Also Segal was doing ALOT of non Aikido. Clotheslining someone isnt Aikido. Just like in his movies when hes breaking limbs left and right, thats doing Aikido WRONG. I know people will argue with me about that, but its supposed to be about redirection like Daizee said, not breaking limbs. Also keep in mind, that test is alot like board breaking. Your "Opponents" are often working to help you pass the test. If you watch it closely, none of those guys are trying to do anything but charge him. At one point he literally just pushes one guy backwards and the guy stands there, and lets him turn around looking for other people. Its pretty silly.
Well......Your mostly correct Thorny. I studied Aikido for 8 years, and while you are correct about the "clotheslining" there is a technique in aikido that your probably mistaken for that. Unfortunately the name of the technique escapes me, (its been a while) but, it utilizes the opponents wieght and momentum (duh) and the bicep area of the arm is used under the opponents chin in a upward motion. This does a couple of different things. As the opponents weight and momentum is going forward, the change of dirrection of there head changes the direction of the body. Morihei Ueshiba (founder of aikido was a very small dude) his theory was where the head goes, the body follows, and in this case it was in the reverse motion of the opponent and lovingly placing it into the ground.
I do agree about your other coments. Aikido takes years to master. and Hollywood has ruined really what it all about. I watched the video that WW posted, and the one comment that one guy made about he would rather be in a street fight situation before being in his Dojo is just a bullsh!t sales pitch. In the Dojo is a controlled environment with people that are trained how to fall, Thats right trained how to fall. A good school will work for months with students just to train them on how to hit the matt as to not get injured. In the video, those students are basically standing in line to get thrown. While I have huge respect for the art, it is not that easy.
I spent a couple of years in my younger days making some extra cash by bouncing at a few different establisments. Got a few scars to prove it. Id much rather go up against my buddies in a padded room that dont want to kill me and know the techniques oppossed to 3 drunks with broken beer bottles that are trying to take my head off anyday.
Martial arts are like cars. Its all personal prefference. Even the bad ones can teach you something about defense, and thats really what its about is keeping yourself safe. Crap about technique and fair fight to me is just that, Its the guy that goes home is the winner. I found in my younger years the all martial arts worked a hell of a lot better on a guy that is unconscience. So if you have to hit him in the face with a brick first to "loosen him up a bit" so be it.
I got a bad rap in college once. A golden glove boxer picked a fight with me, Hell, I thought it would be pretty dumb to fight him, he would kick my ass. So while he was trash talking me to his buddies I picked up a telephone and smoked him in the mouth with it. Fight was over, and I went home with my teeth, and he never bothered me again. thank God.