So four months later, we have the latest version of the Reate D9-A. There has been subtle changes, I call this latest version a "Gen 2", the original was the Gen 1, the version with the updated pocket clip a Gen 1.5 and now a Gen 2 with more changes. I wanted to compare the original to the new one, to see exactly what's been changed.
First thing I noticed was the packaging.
The original case was fake leather and the District 9 version (making a cameo here) had no branding. I can't find my D9-A case but I think it had Reate printed on it in blue. The new one is all nylon with Reate's logo embroidered on with a Reate branded zipper pull, nice detail. Also comes in a sturdy box. And the first thing I noticed, they now include some extra screws, bearing races, and other little parts. Very cool.
Obviously, save for a few small things on the lock side, the knives are identical. The anodize and stonewash on the new one (bottom) are a little more dull than on the old one, but this could also be because the original has been polished by my pocket, because I remember the original being a little duller.
The lock side is where we first notice differences. Namely, the District 9 logo has been removed, the clip is now a much more appropriate machined titanium affair (thank goodness!) and there's now a hole drilled where the detent ball is.
Taking them apart we find more differences, the stabilizer disk no longer has the milling in the frame for a stopper tab.
But, the disk itself wasn't changed, they still grind off the tab (original left, new right):
The bearings are now in a blue carrier instead of a clear carrier. The material seems similar, but the clear plastic seems a little stiffer to me. The bearings themselves are still Ceramic.
Both knives use a Ceramic detent ball.
However, they are now mounted differently. The original (on the right) has the ball mounted in the lock bar insert. This could cause detent and retention issues if the insert isn't seated in the right place when you reassemble, and also makes it more difficult for the insert to be replaced in the case of wear, since the detent ball is rarely in the same place from knife to knife. They're close, but it's enough that it could be an issue. Now, the insert is completely replaceable without any fuss, and a lot cheaper to make, which is why they probably include a spare now.
You can also see that the lock bar is now chamfered to make unlocking easier. The lock bar on my old one was always smooth and easy to unlock and I never had a problem with this, but it's a nice detail nonetheless.
The new machined titanium clip is FAR better looking than the original and brings the knife to a whole new level. This is the way it should have always been. It just disappoints me that the numbered District 9 Storm will never have the new clip, because it would practically be a Mid-Tech in design and quality if it did.
The hardware is basically unchanged, other than longer screws for the clip.
It's a solid update to what was already a very impressive knife. I'm glad that Reate has taken up a Zero Tolerance-style of procedural updates to keep their product fresh.