Tips on selling knives?

Let say I make a knife for someone and they decline or disappear. It happens.

If I can't sell the knife fairly quick, it is my fault, not the guy who ordered it.

BTW, you can't run fast enough to give me a deposit on an order. :D

Sounds like a good solid business plan to me. Maybe yes, maybe no, but it is also the way I look at things.

I don't plan on leaving this world a rich man, but I do plan on leaving knowing I have trusted my fellow man as much as he will allow.

Robert
 
You will do great my friend..
I like your attitude.
We are looking for another guy in the shop right now, if you ever decide to make a move
We just set up a new work area outside with two grinders and I need someone who is willing to really work hard..
Base pay will cover your expenses, rent, etc.. and then you can also make your own knives on the weekends with the support of my full shop.
We will help you sell your knives and introduce you to the key players in the game while promoting your product line.. I just need someone who is tough and wants to be successful.
Thanks for showing me some respect..
Get at me anytime..

[youtube]xscMxspOuZE[/youtube]

If you are still looking for someone to work in your shop then I am interested. I am actually from Texas, and I am in West Texas right now in need of a job. I have alot of experience with grinding and polishing, and cutting metal, metal fabrication, but I have never made a knife before. I am a hard worker and willing to learn. I could be anywhere in Texas in less than 5 days ready to start.

Thanks, William
 
As I already pointed out, the level of reading comprehension among the folks who keep trying to "summarize" my posts is beyond poor. At no time did I demean Jerry Fisk. How is saying that he operates on a DIFFERENT ethical model than SOME others in any way demeaning? You are reading things into my statements which simply are not there, I'm sorry to say. If you want to turn my posts into something hostile, feel free to, but understand that you've completely misrepresented what I said. It's almost as though several of you actually WANT to think that I'm insulting everyone.

Tell me this, how is Fisk NOT operating on a different ethical model than some other people we've discussed in this thread, such as myself, Kyley and any other individual who said that they actually tend to work faster when someone has given them a small good faith deposit? Did anyone even bother to address any of the major points I brought up, or did you stop reading when you decided you wanted to get insulted for Fisk, despite the fact that nobody ever insulted him?

Also, for once in your lives, address the logical fallacies I've brought up time and time again, because they're getting way out of hand.
 
Just like you didn't mean to single out another maker and tell the whole forum how much better Kyley's knives were, right?

You sure operate on a "different" model of proper forum conduct.

Get it? ;)

Nah, probably not.

Roger
 
Hi Minds,

Who are you? How about your real name and a link to your website, youtube videos, etc. I for one would like to take a look at your work.

I think it is the word "ethical" that is throwing me and you using it with regards to Jerry Fisk. I agree that ethical and Jerry Fisk belong in the same sentence.

Tips for selling custom knives....Jerry address's that in his book. Perhaps you read it.

Ive only been working with Jerry since the early 1990's and the word deposit or pre-payment for anything never came up. That seems fairly ethical to me. I suspect part of that is due to his business acumen. Jerry is the second best businessman in custom knives I know :D. The other part is probably that Jerry has had a very busy schedule in the last 15 or so years which in some part may have made him hesitant to take money.

Specifically being the absolute best Ambassador the ABS has ever had. Jerry literally traveled the world teaching makers how to make knives. Not youtube videos..in person, on the ground...up close and personal. As well the countless events here in the US he attended doing the same thing. Jerry is a full time plus maker. He does so much more than just make knives.

As you can see that is the issue I have with your use of the word ethical.

Again, I for one and Im sure some others look forward to finding out who you are and a look at some of your knives.
 
As I already pointed out, the level of reading comprehension among the folks who keep trying to "summarize" my posts is beyond poor. At no time did I demean Jerry Fisk. How is saying that he operates on a DIFFERENT ethical model than SOME others in any way demeaning? You are reading things into my statements which simply are not there, I'm sorry to say. If you want to turn my posts into something hostile, feel free to, but understand that you've completely misrepresented what I said. It's almost as though several of you actually WANT to think that I'm insulting everyone.

Tell me this, how is Fisk NOT operating on a different ethical model than some other people we've discussed in this thread, such as myself, Kyley and any other individual who said that they actually tend to work faster when someone has given them a small good faith deposit? Did anyone even bother to address any of the major points I brought up, or did you stop reading when you decided you wanted to get insulted for Fisk, despite the fact that nobody ever insulted him?

Also, for once in your lives, address the logical fallacies I've brought up time and time again, because they're getting way out of hand.

The less one knows, the longer the explanation.
 
What advice would you offer to a new maker who is trying to carve out some success?


Please offer "words of wisdom" and insights into the business of selling knives, helpful tips and/or pitfalls to avoid- esp. from the veterans among us.. For the benefit of new makers.

Many thanks,
David

Hi folks,
I am not knifemaker, so might be my post just another garbage in.
After read many posts and based on my experienced, i would like to say something from low budget consumer perspective. So my post basically on how to treat the consumers.
BTW, i am Anton Nurcahyo from developing countries who have monthly salary less than a price of let say a simplest work of famous knifemaker in this forum. So, my words will only apply for knifemaker who produce knives that affordable for people like me.
Bear in your mind that i have shortcoming in English, and i have no intention to insulting someone here. But, it might be happen due to my lack of language skills (and i ask apology if its happen). I raise this language issue because of several reasons. In my country, there are several languages, even in some cases certain languages have many dialects, each dialect generally understood by other people who have different dialects but in certain areas the dialect have tendency to have higher tone and might be bit sarcastic for other regions. Its not only orally but also in writing.
I think it also happen in English language. At the moment, I am running program where many people come to visit and work with us, people from Eastern Europe, Northern Europe, US, Canada, UK, Australia. Many of them English is not their mother tongue, we have experienced in culture shock and difficulties to communicate. Even, my friends who have English as mother tongue told me that sometime they found difficulties to understand other people from area where English is the first language not only because of the personal character but also because of the cultures, idioms etc.
So, my dear knifemakers:
1. Put us, the consumer as civilized human, treat us nicely, you will gain what you paid.
Knifemakers might be busy working with the orders, but nice words will make us respect the makers. BF is kind of melting pot of knifenuts, many people from many-many countries are lurking here or be member of this lovely forum. So, for sure, many people from different countries and different cultures will meet in this forum, challenge in communication then will be appear. In this case wording then important. I realized, in this forum so many people know each other personally, especially who live in the US. What i love from BF is this things!!, brotherhood. But, as i already mentioned that many people from almost every corners of the earth who love knives are lurking and became member of this forum, we might be not have idea about someone who contact the maker. If the one who contact the maker is one of very active in this forum and well known by most respective people in this forum, when the maker got an order from those guys, they might be no need to worry about the order even not asking the deposit which might be applied for lesser known people or let say nobody in this world. But, it is normal if i contact a maker then the maker have big question, WHO THE HELL IS anton? Since i am not come from maker comfortable zone area. I come from developing countries, lack of fund not even best friend of one of famous people in this forum.
I always keep telling my wife that man who have hobby on knives mostly family man, trusted people, and respect each other. I said like that to my wife because of what i have seen in this lovely forum, base on what i have read in their posts (but sometime i felt that i did mistake LoL, but i do understand that we are just normal human being).
2. Be transparent, if the knifemakers want to have deposit or something to say please said so.
Many reasons of deposit issue came up in this thread, pros and cons. I don't mind to pay the deposit. This culture of asking deposit is not applied only in certain countries. As already mentioned that i have limited fund, so far i only purchased from 6 knifemakers of BF member. But, i have sent emails to Southern and Northern Hemisphere as well, even i have used google translate to translate my email to Russian to communicate with a knifemaker who only speak in Russian. A couple of the knifemakers asked me deposit, i gave them what they want. The rest are not asking deposit but doing my order. But I guess because of he trusted me since i have been purchased his knife in Knife Sale area. If i did not ask for deposit, i used to keep the money intended for the order safely, will not use it for something else. Just simple thing, you trust me, i trust you, it is the rule of the game. But i understand that some of knifemakers ask for deposit, since i am nobody.
3. Be honest and responsible, or you will have no future in knife business.
I have been asked for full payment by one of maker in my country. I paid fully. He have account in facebook, he was friend of most people in our country knife forum. But my order NEVER come to my door. He death!!!! None of the people in our country believe to him anymore, he became nobody in our country forum. It happened before i made order to knifemakers in this forum, base on one single experienced will not let me to judge that all of the knifemakers are bad guy. So i still have faith that man who love blades are trustworthy people. I am trying to think positively. I got words from my brother inlaw, he said that if someone took your money by cheating on you, you will get more and the one who took your money will end up in a pile of shit in the hell. I do belief in good karma.
Its also apply for the material that you mentioned to the consumers, give what you already promised to them.
If you don't believe to the system in the consumer's country that the knife will not safely arrive just said so. Don't refuse the order with different reason, don't say that you have so many orders to be accomplished. A person that contact you may lead you to good future in your business, don't let them down. In the past, I have been discussed with some fellows before i purchase one of knife in sale area in this forum, one of my friend told me (base on his experience) that the guy have sent knives with poor fit and finish, but i am thinking positively and my knife from him came to my place in a good condition, much-much better than my friend said to me. Words are spreading among potential buyers, beware of your products and the way of you communicate with people.
4. Tips, i have experienced of receiving rusty knives resulted from long period of shipping and because of on how the makers did the packing. I tell to the makers and then second purchase was in better condition. In this case i did not fed up and judge that he did not work professionally, he just lack of ideas about the rest of the world. So, please bear in your mind that some countries have different climate and might be need more time to arrive to the destination. Prepare your shipping properly.

So sorry for my bad English, i have no intention to hurt someone feeling.

Respects,
Anton
this is my longest post ever in this forum
 
Last edited:
Anton, some people pay thousands of dollars to earn a marketing degree to learn what you just said.

1. Put us, the consumer as civilized human, treat us nicely, you will gain what you paid.
2. Be transparent
3. Be honest and responsible, or you will have no future in knife business.

[or any other business for that matter]

It all comes down to what you mentioned wether you do or do not take deposits.
 
Anton, I've seen plenty of people who were born in the same state in the same country as I was who mangle English into something barely comprehensible. You write quite clearly, and more importantly you make good points. :thumbup:
 
In my opinion, if a knifemaker feels he/she needs to require a deposit to reduce their risk it's nothing wrong with that.

If collectors (including myself) are against paying deposits, then just purchase knives from those knifemakers who don't require them .
Trent concurs
It's a private decision between the buyer and seller....

I'm interested on how the consumer changes his behavior with required deposits:confused:
I would think, in general, it narrows your overall buyer market?
The whole time value of money thing
You could be MAKING money, NOW, off the 200 dollar deposit for the knife with a 10 month waiting list
To understand how middlemen behave in such markets, we model one such
middleman's dynamic profit maximization exercise. When customers, also called
importers, come to the middleman they announce a price-quantity offer to buy or sell.

Given the offer the middleman either agrees or refuses to trade. There are two factors that
effect the middleman's decision. First the middleman must find it consistent with his
optimal inventory decision. Second the middleman must find the prices attractive enough
to trade at. These two factors imply that there will be a large number of trades that do not
take place and cause inefficiency as compared to a frictionless market.
Do Security Deposit Rates Matter: Evidence
from a Secondary Market


If a maker is HOT
has a HUGE waiting list
I don't think requiring a deposit really hurts sales
The flip side, if you are a new maker===>
A required deposit will drastically hurt your sales/orders
You need time to build a reputation before you should charge a deposit

I'd have no problem paying a deposit to Kyley
He is internet wide known, I have seen his work, I have read testimonials from his customers
If it was some n00by Joe Shankmaker
I'd be really hesitant....

I don't think blanket statements like "you should ONLY pay a deposit under THESE 3 criteria..." applies to real life business transactions
Each transaction has different demand/supply variables and dynamics..IMHO
 
Very good post, Anton!

BTW, getting an order request from Indonesia can raise the hair on the back of one's neck. But Anton is a great guy to deal with. I have sent W2 steel to him and his knife making friend on a couple occasions and all a smooth deal. :)
 
Back
Top