Guess what your collection is worth!

They still have a blade and do cut, what else do you need from a tool? Someone who wants to buy them for collecting won't give you a second thought but I would easily pay for them 1/2 or 3/4 of what they cost new.
That still wouldn't be much more than $10. ;)

Value estimates of my used users:
Opinel = $1
Old Timer = $5
Hunters Scalpel = $5

Had I not used them, they'd realistically sell on the secondary market for:
Opinel = $5 (brand new ones from dealers are only $8)
Old Timer = $35 (discontinued/collectible, but the most common model)
Hunters Scalpel = $15 (discontinued, but lower grade steel than the new ones that cost $20)
 
[...]And for fun, what's the last knife that you would want to get rid off. Not the last one that you'd sell if you needed money, but the one that would half to be pried from your cold dead hand. Mine would be my Tom Krein Bushcraft that I got as a graduation gift. Though it isn't my favorite user, it has the most meaning.

Whoops, missed this. It'd be my Wenger Handyman. It was my first knife, a gift from my parents, and holds a lot of sentimental value to me. Plus I still use it every single day. It's in my pocket right now.
 
I would say My BRK&T North star 2007 version Yellow G10 scales with matching firesteel....it repersents more than just a BRK&T NS to me...a gift from my 11YO son...he & I both use it from time to time but it was his gift to me a few years back...:)
 
I did this one day, years ago, with my G-scale (Mainly LGB - now gone from the US!) trains. It made me so sick I didn't buy another engine for nearly two years. I like my knives... I don't want to get depressed over them - or my revolvers - so I won't play, other than to say the 'last' pocket knife I would have would be a Buck 110 - the last fixed blade - my late dad's old WWII friend from the S. Pacific - his USN KaBar.

Stainz

PS My 'handle' - Stainz - is the name of a meter gauge Austrian 0-4-0 steam switcher used as LGB's logo.
 
i cannot answer that question...
it would take to long......besides...i dont want to brag....but trust me when i saw....Shock and Awe......Shock and Awe
 
Let's see...

3 multis...about 200 bones
Three FBs...RAT 3, RC 4, and a custom (thanks Doug :)). The prods are about 220$ or so. Can't price the DP.
10 or so proper sized SAKs about 300-400$ is what I spent on them or so.
6 keychain-sized ones, LMs and SAKs. About 60$.

So, currently, about 900$ at most. I've spent probably another 500$ on other knives as well. Those have either gone as gifts, or got lost in various moves or whatnot.
 
I've been buying several hand made items so I'd guess a little over $1000. Of course, the first time I cut something with them that probably goes to $100.

Do not tell my wife. OK?
 
My bank stement says I spent over $1500 on knives between April 08 - August 08. Only one of those knives cost over $100. I doubt the're worth anything close to that now since they are all users. Not one ounce of regret
 
Man... I'll just go with the others, and say that I've spent enough that my wife would use one to cut my throat, if she had any idea.

As for which one I would have pried from my fingers... probably the Para-Military I got on my honeymoon.
 
I missed the last part of the question too. I would have to keep my Vic Explorer.
 
What a collection is WORTH versus what was PAID for it you mean?

Is this before or after the current economic meltdown?

I’d say all these collections people brag about being able to sell for ‘more than they paid’ are now worth about the same as your average full size SUV.

The economy has been great for a couple decades now. Some of us remember how bad it used to be, and understand that spending $500 on a knife you don’t use, isn’t such a great idea. The bottom can fall out at any time.

I bet the high end, super indestructible, atom tough, can’t hurt ‘em , brands are handing out pink slips right now.

My collection cost me around $3500. It is worth a few hundred now, just like everyone elses. All my knives are mid to high end. No CRKT’s or Bucks.

I never bought these knives because they are ‘worth’ something. If I wanted that I would have bought gold.

I bought the knives because they suit a specific purpose, i.e. I use them, or I just like them. I have several folders that I use depending on my attire and situation.

I have several fixed blades because I keep a small survival kit in my truck, house, backpack, hiking-hunting kit. I never forget to add a knife, or anything else, because each kit has its own knife in it already. I can trust my life to any of these knives. Of course if I try to chop rocks with them, I am too stupid to survive anyway and I deserve to die.

The idea of a production knife, [or even semi/custom], being an investment is a joke.
All it takes is a downturn in the economy to put things into perspective.

Look at the for sale section in this forum. Suddenly the words 'Price drop!" are becoming very common....
Gee, you mean they aren't worth as much as you thought?

HA HA!
 
Last edited:
Far too much - - fortunately, I stopped before I went totally nuts and stepped into the realm of the hardcore collector realm - - just barely. I have a few customs but they are all for field use. I admire the wonderful craftsmanship of real collector knives & understand the pleasure that comes from them, but there's too much other outdoor gear that I would like to have. I don't want to pay for things that I won't actually use in the field. - - Even given those limitations, I have more knives than I actually need. I end up using a few favorite knives that meet my personal needs over and over. - - -
 
So far I've bought only about $900 worth of knives. Bryan Breeden can lay claim to about half that amount. You probably wouldn't have convinced me that I would spend that much on knives before I joined the forums. However, I think in my year + 7 mo, I managed to stay pretty reserved on spending. I try to avoid spur of the moment purchases.

Being in Canada and seeing all the 'CONUS-only' statements in the exchange tends to help. I think if you tend to buy through the exchange or maker's forum, then the quest for the deal, can lead to a lot of spending in a short period of time. So far, I've always just contacted the maker I know I want to deal with ahead of time when purchasing. Then again, I'm going to a knife show on Saturday so we will see how disciplined I can stay...

I don't know which is my favorite knife. It hasn't actually crossed my mine to get rid of any of them.
 
Swamp Rat M6. 170$
Ranger Afghan. 140$
Case Sodbuster 17$
BM Griptilian 80$
Old Skool Leatherman 35$
Buck Woodsman 40$

Guestimation = 482$
 
Maybe about 2000 dollars. Many are retired users that have sentimental value.
 
if i were to go out and buy everything new right now it would probably run me somewhere between $1000-2000

but if i tried to sell any of it now i might get $50 for everything...

all of my blades are hard users, nothing gets babied.

As it should be:thumbup:
 
around $2000 including my axes, hatchets, knives, machetes.

the ones with the most value are the ones i have purchased right here from BF in Knifemakers for sale , and also the fixed blade i got as a wee lad and the one my dad gave me.
 
If I sold them all today, I'd net about $900-$1000.

Replacement value (assuming none of them had sentimental value) would be around $2000.
 
Being on call 24/7 I carry a lot of my SAR gear in my car. Luckily my renters insurance and car insurance cover the contents of my car in the event of theft but I had to do an inventory for the insurance company with actual replacement costs. (Not what I paid thank goodness; I bargain shop like crazy) I included any peice of gear that might be utilized such as my Mtn bike and tent. The total came to a staggering $5000. I was floored and that was before I started buying higher end knives like Busses, Swamp Rat and Benchmade. I guess I need to dust off the inventory and update it now that I think about it. How do I explain the replacement costs of a Busse to the insurance company given the limited availablility and secondary prices? Yikes!
 
I keep an index card of the price I paid for evry knife I have bought in the last 2 years
I'm AFRAID to look :eek:

I'm guessing 2K+??
 
Back
Top