removing price on sold items

Status
Not open for further replies.

Matteo Escobar

Gold Member
Feedback: +26 / =0 / -0
Joined
Feb 26, 2002
Messages
4,144
Can I reiterate how annoying it is when people replace the price of a knife for sale with *SOLD* when they receive an offer. It benefites us all when we know what certain knives are going for. Leave the price up, as well as indicating that it has been sold!!!!:(
 
Sorry Matteo Escobar & averageguy. . .I don't agree.

It's the "sellers choice."

Besides. . .what a knife sells for on forums such as this isn't a true measure of the worth of a knife. Prices fluxuate due to the whim/position of the seller. The buyer can also play a critical role on what the knife sold for.

Keep in mind. . .certain knives will always bring "their standard" price.

If you're curious, as to the final sale price of a particular knife, you can do several things:

1. E-mail the seller and ask how much they received
2. Check some of the internet knife selling shops
3. Check the custom maker (e-mail, phone, internet)

Please don't take this as being rude. . . It's no ones business what I sold a knife for nor what I paid for a knife.

The final price is between 2 people. . .the buyer and seller.

It's a "personal privacy" thing.
 
The final price is between 2 people. . .the buyer and seller.
I agree that the final price should be private between the buyer and seller. However the last asking price for an item is valuable information that was public just prior to the sale. I would appreciate it if sellers left that price visible as a service to the knife community.
 
I agree that "final" selling price is between seller and buyer but I think the "asking" price should be left up like Rev. Pete mentioned. Leaving the asking price up does provide a service to the knife community. You can search and see what various knives are going for...and this helps sellers and buyers. If keeping the Price Private is important for some reason, then just post the item for sale and ask for people to email to discuss price. In my personal experience, I enjoy seeing what knives that I like or models that I own, sell for.
For example....There was a post with a 99 Emerson Mil-Spec Commander for sale and it sold and the asking price was Removed. I have one of those (that I don't want to sell) but I would love to know what the asking price was and I think it's kind of rude to email someone who has no idea who I am and ask what the knife sold for......
Just an opinion, but it's my opinion
God Bless America!
Thanks,
Shannon
 
As a buyer, not a seller, I've come to see that nearly every knife for sale represents some degree of bargain on the board. Just how much of a bargain seems to be the crux of this topic.

While I appreciate prices being left in posts, I concur with GigOne; it really is up to the seller as to whether or not prices will persist. And perhaps an occasional buyer might ask the seller to delete the price--I don't know about that, what about you folks?

A simple solution for Matteo et al, if one regularly follows the board, is to save as text files those threads with knives of interest. Tiny file size, replace with updates, at least you'll track a fair number of pricing histories and compile them for later use. Build a separate/associated cache of jpegs.

If you develop interest in a new and different knife than you've already tracked, you of course can still search threads and find SOME which probably have price info still present.

Text files like these are so small you can save 500,000 on the space of a CD-R (which you can buy for 10 cents apiece all over, BTW). Your hard drive should be lean and mean anyway--prune the many gigs of junk by burning to CD or dumping, and streamline/speed up your machine. Plenty of room for knife info. :D

Five seconds of saving per post will accumulate a useful data file in no time. If prices are deleted later, your file is still useful. Those that sell superfast (before you see/save) probably were a super-bargain or so sought after that the thread price is not that helpful.

So sellers, thanks if you leave the info, no sweat if you edit. Another example of freedom, eh?

Regards,
Norman
 
Originally posted by woody
I agree that "final" selling price is between seller and buyer but I think the "asking" price should be left up like Rev. Pete mentioned. Leaving the asking price up does provide a service to the knife community. (snip)

I appreciate the fact that this particular posting addressing this topic has been well mannered and thoughtful. A few prior posters really got on their high horses claiming that editing out offered (or even sold!) prices constituted some sort of nefarious gamesmanship or worse. Good grief!

Personally I do not see that anyone owes me a track record of prior deals. I sometimes edit them out and sometimes leave them in. No particular reason either time. But I don't believe I owe it to anyone to leave them in. I think this subject is a good "poll" topic and so I am posting one.
 
Good poll.

As one of the nefarious ones that usually edits prices out, I prefer to not leave a track record.

Lets say knife A usually sells for $5. Then, someone who really needs the cash or is otherwise desperate sells it for $3. Next time someone (it could be you) puts knife A up for sale, many folks here seem to think that the going rate is $3 and send emails saying "well so and so sold that same knife for $3, here is the thread to prove it".

Every time you buy a knife (or trade) on the Exchange, you are probably getting the best deal available anywhere, with few exceptions. Editing out the figures just means that the buyer has to be a little more knowledgable to do their negotiating.
 
I'd go a step farther and say delete the entire thread once the deal is done. It would not only save space, but it would stop those buyers who can't seem to understand the knife is gone from e mailing offers etc.
 
Originally posted by Jake Evans
I'd go a step farther and say delete the entire thread once the deal is done. It would not only save space, but it would stop those buyers who can't seem to understand the knife is gone from e mailing offers etc.

That will not happen. We DO NOT DELETE POSTS AT BLADEFORUMS!!!

Folks, the posts made here are part of BFC, and become part of the searchable archives in the future. If we deleted everything, including for sale posts, we'd have no history, and that would hurt us all.

I stated in the poll thread that I'd personally like to see the ASKING PRICE remain in the thread, so that there is something of record to look back on in the future.

I'd like to see some more debate on this issue, and I'd like to know the general concensus of the membership.

I'd hate to see us moderators make a policy concerning this, so I'd like to see what others have to say. Maybe the sellers can 'police' themselves on this issue, and show some common courtesy towards your fellow members.
 
First of all, the asking price does not necessarily refect the final agreed upon price, so I really don't find it necessary to immediately delete the price. BUT...I usually list quite a few knives, therefore I have found that to keep my listing readable that will occasionally delete my items that have sold or traded.
 
Whenever I have sold a knife I have never removed the asking price from the ad. I see no reason to do so. I will never post the price that the knife actually sold for. That is no ones business but mine and the person that bought the knife.

It is my opinion though that it is totally up to the person that posted the knife for sale if they are going to leave the price posted or remove it.
 
Knowing how 2 of the moderators feel on this subject. . .I pray that we aren't forced to live with a decision that they make ! :barf:

It's a "sellers choice" and should be left that way !

Personally. . .I think some moderators are over-stepping their bounds on this issue !
 
Moderators have opinions too, and so do I!!!

My opinion for what it is worth. Prices can stay or go. It may be beneficial to other members to leave them. What was sold should stay.

I have always left my for sale posts as is, and I did not edit out any pricing. Big D1
 
Originally posted by Jake Evans
I'd go a step farther and say delete the entire thread once the deal is done. It would not only save space, but it would stop those buyers who can't seem to understand the knife is gone from e mailing offers etc.

I agree with removing sold item threads. Aside from the reason above, it would save server space. a seller would probably have to notfiy adminisrtation to have the thread deleted.

As far as replacing the price with sold, I have to agree, it's the sellers choice. It does make it easier to tell when a piece is gone. Some of the threads are long and span some weeks.

What is the time limit for changing headers? This is another great way to flag an item as sold.

Cheers

GC
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top