We're not perfect. Mistakes happen and all we can do at this point is make it right. The OP is getting his refund because that is what he wanted. If he wanted to exchange it we would've sent him another knife out with zero issues. All of our knives are assembled by human beings. Every piece is handled by hard working people who do their very best. Things happen and sometimes a bad knife out of thousands gets through. We've been working really hard on getting the fit and finish perfect. Our QC department does not need a spanking. We will look at this knife, asses what went wrong and move forward. We also strive to have the best customer service in the business.
I'm personally sorry that you had to send the knife back and hopefully it didn't ruin your holidays. As you know this time of year is extremely busy for us and hopefully every other grass root company.
I agree with the point that a forum would be boring if everyone had the same opinion. I'm all for conversation and personal opinions. It's the trolls that are not welcome.
I agree that for your hard earned money that the knife should've been perfect. The knife pictured (FYI) would not fail as the lock has no where else to go.
Merry Christmas, Happy Chanukah, Happy Kwanzaa and have a safe New Year!
ER