The stockman punch thread

Blake the Blade said:
Yes I did Graham. Not allowed to mention the supplier but there are only two that stock Rough Rider and Colt in UK to my knowledge, and I think it fair to say it was the smaller of the two. Put it this way, I'm over the MOON with it, and that's not just a clue but, also, the truth. Not a lot of money either, for something of good quality with nice bone/stag scales. I did a fuller review on the Rough Rider and related slip joints thread. Best of luck mate. 👍
Click to expand...

Looks like a very useful pattern!
 
That Case Carhartt also has the distinction of being the only relatively recent punch model with all tru-sharp steel(stainless) blades, iirc.
Thanks, Neal
 
neal70 said:
That Case Carhartt also has the distinction of being the only relatively recent punch model with all tru-sharp steel(stainless) blades, iirc.
Thanks, Neal
Click to expand...
Yup, and the blades have the 'as-ground' finish. At least I think that's what they call it. One of my favorite Stockman patterns.

Sent from my SM-T350 using Tapatalk
 
traumkommode said:
Rookie, how's the F&F on this run of stockmans? I'm eyeballing the black horn.
Click to expand...

I just got it out and looked at it again before writing this. I wanted to give a thorough review of it before responding.

The front side handles are nice and tight all around. The back side handle has a hairline gap near 1 of the bolsters. On the spine, there is a hair gap between the liner and the 1st spring. Finish is very nice all around. Main blade has a tough pull, probably 7.5, very strong snap open and closed, no wobbles or play, and is centered in it's slot when closed. 2nd blade and punch are both a little easier to pull, probably 6.5, and have strong snap both open and closed. Pins on front and back are fit really tight, and are perfectly flush with the horn. There are no blemishes or scratches on any of the bolsters, springs, or blades. The main blade grinds are pretty even up until the last 1/4 inch before the tip, then they are slightly uneven. For a Queen made knife, I think you could say the blade is actually sharp. Usually Queen knives come "dull" from the factory. Secondary blade has even grinds the full blade length, and the blade is not very sharp. The punch is very sharp, although the grinds are a tad sloppy if you hold it to the light just right. Seems like there are 3 different grind angles on it. The tube and CoA are both in pristine condition.

I like it, I think it's a nice knife for the cost, especially for the limited 25 pieces they make in horn. The Tuna website has a typo and says they made 50 of these, but I confirmed it with Queen, that only 25 were made.

I think that about covers it. Let me know if I missed something or if you have any other questions about it.
 
After seeing that buck 319 again, I'm really wanting one. Something about that spiral punch calls to me. And OH-that Camillus made Western is still just interesting as all heck. I wonder what Charlie would know about that punch, it's almost like a sailing awl, with no eye. Cool stuff.
Thanks, Neal
 
Rookie82 said:
I just got it out and looked at it again before writing this. I wanted to give a thorough review of it before responding.

The front side handles are nice and tight all around. The back side handle has a hairline gap near 1 of the bolsters. On the spine, there is a hair gap between the liner and the 1st spring. Finish is very nice all around. Main blade has a tough pull, probably 7.5, very strong snap open and closed, no wobbles or play, and is centered in it's slot when closed. 2nd blade and punch are both a little easier to pull, probably 6.5, and have strong snap both open and closed. Pins on front and back are fit really tight, and are perfectly flush with the horn. There are no blemishes or scratches on any of the bolsters, springs, or blades. The main blade grinds are pretty even up until the last 1/4 inch before the tip, then they are slightly uneven. For a Queen made knife, I think you could say the blade is actually sharp. Usually Queen knives come "dull" from the factory. Secondary blade has even grinds the full blade length, and the blade is not very sharp. The punch is very sharp, although the grinds are a tad sloppy if you hold it to the light just right. Seems like there are 3 different grind angles on it. The tube and CoA are both in pristine condition.

I like it, I think it's a nice knife for the cost, especially for the limited 25 pieces they make in horn. The Tuna website has a typo and says they made 50 of these, but I confirmed it with Queen, that only 25 were made.

I think that about covers it. Let me know if I missed something or if you have any other questions about it.
Click to expand...

Thanks man. This is very informative, precisely what I was looking for.
 
I have a few, but this is not all inclusive. Very useful combination. The 4 blade wards is particularly handy to have.

330906x.jpg


fxypl1.jpg


2u58b9i.jpg
 
Ah man!!^^^tell me more about that 4 blade. The blade combo and punch is perfect. I must have one!
 
Good idea for a thread Rishma, and great to see all the knives posted here.

The Schrade 36OT Saddleman is just a superb knife - in fact it's probably close to my ideal three blade configuration.

I lucked into this knife late last year, and it was one of the top three contenders for my Knife of the Year.

One thing I've found the punch really useful for, is for working an oiled piece of cotton wool in the blade channel of my other slippies, when doing a bit of maintenance and cleaning.

I wish they'd make more stockmans in this configuration.

IMG_0935.JPG
 
Last edited:
^yep, 36OT is probably my favorite too. Perfect size and blade combo. I will get a usa made carbon steel version....eventually
 
neal70 said:
That Case Carhartt also has the distinction of being the only relatively recent punch model with all tru-sharp steel(stainless) blades, iirc.
Click to expand...

I'm still crossing my fingers that Case will do the same Stockman with different covers in a non-Carhartt version. It worked for the "Traplifter," a knife I very much wanted to see in stainless, so maybe it will work for this pattern as well. :D
 
Agree with the OP premise 100%. I have found this to be the perfect complement of blades for my life. On the one hand I am sorry it isn't offered more in current production. On the other hand I am thankful, or I would be spending more on knives.
 
rishma said:
Ah man!!^^^tell me more about that 4 blade. The blade combo and punch is perfect. I must have one!
Click to expand...

Thanks. It's a wards, not sure who made it maybe utica. I think its post ww2. The spey blade was poorly reshaped into a pen when I got it but I fixed it up better. Not the best fit & finish, but the blades are nice and thin so it's a very versatile razor blade. I would highly recommend a 4 blade if you come across one of any kind since you seem to like the versatility of stockmans.
 
Chin-that's one heckuva punch on that 36OT! I certainly have done the same thing with punches too. The forum knife is particularly adept at this, with the needle like awl it has. More uses everyday!
Thanks, Neal
 
TheChunk91 said:
Thanks. It's a wards, not sure who made it maybe utica. I think its post ww2. The spey blade was poorly reshaped into a pen when I got it but I fixed it up better. Not the best fit & finish, but the blades are nice and thin so it's a very versatile razor blade. I would highly recommend a 4 blade if you come across one of any kind since you seem to like the versatility of stockmans.
Click to expand...

Indeed!
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top