, though the can says it preserves leather. I've never found it to dissolve leather.
I think someone on the forums has said that, and when I told a non-member dealer that I was going to dip the sheath of my incoming knife in NFO, he said "hold thy desperate hand!", or words to that effect.
...
Wow, Jer, I like that quartet of lambsfoot knives you've gathered!!Lambsfoot content. That black one I've been fooling with needs a little rounding, I see.
![]()
![]()
Knife on Fire!!That is so strange... Considering that neatsfoot oil is still sold in leather shops and is recommended for the conditioning and preservation of leather, I find it rather bizarre that someone would claim it dissolves leather...
Rest assured though, it does no such thing, I've been using it for many years on sheaths, holsters, belts, bags, boots, etc. It is readily available and effective!
(Lambsfoot content, I snapped a pic on lunch today)
![]()
I think I first used it on a ball glove I got for Christmas in 1958, and last used it on Sunday!Yeah, I also know people who've been using it for decades. Come to think of it, I have!![]()
...
Thanks for finding the link, Jack. Enjoy reading, Keith. I just went and fixed a few picture links since, like many older threads, some pictures are missing.
Hmm...since I have an Ettrick and a Lambfoot, I'm thinking I need to find a Tackler for the Sheffield Trifecta.![]()
Your Guardian Lambsfoot gets plenty of photos with your "signature" watery backgrounds, Jack!Glad to hear you throw your support behind neatsfoot oil, too!
And thanks for the breakfast info; makes me feel like quite a problem solver to have some of my hypotheses verified.
![]()
I think I first used it on a ball glove I got for Christmas in 1958, and last used it on Sunday!
Obligatory pic showing how deeply the coloration is imbedded in the horn:
![]()
- GT
Reporting for duty as summoned in the other threadJack Black
It's so great how this thread has kept going, and going, and going, and going...
![]()
Thanks Jack, yeah the Kukri, and the guillotine are perfect examples of the cutting tool design principle I was trying to illustrate.A really excellent post my friend, a pleasure to readI was also minded of discussions I've read on the reasons for the devastating cutting/shearing power of the Kukri - and the French guillotine!
![]()
![]()
Thanks my friend, just a lucky break reallyWright's had got hold of a very small amount of Sambar, so I grabbed what I could!
![]()
Here's the pile side of that one
View attachment 793622
Thanks for your kind words about my posts, knives, and knife names, Chin; I look forward to hearing what Norse name you've dreamed up!I certainly admire your ebony lambsfoot (is that the prodigal that returned?), and I'm a sucker for lambsfoot pics with actual lambs/sheep in the background!!
![]()
Chin, I'm glad I could be of assistance in your developing perspectives on your Guardian Lambsfoot.I also enjoyed your ruminations on visual vs functional beauty, so to speak.
![]()
Very impressive Clamsfoot knife you have there, Chin!![]()
LOLAbsolutely fascinating post, Chin; helpful pics and intriguing speculations!![]()
Cheers, r8shell - I'm always interested to hear your thoughts on traditional patterns given you use them for craft work as well as the more usual EDC chores. I carried the Ettrick for a bit, it's a very cool knife to whip out to use, when EDCing it, but I'm convinced one of the ways it may also be designed to use is in a kind of reverse grip, with the edge facing the user. It used to be reasonably common, I remember when I was a kid, to see adults peeling and slicing up their lunchtime apples using this hold.Thank you for the illustrative pictures and ruminations re: canted blades. I was inspired to examine and photograph a comparison of my new guardian lambfoot with an Ettrick I received from @WhittlinAway last spring. If I'm being honest, I think the Ettrick would be more aesthetically pleasing if it were not canted, with the graceful s-curve this pattern is known for. Yet, in use both blades are very effective and the Ettrick is especially well suited to draw cuts. (whittlinaway did an excellent job thinning out the primary grind, and this is my favorite knife for craft projects involving cutting leather. Much easier on the wrist and so much classier than an x-acto)
View attachment 793841
I think someone on the forums has said that, and when I told a non-member dealer that I was going to dip the sheath of my incoming knife in NFO, he said "hold thy desperate hand!", or words to that effect.
[Edited to make my reference more obscure, in case I'm maligning the guy. It is a long time since I bought that knife.]
Lambsfoot content. That black one I've been fooling with needs a little rounding, I see.
![]()
![]()
I've never used neats foot oil but I did post earlier that the coconut oil worked great on the leather softened it right up and smells good too. Andr8shell that picture you posted the top knife I really like,I bet it's very comfortable to use. I'm going to look it up later. Also the patina you have going is great working on mine as I type cutting a apple.
That is so strange... Considering that neatsfoot oil is still sold in leather shops and is recommended for the conditioning and preservation of leather, I find it rather bizarre that someone would claim it dissolves leather...
Rest assured though, it does no such thing, I've been using it for many years on sheaths, holsters, belts, bags, boots, etc. It is readily available and effective!
Reporting for duty as summoned in the other threadJack Black
It's so great how this thread has kept going, and going, and going, and going...
![]()
Very interesting knife posted here: https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/old-knives.527126/page-651#post-17588744
I'm hoping the discussion moves over here![]()
Thanks. I like the extra sway on the reddish wooden one Jack sent me (no name on it, but whoever it was got it right). I consider that one less of a beater than the 2-blade Wright I was forced to transmogrify.Wow, Jer, I like that quartet of lambsfoot knives you've gathered!!![]()
Thanks Jack, yeah the Kukri, and the guillotine are perfect examples of the cutting tool design principle I was trying to illustrate.
I think I spotted a smaller pile of what appears to be Sambar antler next to the big stack of strange shaped Pere David antlers in the pic you posted earlier of the A. Wright stag cellar.
Thanks GT, I'll have to try the name out in my head a bit first to see if it works. I find I think of my ebony Lambsfoot in my mind just as 'Mah Knife'. As in, reciting when getting dressed in the morning: 'Keys, wallet, phone, torch and mah knife'! No disrespect intended to any of my other knives, of course, but that's just how it is.![]()
Wow, that knife is a really lucky find, never seen that blade configuration before. Presses all the buttons for me, come to think of it!
Definitely looking forward to seeing more of that one over here @rockman0.
![]()
Thanks. I like the extra sway on the reddish wooden one Jack sent me (no name on it, but whoever it was got it right). I consider that one less of a beater than the 2-blade Wright I was forced to transmogrify.