Random Thought Thread

Watching you guys post the garbage you shovel into your pieholes is depressing. Some of it isn’t even food. No idea what you’re thinking.

Anyway, I live in Buffalo. Mostly, what we’re best at is really horrible weather that we love, because we’re fools, a couple professional sports teams that should be spiking the suicide rate, but we’re too dumb to give up on, and alcoholism.


And probably heart disease.


Being a Rust Belt town, we know how to eat poorly. The famous "Buffalo Chicken Wing" is the best example of this. However, there’s a sleeper of a sandwich that everyone should know about that’s all ours, too. And I want you to have it.


So, here’s a quick pictorial on “Beef on Weck”.

You need to start with Kimmelweck rolls. Sometimes it’s spelled ‘Kummelweck”. Probably German in origin. Most of the German immigrants that moved here (like all the rest of the immigrants that moved here) were undereducated, poor, and already mutilating their own language, much less the American English they were expected to learn, so it’s anyone’s guess what the hell it's supposed to be. The point is that it’s a soft, white roll with a crispy crust, but not too crispy, and sprinkled with caraway seeds and coarse salt. (If you know the real origin of the roll, don’t tell me. I genuinely don’t care).

This is crucial.

You can’t do this sandwich without the roll. Either find some, or look up a recipe and make your own. It’s that important.

IMG_8558-1-L.jpg





You also need roast beef dripping juice. Meaning, the juice that comes off the beef as it’s being roasted. I’m not making this up. We refer to it as ‘au jus’, yet another brutalization of a foreign language, in this case French, but important. Find some. Maybe ask the butcher or a good Jewish deli. Heat the stuff up a bit - doesn’t need to be super hot, just hot.

IMG_8560-1-L.jpg






Cut the rolls in half, and dip each half in the ‘au jus’:

IMG_8561-1-L.jpg



The soft inside of the roll will soak it right up, and it’ll look like this:


IMG_8562-1-L.jpg




Put a lot of roast beef on the bottom half.

Really, I mean a lot. An inch is a solid starting point.


IMG_8563-1-L.jpg





Then you need horseradish. Ideally, you get this from Polish people. they’re in my genetic makeup, and they’re obviously convinced that they’re paying penance for something through hurting themselves with this shit. Miller’s does a decent job, but if you’re really feeling Fonzi, you’ll head to dat dere “Broadway Market” in downtown Buffalo during Easter, and get you a handful of the freshly ground stuff lay you up in the hospital for seven or eight days.


IMG_8559-1-M.jpg





Put a metric shit-ton on the top half of the roll:

IMG_8564-1-L.jpg


(If I’m being honest, the left sandwich is a little light)



You should end up with a sloppy, savory, painful sammich that cleans your sinuses while clogging your arteries, like these:

IMG_8565-1-L.jpg


Best served on a Polish pottery plate.





FFS, guys, develop a little dignity and stop eating at McDonalds.






You’re welcome.
That’s a good ass post, right there!!!!!!😍
 
Watching you guys post the garbage you shovel into your pieholes is depressing. Some of it isn’t even food. No idea what you’re thinking.

Anyway, I live in Buffalo. Mostly, what we’re best at is really horrible weather that we love, because we’re fools, a couple professional sports teams that should be spiking the suicide rate, but we’re too dumb to give up on, and alcoholism.


And probably heart disease.


Being a Rust Belt town, we know how to eat poorly. The famous "Buffalo Chicken Wing" is the best example of this. However, there’s a sleeper of a sandwich that everyone should know about that’s all ours, too. And I want you to have it.


So, here’s a quick pictorial on “Beef on Weck”.

You need to start with Kimmelweck rolls. Sometimes it’s spelled ‘Kummelweck”. Probably German in origin. Most of the German immigrants that moved here (like all the rest of the immigrants that moved here) were undereducated, poor, and already mutilating their own language, much less the American English they were expected to learn, so it’s anyone’s guess what the hell it's supposed to be. The point is that it’s a soft, white roll with a crispy crust, but not too crispy, and sprinkled with caraway seeds and coarse salt. (If you know the real origin of the roll, don’t tell me. I genuinely don’t care).

This is crucial.

You can’t do this sandwich without the roll. Either find some, or look up a recipe and make your own. It’s that important.

IMG_8558-1-L.jpg





You also need roast beef dripping juice. Meaning, the juice that comes off the beef as it’s being roasted. I’m not making this up. We refer to it as ‘au jus’, yet another brutalization of a foreign language, in this case French, but important. Find some. Maybe ask the butcher or a good Jewish deli. Heat the stuff up a bit - doesn’t need to be super hot, just hot.

IMG_8560-1-L.jpg






Cut the rolls in half, and dip each half in the ‘au jus’:

IMG_8561-1-L.jpg



The soft inside of the roll will soak it right up, and it’ll look like this:


IMG_8562-1-L.jpg




Put a lot of roast beef on the bottom half.

Really, I mean a lot. An inch is a solid starting point.


IMG_8563-1-L.jpg





Then you need horseradish. Ideally, you get this from Polish people. they’re in my genetic makeup, and they’re obviously convinced that they’re paying penance for something through hurting themselves with this shit. Miller’s does a decent job, but if you’re really feeling Fonzi, you’ll head to dat dere “Broadway Market” in downtown Buffalo during Easter, and get you a handful of the freshly ground stuff lay you up in the hospital for seven or eight days.


IMG_8559-1-M.jpg





Put a metric shit-ton on the top half of the roll:

IMG_8564-1-L.jpg


(If I’m being honest, the left sandwich is a little light)



You should end up with a sloppy, savory, painful sammich that cleans your sinuses while clogging your arteries, like these:

IMG_8565-1-L.jpg


Best served on a Polish pottery plate.





FFS, guys, develop a little dignity and stop eating at McDonalds.






You’re welcome.
Charlie The Butcher’s
 
Matthew I like your style and respect your authenticity. As well I love horseradish and simple dishes.
Very good. And I agree a bun without caraway seeds in your recipe would be a shame.
Well done
Weird thing is, I doubt I’d eat these rolls with anything else. 🤷🏻‍♂️



Looks tasty, Matthew. We used to call buns “Weck” in dialect when I grew up in Germany.
For crying out loud, don’t tell me the truth. 😉


I gave up reading on your post you type to much... but skimming through it I seen garbage and polish

And you posted pictures (I'm the degenerate that needs pictures)

Heart emoji earned

I dare you to stop by my house and let me smoke you some food without you leaving happy! Lol

Well done Matthew

(Typed while drinking)

(Maybe at least get a gold account hahahahahaha)
Wait until things are less blurry and try again. And the dare could be reciprocated - I’ve been smoking meats for a couple decades, now. 😉



Charlie The Butcher’s
Always a local favorite. The roast beef you see in these shots is from them (they’re a very successful local butcher shop, for the rest of you guys). A couple others that vie for the title of best Beef on Weck are Schwabl’s in West Seneca, and Bar-Bill in East Aurora.


Right? It’s 2025, man. Your food should at least contain food!
 
Didn’t know there was one. Hardly matters, I guess, as I follow the Groucho Marx rule of ‘clubs’, in this regard.




Have fun!

It started last year and was mostly traditional pocket knives but this year there’s more custom makers and dealers, I’m just going to check out Robert Appleby’s Loveless style knives to be honest.
 
Watching you guys post the garbage you shovel into your pieholes is depressing. Some of it isn’t even food. No idea what you’re thinking.

Anyway, I live in Buffalo. Mostly, what we’re best at is really horrible weather that we love, because we’re fools, a couple professional sports teams that should be spiking the suicide rate, but we’re too dumb to give up on, and alcoholism.


And probably heart disease.


Being a Rust Belt town, we know how to eat poorly. The famous "Buffalo Chicken Wing" is the best example of this. However, there’s a sleeper of a sandwich that everyone should know about that’s all ours, too. And I want you to have it.


So, here’s a quick pictorial on “Beef on Weck”.

You need to start with Kimmelweck rolls. Sometimes it’s spelled ‘Kummelweck”. Probably German in origin. Most of the German immigrants that moved here (like all the rest of the immigrants that moved here) were undereducated, poor, and already mutilating their own language, much less the American English they were expected to learn, so it’s anyone’s guess what the hell it's supposed to be. The point is that it’s a soft, white roll with a crispy crust, but not too crispy, and sprinkled with caraway seeds and coarse salt. (If you know the real origin of the roll, don’t tell me. I genuinely don’t care).

This is crucial.

You can’t do this sandwich without the roll. Either find some, or look up a recipe and make your own. It’s that important.

IMG_8558-1-L.jpg





You also need roast beef dripping juice. Meaning, the juice that comes off the beef as it’s being roasted. I’m not making this up. We refer to it as ‘au jus’, yet another brutalization of a foreign language, in this case French, but important. Find some. Maybe ask the butcher or a good Jewish deli. Heat the stuff up a bit - doesn’t need to be super hot, just hot.

IMG_8560-1-L.jpg






Cut the rolls in half, and dip each half in the ‘au jus’:

IMG_8561-1-L.jpg



The soft inside of the roll will soak it right up, and it’ll look like this:


IMG_8562-1-L.jpg




Put a lot of roast beef on the bottom half.

Really, I mean a lot. An inch is a solid starting point.


IMG_8563-1-L.jpg





Then you need horseradish. Ideally, you get this from Polish people. they’re in my genetic makeup, and they’re obviously convinced that they’re paying penance for something through hurting themselves with this shit. Miller’s does a decent job, but if you’re really feeling Fonzi, you’ll head to dat dere “Broadway Market” in downtown Buffalo during Easter, and get you a handful of the freshly ground stuff lay you up in the hospital for seven or eight days.


IMG_8559-1-M.jpg





Put a metric shit-ton on the top half of the roll:

IMG_8564-1-L.jpg


(If I’m being honest, the left sandwich is a little light)



You should end up with a sloppy, savory, painful sammich that cleans your sinuses while clogging your arteries, like these:

IMG_8565-1-L.jpg


Best served on a Polish pottery plate.





FFS, guys, develop a little dignity and stop eating at McDonalds.






You’re welcome.
Round cheer (actually north of Boston) we have the Roast Beef 3-way...served on a griddled onion roll with bbq sauce (specifically James River), mayo, and cheese.
 
Offset, pellet grill, or charcoal?

To my knowledge, there was no such thing as pellet when I started. I’ve used offset, before, but pretty much settled on the simplicity of the Weber Smokey Mountain smoker. Think mine is over 20 years old, now, I’ve beaten the shit out of it, never taken care of it, and it still works perfectly. When I can find it, which isn’t often anymore, I prefer Humphrey’s hardwood charcoal briquettes. They’re out of PA, but no one seems to stock them anymore, around here. Have to order an entire pallet to get it, and I just can’t justify that. Flavor with apple wood that I scrounge.



Round cheer (actually north of Boston) we have the Roast Beef 3-way...served on a griddled onion roll with bbq sauce (specifically James River), mayo, and cheese.


I’ve had North Shore 3 way. Good, but a totally different animal from beef on weck.
 
Back
Top