The BladeForums.com 2024 Traditional Knife is ready to order! See this thread for details:
https://www.bladeforums.com/threads/bladeforums-2024-traditional-knife.2003187/
Price is $300 $250 ea (shipped within CONUS). If you live outside the US, I will contact you after your order for extra shipping charges.
Order here: https://www.bladeforums.com/help/2024-traditional/ - Order as many as you like, we have plenty.
I was just looking at a Worksharp. Wondering if they are really worth the price tag. I was checking out the Ken Onion edition and by the time you get a few attachments and belts.....you're looking at near $300. Almost by a decent belt grinder for that.
I want it for a bit of "experimenting". Also, dropped my Southard and destroyed the tip. I've never had an issue with getting them "work" sharp, but also never been able to get them shaving sharp.
I have the Worksharp KO edition and I have the Wicked Edge Field and Sport Pro (waiting to get additional stones and strips). I'll share a few points about each:
The Worksharp KO Edition
The Good:
1. It has great belts that work very well
2. It has variable speeds
3. It has the ability to reprofile very quickly
4. It's easily transportable
5. It can accommodate a wide variety of edge angles
6. It can effectively produce a mirror polished edge very quickly
7. Attachments are available and allow for a variety of different steel edges (chisels, axes, scissors, knives, hooks, straight razors, etc.)
8. Cost is around 150 for sharpener and 2 packs of belts
The Bad:
1. Cost (although this is relative)
2. Belts wear out faster than I'd like
3. Belts are not sold individually, so you have to buy the pack
4. THIS IS A BIG PROBLEM: the angle guides MOVE!! Meaning when you apply lateral force/pressure against the guide -- the guide moves and therefore changes angles. The original Worksharp did NOT have this problem.
5. In my experience, thicker knives -- especially ones with coating -- do not easily get sharpened at 20 degrees or less.
6. Steel can sometimes be removed too quickly
7. If you're not careful (even with the KO edition) tips can be rounded off
The Wicked Edge Field & Sport Pro
The Good:
1. Transportable
2. Works pretty much anywhere and everywhere
3. The level of precision is unrivaled
4. With the accessory stones and strops there is nothing out there (including paper wheels) that can get your knife super sharp and precise.
5. Once the measurements are learned the sharpening process becomes essentially the exact same every time you sharpen.
6. The diamond stones cut steel fast and they last a really long time
7. This is what you want to use on super expensive knives. Truly perfect edges are fairly easily achievable.
The Bad:
1. It's freaking expensive
2. There's a learning curve
3. There's inherent safety issues/dangers with the knife edge facing up
4. Re profiling can take too long if the angle change is too drastic
5. Different knife blade designs require slightly different techniques that need to be learned
6. Diamond particles can scratch the surface they fall on (e.g glass, wood, etc.)
They each have their perks -- but if we're comparing both -- the wicked edge is clearly dominant in the end result that is produced. Hope this helps!
-Rob Abyane
Thanks rob through as usual. Have you done convex edges with the KO? I know you need the attachment for it. I like cobalt idea and post as well. I think I will try that with a cheap knife first haha
Thanks rob through as usual. Have you done convex edges with the KO? I know you need the attachment for it. I like cobalt idea and post as well. I think I will try that with a cheap knife first haha
I was just looking at a Worksharp. Wondering if they are really worth the price tag. I was checking out the Ken Onion edition and by the time you get a few attachments and belts.....you're looking at near $300. Almost by a decent belt grinder for that.
I have the KO Worksharp and the original. Most of what Rob says is true but I tend to disagree on a few points,
Belts, yes you do have to buy the originals in packs mostly (I think though you can get them individually direct from WS), I buy micromesh belts for mine is larger lots (as there is a minimum out here) but in the US this should be easier.
The moving guides take some getting use to but I actually find it an improvement over the fixed guides as it lets me know when I am pressing out too far (you can tighten them up if you wish but you need to loosen them again to change angles).
I had no trouble with my thicker blades Rob, did a .32 ASH that is a bloody big razor now...![]()