Swamp Rat vs Becker?

wildmike said:
I live in the PNW as well. I have had zero rust and corrosion issues with 52100/sr101 in heavy field use. In all 4 seasons. It might be an issue if left in salt water without cleaning or left coated in blood without cleaning for days etc. In regular and even very heavy use with the same care most folks would give any blade in use you will have no problems.
Click to expand...

yep ive had no issues with rust what so ever...
 
I work in a very wet/salty environment, haven't had any serious issues with my swamp rats. I have had worse results from some stainless steels oddly enough. Just remember to wipe your knife off if you go swimming in the ocean.
 
so what you are saying is that a becker bk7 will not do what a swamp rat will i beg to differ bud the beckers are the best knives ever made and they are made to beat the snot out of just my personal preference why spend three hundred dollars when i can spend 80 on my bk7 and it will do the same thing.
 
hi all i am new here i replied to kdstrick about the bk7 vs the swamp rats and my post was moved to page 4 i dont know why that is wierd but he was saying he beats the snot out of his swamp rat well i promise you my becker bk7 will do everything that any swamp rat will do and its less than half the price my personal opinion is that becker makes the hands down best knife in the world steal isnt to over the top good ole 1095 thats proven its made for rough use holds a razor edge and wont let you down that is my kind of knife and oh yeah it dont take a second mortgage to get one or a six month waiting period lol im new here but i love this site thank yall.
 
I started with beckers and moved up to Busses. I still think beckers are the best bang for your buck on the market, without excepton
 
baddestblade#1 said:
hi all i am new here i replied to kdstrick about the bk7 vs the swamp rats and my post was moved to page 4 i dont know why that is wierd...
Click to expand...

Greetings and welcome to the Swamp Rat Knife Forum!

Posts in threads on almost EVERY internet forum are placed in chronological order (the order in which they are received). If you post a reply to something on page 1 of a 4-page thread, your reply will appear on the bottom of page 4, or the top of page 5. You may also want to note the DATE of the post you are replying to - this is a (nearly) 4-month-old thread on a topic that has been rehashed many times over. Perhaps you'd like to go through all old threads regarding this same topic and add your opinion? Such practices are generally frowned upon. However, if you do decide to go through these older threads, I encourage you to READ first, get an idea of why individuals prefer one to the other. Keep an open mind, there is a lot to be learned - about the knives, the makers, and even the physics relevant to the subject.

Have fun and enjoy your time ;)
 
chiral has the best advice for this situation. Most of us have a wide variety of knives to use and test, either owned and or borrowed so we have a good idea of their strengths and weaknesses.

I have Becker, ESEE, Swamp Rat, and Busse, and I love them all in spite of it all, :) :p
 
baddestblade#1 said:
so what you are saying is that a becker bk7 will not do what a swamp rat will i beg to differ bud the beckers are the best knives ever made and they are made to beat the snot out of just my personal preference why spend three hundred dollars when i can spend 80 on my bk7 and it will do the same thing.
Click to expand...
.....I don't think ANYONE has said the Beckers wont handle a beating, just as well as the Swampys perhaps.... can't say agree that the Beckers are "the best" knife ever made as the criteria used to decide such a glorious title has yet to be spelt out. Needless to say *I* own many more Busse/Swampy/Scrapper blades than any other brand, that said I would happily go bush (I do this with some regularity) with only a Becker and not be in fear of my life as a result, I just prefer something different to you my friend. Like blondes v redheads v well....you get the idea... :D
 
Badblade. Try a swamp rat sometime, then give a follow up. You live fairly close, I live just outside New Orleans. If you are ever in the area I have a few you can use.

Also on a side note. Try a period or comma every now and then. It makes reading threads much easier.
 
Last edited:
We're running awfully close to some cross-manufacturer bashing. Swamp Rat et al, stands on their own merit without the need to do comparisons to other manufacturers. If you want to continue discussing Becker, it would best be served in the Becker subforum or in general. It would be no more appropriate to go to the Becker forum and laud that Busse being the best blades ever. As knife knuts, we are fortunate to have a large enough consumer market to support a number of different manufacturers with their own respective merits and design features.

Keep it civil, please. This will be the only warning. :)
 
Hey gravel face i appreciate the invite that would really be nice i have never handled a swamp rat before.And to be honest i would love to have one it just seems like they are impossible to get.IF you have any info on how I could get one please let me know and sorry about throwing becker into this forum i have to learn how to work bladeforums a lil better lol.All the best baddestblade#1
 
baddestblade#1 said:
Hey gravel face i appreciate the invite that would really be nice i have never handled a swamp rat before.And to be honest i would love to have one it just seems like they are impossible to get.IF you have any info on how I could get one please let me know and sorry about throwing becker into this forum i have to learn how to work bladeforums a lil better lol.All the best baddestblade#1
Click to expand...

Mate,

For Swamp Rat knives: http://www.swampratknifeworks.com/
For Scrap Yard knives (sister company, same quality different handle & designs): http://www.scrapyardknives.com/intro.htm
For Busse (the parent company, different steel and much higher prices): http://www.bussecombat.com/home/index.shtml

The business model is way different than your average knife producers, first there is announcement, then you place your order (you get to choose blade finish, handle material) and then you wait. You could say that those are semi-custom knives.

Secondary market: http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/forumdisplay.php/804-Busse-Swamprat-Scrapyard-Knives-For-Sale and the popular auction site.

Take your time, read up, learn, and after that start expressing your opinions...

And as Gravelface said, you should work on your punctuation...
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top