SquarePeg (and to all that contributed), OUTSTANDING information here!
Thank you guys very much. I'll put all this wisdom to good use.
Full disclosure; Lifetime Hudsons Bay fan. I agree that the smaller eye contact area is a disadvantage in an absolute durability test, however, when it comes to limbing and general camp chores including small firewood, kindling, shaping poles and pegs etc. I love using the hudsons bay. I find it light enough to swing one handed easily while still able to buck up 8" green timber. I like being able to choke up on the handle and make use of the bearded blade for shaving, shaping and as an assist in peeling the bark off a cedar. I've only ever had one handle fail on me and it broke do to grain run out several inches below the head after years of use. That said I would not recommend it for serious splitting or felling. It's more my "jack-of-all-trades" axe that's small enough to find it's was into my camping kit and the tool kit of my vehicle.
Also, and I know this is a very specific situation, a sharp Hudsons Bay will go through a young red alder grove like the Reaper Mans scythe .
edit: Hey Peg, I think I have that very Collins you've pictured.
Alocksly,
THAT is exactly the extent of my use with a camp axe, except that I'll have to add splitting to that list of chores. I won't split anything more than 8" though. That shouldn't affect a 3# (total weight, head & handle) Hudson Bay. I don't like it for chopping. That I'd leave to my Council Tool Forest Service Edition Boy's Axe for sure and even then, only when a folding saw like a Bahco Laplander wouldn't suffice.
I'm going to do my best to make my Norlund Tomahawk Hudson Bay Axe "right", but I'm also looking at picking up a Council Tool Hudson Bay and their Velvicut Hudson Bay along with an American-made modern Snow & Nealley Hudson Bay. I really like the forward weight of my Norlund compared to the 2 Wetterling Forester's Fine Axes I had. For camp chores like making kindling and minor chopping (stakes, woodcrafting, etc..), it's the best I've used. I had no problem splitting with mine. The head didn't come loose until I began chopping into a 6" log.
I like the Hudson Bay pattern for all the reasons you listed. As long as we use axes for what they were designed for, we'll have less issues. I'm seriously seeing a 3 axe combo: A hatchet (<18"), the Hudson Bay and the Boy's Axe for camping depending on what I'd need at the time. I'd leave the feller and the maul for homestead use.
But personally, I'm staying away from the Swedes at all costs. They might make some premium carving axes, but I've had nothing but trouble with them. User error? No. I got them bad from the factory while my $60 Boy's Axe from Council Tool came hung right, hung tight and ready to work and hasn't ever disappointed me. But that's another thread.