M390 VS ZDP-189 Rope Cutting - Informal testing

Ankerson

Ankerson

Knife and Computer Geek
Joined
Nov 2, 2002
Messages
21,094
The Knives used were Spyderco Endura 4 FFG and Benchmade 710-1.

Material was 1/2" Manila rope.

ZDP was tested 1st and I cut until it would not cut paper without tearing it.


Results

ZDP-189 = 550
M390 = 600+ (I stopped after 600)

Impressions

ZDP did extremely well until around 450 cuts then it noticeably harder to make the cuts as in it got to be a lot of work. After 550 cuts it started to tear paper.

M390 even after 550 cuts it was still not getting noticeably harder to cut the rope, after 600 cuts it was still pretty easy and it would still slice paper clean.

Nothing is conclusive or the final word etc on this as this is just my informal findings between these 2 steels. Both are excellent and hold an edge for a very long time, both are at the top of the heap IMO of the Super Steels.

Endura 4 FFG Photos after 450 cuts

DSC_0723.JPG


DSC_0724.JPG


DSC_07251.JPG



BM 710-1 Photos after 600 cuts

DSC_0726.JPG


DSC_07271.JPG


DSC_0728.JPG
 
Very intriguing. I guess I can be confident of my new 755 MPR tomorrow with the corn(though that type of cutting might require a different aspect than just wear resistance). My 755 seems painfully short when I held it. I never quite realized just how short a less than 3 inch blade really was.

Still, I wonder if you have something in CPM-M4 to compare it to? Or even CPM S90V?

It'll be nice to have a good comparison, though I still feel CPM-M4 will be king.
 
Noctis3880 said:
Very intriguing. I guess I can be confident of my new 755 MPR tomorrow with the corn(though that type of cutting might require a different aspect than just wear resistance). My 755 seems painfully short when I held it. I never quite realized just how short a less than 3 inch blade really was.

Still, I wonder if you have something in CPM-M4 to compare it to? Or even CPM S90V?

It'll be nice to have a good comparison, though I still feel CPM-M4 will be king.
Click to expand...


Yeah less than 3" is very short. :D

I guess S90V would be close, not sure though.

M4, from what I saw with it before I don't think it will match these two.

M390 still had a lot of life in it when I stopped cutting.

I need to get more rope though before I do any more steels.
 
Ankerson said:
Yeah less than 3" is very short. :D

I guess S90V would be close, not sure though.

M4, from what I saw with it before I don't think it will match these two.

M390 still had a lot of life in it when I stopped cutting.

I need to get more rope though before I do any more steels.
Click to expand...

I wish there were more models of BM available in M390 than the 710 and 755. I don't really like the recurve on the 710. Might wind up getting an MPR though.

Is there anyone else doing M390? I think I saw a Kershaw composite in it, but I think the cutting edge was in something else.


I'd be interested in seeing them being compared in the resistance of the metal to deform under impact. I've heard some interesting stories about ZDP in that regard, and I'd probably go for edge-holding in this aspect over wear resistance.
 
Hi Ankerson,

Thank you for your enormous efforts, you're a big part of what contributes to the knife community!

Now the question is, are the bevels on both knives at 9 degrees per side or was it just the ZDP?
 
KennyB said:
I wish there were more models of BM available in M390 than the 710 and 755. I don't really like the recurve on the 710. Might wind up getting an MPR though.

Is there anyone else doing M390? I think I saw a Kershaw composite in it, but I think the cutting edge was in something else.


I'd be interested in seeing them being compared in the resistance of the metal to deform under impact. I've heard some interesting stories about ZDP in that regard, and I'd probably go for edge-holding in this aspect over wear resistance.
Click to expand...

Not sure of anyone else using it right now, but from what I have seen so far it's one to watch definitely, M390 and it's sister steel 20CV.

Carpenter also has it's version, CTS-204P.
 
xtestifyx said:
Hi Ankerson,

Thank you for your enormous efforts, you're a big part of what contributes to the knife community!

Now the question is, are the bevels on both knives at 9 degrees per side or was it just the ZDP?
Click to expand...

Oh, I changed the Endura to a 15 Degree per side Micro-bevel after my last video to get all the small chips out.

The BM was at 15 Degrees per side also.
 
Ankerson said:
Oh, I changed the Endura to a 15 Degree per side Micro-bevel after my last video to get all the small chips out.

The BM was at 15 Degrees per side also.
Click to expand...

Awesome :thumbup:

Just wanted to confirm, I know you're not comparing two steels sharpened at different angles
 
Ankerson said:
Yeah less than 3" is very short. :D

I guess S90V would be close, not sure though.

M4, from what I saw with it before I don't think it will match these two.

M390 still had a lot of life in it when I stopped cutting.

I need to get more rope though before I do any more steels.
Click to expand...
I hope it was CPM M4, because powder metal technology is just awesome:thumbup:.

I've never had S90V, but I do have ZDP-189, and that thing loves to chip on corn. Of all my knives, my Gayle Bradley in CPM-M4 held up the best on corn. The corn made me extremely disappointed in S30V, Elmax, and CTS-XHP.

It would also ask precisely what properties of the steel that rope cutting would test(toughness, hardness, wear resistance) and what type of edge degradation would occur most with this type of testing(edge rolling from lack of hardness, micro chipping from lack of toughness, abrasion from lack of wear resistance). With corn cutting, I feel it tests hardness the most. Cutting through such a rigid and thick medium, the edge tends to roll rather than chip, and that happens to knives at Rc 60 or below. And while my ZDP-189 chips on corn, I feel it's because of the remarkable lack of toughness in the steel rather than because the corn is abrasive or hard.
 
Noctis3880 said:
I hope it was CPM M4, because powder metal technology is just awesome:thumbup:.

I've never had S90V, but I do have ZDP-189, and that thing loves to chip on corn. Of all my knives, my Gayle Bradley in CPM-M4 held up the best on corn. The corn made me extremely disappointed in S30V, Elmax, and CTS-XHP.

It would also ask precisely what properties of the steel that rope cutting would test(toughness, hardness, wear resistance) and what type of edge degradation would occur most with this type of testing(edge rolling from lack of hardness, micro chipping from lack of toughness, abrasion from lack of wear resistance). With corn cutting, I feel it tests hardness the most. Cutting through such a rigid and thick medium, the edge tends to roll rather than chip, and that happens to knives at Rc 60 or below. And while my ZDP-189 chips on corn, I feel it's because of the remarkable lack of toughness in the steel rather than because the corn is abrasive or hard.
Click to expand...


Manila rope is very abrasive and hard on edges, and it's not easy to cut once the edges start to dull.
 
Mr. Ankerson, do you feel the slight recurve of the 710 aided in it's cutting ability?
Do you think the M390 and ZDP189 would be closer if the blades were the same shape?

Thank you for your continued testing of knives.
 
CarlBagget said:
Mr. Ankerson, do you feel the slight recurve of the 710 aided in it's cutting ability?
Do you think the M390 and ZDP189 would be closer if the blades were the same shape?

Thank you for your continued testing of knives.
Click to expand...


Doesn't make a difference in a test like this as I wasn't using the recurve anyway.
 
Noctis3880 said:
I've never had S90V, but I do have ZDP-189, and that thing loves to chip on corn. Of all my knives, my Gayle Bradley in CPM-M4 held up the best on corn. The corn made me extremely disappointed in S30V, Elmax, and CTS-XHP.
Click to expand...

What part of the corn do you cut? Stalk? Husk? Kernels?
 
KennyB said:
I wish there were more models of BM available in M390 than the 710 and 755. I don't really like the recurve on the 710. Might wind up getting an MPR though.

Is there anyone else doing M390? I think I saw a Kershaw composite in it, but I think the cutting edge was in something else.


I'd be interested in seeing them being compared in the resistance of the metal to deform under impact. I've heard some interesting stories about ZDP in that regard, and I'd probably go for edge-holding in this aspect over wear resistance.
Click to expand...

I just saw a BM Grip with M390 blade listed as an LE pre-order at one of the online sites. GPK, I think. It's a sprint run of 200 units, so I'd get there PDQ if you want one.
 
Last edited:
I have to say I'm surprised and impressed. When I first read the manufacturer's data/tech sheet, it didn't seem like M390 would perform the way it has been. Thanks, Jim.
 
JNewell said:
I have to say I'm surprised and impressed. When I first read the manufacturer's data/tech sheet, it didn't seem like M390 would perform the way it has been. Thanks, Jim.
Click to expand...

I wouldn't say it's conclusive or anything or the last word etc.

It's just the way it worked out for me. :)

I took the top 2 performers from my cardboard series and tested them directly against each other.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top