Good points guys, some valid, some not so valid...
If a person had a hobby, and if that person also had an obsessive compulsive personality...a personality that almost forced him to buy something that he truly didn't need, such as say, many thousands of dollars worth of knives...
Then, after many, oh maybe 15 years or so, of collecting knives, that person found himself sick, or looking after a sick family member....and having no insurance, found himself in a position where he needed to sell his collection of knives...would that person suddenly become a dealer, as opposed to being a collector selling his collection?
And if that same person, needing the money for bills, found it advantageous to trade knives as part of the selling process, would that person then be deemed a dealer?
If that person was also outspoken, a personality trait that we simultaneously exhalt and vilify, and if that person had alienated numerous people with his outspoken personality...would that person then be deemed a dealer?
If a person made themselves an easy target because of their outspoken ways, or because they didn't utilize a spell checker, would that person then be deemed a dealer?
The reason that I ask this question is, short of, god forbid, the family illness part, I too am going to be deemed a dealer someday if this trend towards vilification continues...just as Jack is being vilified today.
When I say that, I mean...
I once had a "collection" of nine late '60's "Muscle cars", Mustangs, Camaro's, and Chevelle's...Municipal Traffic Court Judge Bundy told me that if I didn't sell the cars, and/or if I showed up in "his" court again, he was going to incarcerate me for as many years as possible...I sold the cars.
I once had a "collection" of 20 "Black Rifles", the legislators here in California told me that if I didn't sell them, then they were going to incarcerate me for as many years as possible...I sold the rifles.
Rest assured, if I had a sudden need for money tomorrow, I'd be dumping some 50-odd Randall's here at the drop of a hat. I bought all of these knives "legitimately" via the forums, ebay, and shows...though I confess, I don't know the history of Any of these knives prior to my purchase...would that make me a dealer?
Also, some of the very best field service techs that I've met over the last 20 years, the ones that maintain our missiles and our Navy, can't spell or type well, and many don't use a spell checker...but our very lives depend on their work...and they're damn good at it, so the "punctuation" arguement is a cheap shot in my opinion.
So, someone has offended you by offending your friend(s) with their typed words, and yet the offended party, (all parties, not any single party), takes no notice...and somehow you now have an obligation to take their place? What exactly does that make you? Does that make you them? No, it doesn't. If they had something to say, they would say it, wouldn't they?
I'm not agreeing with Jack here guys, I think his post was poorly written and was mean spirited. I also sense it was borne of frustration.
And I don't agree with Kevin either...he want's Jack to freely give him back a knife that he alleges was stolen, and that thievery unbeknowest to Jack, the knife later purchased by Jack during the course of a seemingly legitimate business transaction. Kevin's beef is with the thief, not Jack, IMNSHO.
Back to the dealer thread...isn't this just a back door method of trying screw Jack over for alledged past misdeeds? Has anyone here personally been screwed over by Jack? If so, I'd sure like you to post the facts of it here.
Personally, I've had two high dollar transactions with Jack to date, with very little money changing hands, mostly just knives moving cross country.
The guy has the knives we want...and he busted his ass obtaining them too! I'm quite sure that if he didn't need the money, we wouldn't even be hearing about them...kapish?
Is Jack easy to deal with? No, not in my opinion...I always feel like I've gone 10 rounds...but have I gotten screwed over? No, not in any way, shape, or form...he's a tough guy to deal with on a mental basis, and strikes a hard bargain to boot, but does that make him scam artist, or worse yet, a dealer?

Hardly...
Keep it to the facts please...and if you haven't Personally dealt with the man, get off his back then...eh?
"Ye verily, let him with no sin cast the first stone..."
(Typed without benefit of a spell checker...I hope I passed your test...)
