Oh yes....Somebody HAS to try this with a BK2! Who has the b@lls??

The BK2 would defentily handle it but I wouldn't worry about it breaking, I would be worried that it would slip out! Having said that I bet the BK2 could hold my truck off a cliff!
 
And thats why climbing areas get closed. Funny photo, but I have to wonder what was going on! maybe some sort of climbing challenge, or someones method for adding a shock absorber? Either way, thats a fair few $$$ of gear to leave at the top of a climb, must be a temp anchor of sorts.
 
Doesn't seem like there's weight on the ropes since there's no tension, worst case scenario is the blade slipping out of the tree cause it looks like it was jabbed into between the bark and the trunk.
 
If they tried it they had a safety rope, so no big deal probably a fellow knife nut doing something silly like we do. I agree that its not cool to stab a tree for no reason.
 
daizee said:
Climbing gear has to support not merely static weight, but DYNAMIC force. It's about kinetic energy, not just holding something up.
It's one thing to hold a bowling ball. It's quite another to catch one.
Click to expand...
Ya, if you hang a 550 pound weight on a rope that's tested for 550 pounds it's most likely fine, but if you lift that same weight a few feet and let it drop, SNAP!
I wouldn't want anyone to do this but I would like to see it done with a crash test dummy just for giggles. Maybe we can get it on TV! Free advertising anyone? :D:D:D
 
Again.... That is beyond idiotic and I will lose respect for anyone that tries it.
 
oXide said:
Again.... That is beyond idiotic and I will lose respect for anyone that tries it.
Click to expand...

Why? If someone wants to do it - who are you to judge them or anyone else for that matter?

It may not be the smartest thing but there is the whole free will and personal choice thing that we all have the right to.

There are always consequencies for our choices - good and bad.
 
I seen it on Facebook as well. Its a new knife maker that thought this would be a neat idea to test one of his knife blanks.

Its good marketing if you ask me. It may be crazy and stupid, but it gets people talking about it and linking to his website.
 
majormountaineer said:
Why? If someone wants to do it - who are you to judge them or anyone else for that matter?

It may not be the smartest thing but there is the whole free will and personal choice thing that we all have the right to.

There are always consequencies for our choices - good and bad.
Click to expand...

I'm not trying to infringe on anyone's right to make the choice to do it, but it's such a blatantly self-destructive thing to attempt...
 
I believe knife is the EDC-4 by Survive! Knives.

[youtube]Wo6vRFgOAAA&feature=player_embedded][/youtube]
 
Holy Shit! Well, first off I'm "the idiot" who did this. lol I'm thinking a BK 2 might be able to do this but would you trust a BK16? THAT is the size of the knife I'm using. The knife in question is my SURVIVE! EDC-4 model, made in CPM-3V. Is has an overall length of 9", with a 4.25" blade, that is 5/32" thick. Yes, it is .156" thick! Here's the video to go with it. www.SurviveKnives.com

The tree was a standing dead, that had not yet begun to rot. The knife was removed using a hammer to free it up a bit, then by rocking it back and forth a bunch of times to get it to release. I was making two points with this video. #1 I REALLY trust my knives and #2 by using better materials, a blade doesn't need to be a prybar to be strong. In my opinion mission accomplished.

And for the people screaming "STUPID", I had the line backed up in case of failure. I am a little crazy, I'll give you that but not stupid.

[video=youtube_share;Wo6vRFgOAAA]http://youtu.be/Wo6vRFgOAAA[/video]
 
Last edited:
Sooo, I have more climbing harnesses and rope. What brave volunteer wants to bring their BK-16?
 
In a world of "put up or shut up" you definitely put up.:thumbup:
Nice knives.
I'm glad to hear that about the tree..
I still think you are freakin' nuts.:D
 
DJG097 said:
In that case looks like me and you are just a bit alike...Lol. Did the blade morph or bend in any way after? Sorry if its in the video i didnt watch it.
Click to expand...
The pull up test was actually harder on the blade than the climbing anchor test. The blade came right back to center after using it like a climbing anchor but I had to tweak it just a little to straighten it after the pull ups. Even I was really impressed. Especially taking into account I left the handles off, which would have increased the knife's strength. I have a 5" model releasing in a few weeks, closer to a BK2 sized knife. My only question now is, how in the hell do I top what I just did? Things are going to get really crazy...

On a more serious side note. I do not suggest or encourage any of the crazy stuff I do. In fact I enthusiastically discourage you. I perform these tests so you can use your SURVIVE! knife with confidence, knowing that the crazy owner at SURVIVE! trusts them enough to dangle off a 50 foot cliff, using a thin(.156"), sideloaded knife as a climbing anchor.
 
Last edited:
They are sweet blades. I can attest to that. I have to say I find it a little bit strange that the tone went from stupid idiot to Great knives Guy. After your response.
 
jim62 said:
That looks like a pic from a Polish Mountaineering School brochure..

Or a marketing photo for a knife company from Ohio.:D
Click to expand...

actually, polish mountaineers are among the most respected and accomplished folks among the tight circle of that crowd, dating way back to early years...scaling the toughest peaks in hardest conditions on an inferior budget and using superior ingenuity.... dude, epic fail at cheap humor...
but it's easy to use the crowd favorite old standbys hehe... would you have the nerve to use jewish or black instead??... but that could get ya banned or earn an infraction at best for un-pc conduct or some crap....
i'm from poland originally and although i often use self-deprecating stabs at my 'pollack' ways, i try to be more creative at this type of humor when i do...
};->

to remain on topic - imho a pretty creative marketing gag, i dig the pic though it could've been composed more dramatically and at a more sinister, raw alpine setting....
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top