• The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is ready to order! See this thread for details: https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/bladeforums-2024-traditional-knife.2003187/
    Price is $300 $250 ea (shipped within CONUS). If you live outside the US, I will contact you after your order for extra shipping charges.
    Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/ - Order as many as you like, we have plenty.

  • Today marks the 24th anniversary of 9/11. I pray that this nation does not forget the loss of lives from this horrible event. Yesterday conservative commentator Charlie Kirk was murdered, and I worry about what is to come. Please love one another and your family in these trying times - Spark

Outdoor Knife that last

Status
Not open for further replies.
Thank you! The artsy photo of yours looks like it has more tip and sweep than I thought the S1 had. Great pic! Had a lot of knives pass through my hands, but never a fallkniven. Looks appealing!

How's about the few folks who want a debate on grinds and who is smarter start their own thread?


rpn,

If you look around they can be found with micarta slabs to.



About to slice up a steak cooked in the coals,



I started out not being overly impressed by these knives. But when you block out the internet dribble and actually use them, they excel. At least in the ways I use them. I own the F-1, S-1, A-1, and A-2, among others.

I like the S-1 quite a bit. It is a lot of knife in a small capable package.
I never pretend to tell anyone else they should like my choices. But these knives work very well for me.

Like you, I have had my fair share and can choose what I want.
 
Last edited:
Yes this thread could certainly use some lightening up.

In a similar heated debate over carbon or Stainless on another forum. I offered this up as a way to lighten up the mood a bit.

...

Well that's all she wrote. I have to go wash and oil my knife before it starts to rust.

Oh wait?

Ha, I crack myself up!

Hah! I loved this post. Thank you for lightening things back up
 
So now people who never post online with no cyber cred know exactly nothing about what works, so how could someone with 9 posts know anything. That sounds like something someone would say who seen a YouTube video and thought it would be cool to get into knives because of it and started at zero knowledge with post number one would say.

Here is what I see happening. Someone gets a thick long heavy flat or saber ground blade and try to do some fine work an agile blade does easily. They realize it sucks pretty bad at them tasks but man, it chops decent. So that's all it gets used for. Somewhere along the line of posts and people repeating things they've never done it becomes true. Wait a second, it is true! Them heavy thick saber and flat grind blades do suck at the finer work, but they do chop decent. So how could anything be better? Well I have a long thick saber ground knife and it is horrible at finer details. I have a slightly shorter just as heavy hollow ground blade that weighs the same and it chops much better, in fact it chops almost as good as the twice the weight semi hollow ground SCHF37 I got.

You clearly aren't getting some people get better chopping results from a hollow grind. Just because other grinds are decent at it and suck for other tasks don't mean that grinds best suited task will be better than other grinds for chopping.

I haven't seen any supporting evidence of what the anti hollow grinders are saying. All I see is you're wrong, you don't get it, I'm right, listen to me. Even when people do try to give supporting evidence all it does is help the hollow grind show it's better for chopping. No one has came along to support their axe comments yet. I want to see them explain why the axes I've shown are better suited for chopping than axes ground for splitting. Maybe if one of the guys trying to prove a point can take an 8lb splitting maul and a 2ld Michigan double bit axe to two similarly sized trees and time how long it takes to fell them. You'll get it then.

I have to say I found the comment by craytab of someone with 9 post not being credible here quite hilarious... Knife useage credibility is earned by posting on Bladesforums! Never mind an overgrown property he's been chopping at for years... Let's keep that in mind...

Gaston
 
I have to say I found the comment by craytab of someone with 9 post not being credible here quite hilarious... Knife useage credibility is earned by posting on Bladesforums! Never mind an overgrown property he's been chopping at for years... Let's keep that in mind...

Gaston

I'm still waiting for them to back up the claim the axe companies don't know what they are doing making chopping axes with hollow grinds.
 
I'm still waiting for them to back up the claim the axe companies don't know what they are doing making chopping axes with hollow grinds.

Interesting how if somebody else says something, its a claim. And when you say something, its a fact.

Now you do realize that the Randall Garçon444 is advocating is a saber grind, right?
 
Interesting how if somebody else says something, its a claim. And when you say something, its a fact.

Now you do realize that the Randall Garçon444 is advocating is a saber grind, right?

Never said anything negative about a knife model, or a grind, I just pointed out some grinds do better than others. Unlike oh maybe you. I'm waiting to hear why you think axe makers use hollow grinds on their chopping bits and why they don't know what they are doing and how you know it, and the fella who made the original claim. I'm not gigging anyone or any grind or any brand. I'm sitting here loling at some wild come backs trying to prove a point and doing the complete opposite.

So take a 8lb maul to a tree and fell it, then take a 1/4 the weight two bit Michigan axe to another tree. Come back and tell me what one fells it quicker. I already know, didn't even read it anywhere. You get offended when I site my experience so I won't do that in this post. I'm trying to help you out by getting some chopping tools in your hand. By all means, if that 8lb maul does it quicker for you, then let me know.
 
Not worth it.

I seen it before you edited. It is worth it. I been sitting around waiting for the rain to clear so I can go for a bike ride. While I'm out please post something to back up your claim, even make something up if you have to. Let's hear about why axe makers don't know what they are doing when they design an axe for chopping ground with a hollow grind.
 
I seen it before you edited. It is worth it. I been sitting around waiting for the rain to clear so I can go for a bike ride. While I'm out please post something to back up your claim, even make something up if you have to. Let's hear about why axe makers don't know what they are doing when they design an axe for chopping ground with a hollow grind.

You know what, it still isn't worth it.
You have derailed this thread entirely, and now you won't let it go.

So hey, here you go; you win the internet today.
There are hollow ground axes...woo!
So there you go; pat yourself on the back.
Yay!
 
You know what, it still isn't worth it.
You have derailed this thread entirely, and now you won't let it go.

So hey, here you go; you win the internet today.
There are hollow ground axes...woo!
So there you go; pat yourself on the back.
Yay!

Yup. I gave up a while ago. It is so not worth it. But honestly? The thread was a bit of a farce anyway. The fact that these two guys turned it into something serious is funny all on its own.
 
Yup. I gave up a while ago. It is so not worth it. But honestly? The thread was a bit of a farce anyway. The fact that these two guys turned it into something serious is funny all on its own.

I'd say they turned into something that is circular and has a jerking type movement to it. It may also be hollow ground. :D
 
who's got a map? what font type was used on it?? I believe Times New Roman is better than Century Gothic...

and where, oh where is the OP???

Oh well...just get a Bear Grylls knife and be done with it.
 
The new bk reinhardt kukri.
Hopefully it comes out soon and if it's half as good as the bk9 it will be great but I'm sure it's even better
 
So now people who never post online with no cyber cred know exactly nothing about what works, so how could someone with 9 posts know anything. That sounds like something someone would say who seen a YouTube video and thought it would be cool to get into knives because of it and started at zero knowledge with post number one would say.

Here is what I see happening. Someone gets a thick long heavy flat or saber ground blade and try to do some fine work an agile blade does easily. They realize it sucks pretty bad at them tasks but man, it chops decent. So that's all it gets used for. Somewhere along the line of posts and people repeating things they've never done it becomes true. Wait a second, it is true! Them heavy thick saber and flat grind blades do suck at the finer work, but they do chop decent. So how could anything be better? Well I have a long thick saber ground knife and it is horrible at finer details. I have a slightly shorter just as heavy hollow ground blade that weighs the same and it chops much better, in fact it chops almost as good as the twice the weight semi hollow ground SCHF37 I got.

You clearly aren't getting some people get better chopping results from a hollow grind. Just because other grinds are decent at it and suck for other tasks don't mean that grinds best suited task will be better than other grinds for chopping.

I haven't seen any supporting evidence of what the anti hollow grinders are saying. All I see is you're wrong, you don't get it, I'm right, listen to me. Even when people do try to give supporting evidence all it does is help the hollow grind show it's better for chopping. No one has came along to support their axe comments yet. I want to see them explain why the axes I've shown are better suited for chopping than axes ground for splitting. Maybe if one of the guys trying to prove a point can take an 8lb splitting maul and a 2ld Michigan double bit axe to two similarly sized trees and time how long it takes to fell them. You'll get it then.

Hey Boris, I don't chop with my knife, I will never need to, I carry a mora 511. Please take this argument to a profile wall or something.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top