Spyderco Tenacious not so popular?

Joined
Aug 17, 2009
Messages
362
Hey sorry just wanted to know cause I really like the knife I just want to know if it has been surpassed or something recently... I never see it in the exchange. Please tell me because I really like it but im not sure...
 
Its great!!! trust me I like mine nearly as much as my Lone Wolf that was over twice as much!! I doubt you'll ever hear anything bad about them on here but I could be wrong! And one reason you may never see them in the exchange is nobody wants to get rid of theirs!
 
Awesome! I was feeling depressed because no one uses it for edc. I think its cool and I plan to use it for edc as long as its good for that...
 
A ton of people carry it every day. I do. Read all the "best folder for under XXX$" threads if you want to hear people recommend it.
 
Maybe the best folder ever dollar for dollar. I love mine and the price lets me use it the way it was meant to be used without any guilt.
 
And one reason you may never see them in the exchange is nobody wants to get rid of theirs!

This is probably what's goin on.

The Tenacious is the golden boy of these forums. I don't think I can recall anybody ever saying anything bad about it.
 
Mine is my current EDC I love it and the one thing I'd change which is I would make the blade longer and theres a new version coming out that fixes that.
 
I already bought three PE Tenaciouses, gave away two. The last one always keeps me company. It's a great knife for the price (even when I paid too much for it at 39 euros).
 
The Tenacious is the golden boy of these forums. I don't think I can recall anybody ever saying anything bad about it.

Except that it's Chinese in origin. I personally don't care where it comes from, though. It's a mighty fine knife!
 
This is probably what's goin on.

The Tenacious is the golden boy of these forums. I don't think I can recall anybody ever saying anything bad about it.


Nothing bad?

Well, its a linerlock knife - so watch them fingers. The cut-out to disengage the lock is too big, making the lock easily inadvertently disengaged.

The 8CR13MOV steel isn't the "cat's meow" as far as steels go. Good for sharpening practice.

The big hole in the blade is a weak spot where the blade will probably snap off.

As for being the "golden boy", hardly. Its a $40 dollar knife that performs as well as a $40 will. Nothing special. You can do worse, but for a few bucks more you can do better. Same can be said for a number of knives.
 
I think it's still one of the top 3 best buys out there. That level of quality, features and low price never gets old. It only loses 'popularity' when it reaches market saturation or gets discontinued.

I love mine and may get another in the near future.
 
Nothing bad?

Well, its a linerlock knife - so watch them fingers. The cut-out to disengage the lock is too big, making the lock easily inadvertently disengaged.

The 8CR13MOV steel isn't the "cat's meow" as far as steels go. Good for sharpening practice.

The big hole in the blade is a weak spot where the blade will probably snap off.

As for being the "golden boy", hardly. Its a $40 dollar knife that performs as well as a $40 will. Nothing special. You can do worse, but for a few bucks more you can do better. Same can be said for a number of knives.

I"m just wondering if you have held a Tenacious?

I think that Spyderco liner locks are some of the best in the business. My Tenacious has great lock up, no vertical or horizontal play. When opened it locks up with a nice "thunk". I don't worry about the lock up at all.

I have tried my Tenacious in several different grips and the way my hands grip the knife, I cannot see any way that the lock would disengage accidentally. Of course different people have different size hands and some people might have issues with this. I would think that if they do, the problem would not be limited to the Tenacious.

The steel may not be the "cats meow", but that does not mean it is a bad steel. I use mine around the yard and find that the edge holding is up there with steels in the 440C and AUS-8 catagory. It doesn't hold an edge forever, but it doesn't take much time to touch up. A few minutes on the Sharpmaker and its ready to go. I don't think I have had to use anything but the fine stones to touch it up.

I have been around this forum and the Spyderco factory forum for a long time and I have never seen a Spyderco broken at the hole in normal use. Of course if you do something stupid it is possible.

As for the price, at $40.00 it's a great value. I showed it to a friend of mine and he couldn't belive that it was only $40.00, he thought it would have sold closer to $100.00.

Bruceter
 
Nothing bad?

Well, its a linerlock knife - so watch them fingers. The cut-out to disengage the lock is too big, making the lock easily inadvertently disengaged.

The 8CR13MOV steel isn't the "cat's meow" as far as steels go. Good for sharpening practice.

The big hole in the blade is a weak spot where the blade will probably snap off.

As for being the "golden boy", hardly. Its a $40 dollar knife that performs as well as a $40 will. Nothing special. You can do worse, but for a few bucks more you can do better. Same can be said for a number of knives.

Linerlocks can be made right, and Spyderco is front and center doing them. Nobody, including me, complains about Spydercos much failing. Plenty of other makers screw up the design and get reported here.

The steel is a local Chinese product equivalent to AUS8, in the opinion of the knowledgeable. It certainly isn't the typical junk steel so often found on American slipjoints. Why import higher priced material when you can use the local stuff?

If the Spyderhole was a huge defect in blade strength, pictures would have been posted long ago, and nobody would be making things worse by waving the hole to improve it as a self defense weapon - which makes it subject to even more impact. If anything, people complain about Spyderco's pointy tips and have posted they broke it off doing something less than knifelike to it.

As for price, another bogus whine. Labor rates affect material costs as much as manufacture and assembly. The knife sells for $40, sure, but it's superior to many US made knives at $60 - and I've got the Buck knife to show for it, a Strider knock-off in 420 and FRN. The Griptillian crowd won't like it, but that's an even better example of high priced low performance material consumption.

At least with the Tenacious you get G10 - and if you like to upgrade, try the Benchmade Vex, even better with a TiN blade that zips through cardboard like a light sabre.

For $40, you get a much superior knife compared to American "junk." (Heavy irony to those who know.)
 
I think it is a good knife "for the money". I personally would rather spend a little more and buy a knife that is manufactured in a country that doesn't hate the U.S.
 
I have 2 Tenacious, one always gets carried in my laptop bag. It's a little too heavy for my taste as an EDC since I prefer lighter blades; my Delica is my current favorite EDC. I live in a liberally oriented suburb and I've gotten a few surprised and even shocked reaction from people when I pulled the Tenacious out for whatever reason. I think that would be true for ANY knife aside from a little Victorinox around here.

Regarding the strength of the liner lock and the blade steel, I think it's probably the strongest liner lock I've owned on a folder. I've chopped through a 2x4 with my Tenacious and it did a good job so I have no reservations about the steel and more importantly the heat treatment from Spyderco. It needed a good touch up afterwards as I like a shaving sharp edge but no chips or looseness at all. It's a good value knife. BTW, take a look at the Persistence. It's a little brother to the Tenacious.
 
I"m just wondering if you have held a Tenacious?

I think that Spyderco liner locks are some of the best in the business....

I have tried my Tenacious in several different grips and the way my hands grip the knife...

The steel may not be the "cats meow", but that does not mean it is a bad steel. I use mine around the yard and find that the edge holding is up there with steels in the 440C and AUS-8 catagory...

I have been around this forum and the Spyderco factory forum for a long time and I have never seen a Spyderco broken at the hole in normal use...

As for the price, at $40.00 it's a great value. I showed it to a friend of mine and he couldn't belive that it was only $40.00, he thought it would have sold closer to $100.00.

Bruceter

Yes, I have held one.

Try more grips and have a fleshy handed person give it a try.

What is "normal use"? Snapped a Military, 440v unfortunately, and it was my bad. Still, the hole weakens the blade in comparion to a un-holed blade.

Never said it was not a fair value.
 
Linerlocks can be made right, and Spyderco is front and center doing them...

The steel is a local Chinese product equivalent to AUS8, in the opinion of the knowledgeable. It certainly isn't the typical junk steel so often found on American slipjoints...

If the Spyderhole was a huge defect in blade strength...


As for price, another bogus whine...


For $40, you get a much superior knife compared to American "junk." (Heavy irony to those who know.)


Spyderco sells them, Spyderco does not make them. Artisans in China make these knives.

And what does the piss-poor performance of most factory slipjoints have to do with it? Few buyers appear willing to pay for a high perfermance steel in a slipjoint - so few such knives are offered. I thank Spyderco for my UKPK knives - note the price of that model.

AUS8 nor 440C are considered all that great in comparison to some of the other readily available steels. And for $40, the blade better be better than the oft seen "junk".

As for price, where is the "whine". Noting that the knife is equivalent to similarly priced products amazingly is not a "whine". It is an observation.

A hole in anything is structurally weaker. Simple strength engineering stuff and obvious to anyone. Heck, people still get doctorates studying this stuff to derive "k" factors for modelling the REDUCED strength of members with holes in them.

American workers do make more per hour than the average Chinese worker. So, American made things cost more. As for American made "junk", what constitutes "junk" is subjective.

But that does not change the fact that there are alternative $40 knives that are just as good, or bad, as the Tenacious.



When someone states that nothing bad has been said about a product, it is unclear as to why suddenly people find it required to only then step forward to extoll the "virtues". Every product has good and bad points.

Makes for more interesting posts, though, in comparison to the usually fawning.:D
 
how did you do that?
do you have pictures, I'd love to see the broken blade.

Snapping blades is simple to do - in the instant case I was simply levering through a thick plastic drum seem. Too much side force and snap. Personnally, I was amazed I was able to get that much force, as these early Military knives have "flexi-flyer" locks.

I'm not a member of the current "lets take picture of everything" generation. I can't even figure out how my cell phone takes pictures.

If you can find it, I saw a picture of a Spyderco hole knife where the top of the blade had a through crack.
 
Back
Top