What is your favorite way to open your blades?

What is your favorite way to open your knife?

  • Emerson Wave

    Votes: 11 8.2%
  • Thumb Studs

    Votes: 41 30.6%
  • Spydie Hole

    Votes: 69 51.5%
  • Nail Knick

    Votes: 9 6.7%
  • Flipper

    Votes: 53 39.6%
  • Push button automatic

    Votes: 5 3.7%
  • Automatic Axis

    Votes: 1 0.7%
  • I carry a fixed blade

    Votes: 9 6.7%
  • Thumb Disc

    Votes: 5 3.7%
  • Front Flipper

    Votes: 6 4.5%

  • Total voters
    134
  • Poll closed .
Flipper. The flipper is extremely quick out of pocket, soon as I take my pocket out of knife my finger just naturally lands on the flipper tab, and also have a secure grip on the knife while doing so quickly (unlike many other designs where you have a weak grip on the knife), in my testing it just as fast as an emerson wave, or within 0.25 seconds including having a proper grip on the knife (most time when you have your hand is very car back on the grip and your grip isn't super secure). Also, a properly designed flipper while being fast, is also easy to operate with gloves on, when wet and is a safety feature acting as a forward guard and if the lock fails the flipper tab will hit your finger not just the blade.

I don’t see how a flipper can be as fast as a wave as the wave has the knife open as it comes out of your pocket. The only way I could see a flipper being as fast os if you pressed the flipper and had the knife starting to open before it leaves your pocket.

In some cases I can actually draw a waved knife faster than a fixed blade. This is because I wear my fixed blades iwb so I have to lift my shirt, sweater or jacket out of the way first. On the other hand my waved knife is unobstructed.

Not that speed of draw matters in almost any situation. The only place where it matters is in self defense situation.
 
My favorite is to depress the AXIS lock and flick open. I especially like it because the same method is used for closing. I didn't vote because the poll says "automatic AXIS", and I'm not a fan of AXIS locks with auto or assisted opening, as it eliminates easy one handed closing.

My favorite is also the AXIS, whether using the lock or thumb stud. It's just second nature to me now.
 
Front flipper (Burger type, but not Thorburn version).
Can be opened slowly or quickly, and ambidextrous.
No protrusions sideways.

Front_Flippers.JPG
 
I like slow but smooth blade deployment, and I'm not a huge fan of protrusions on the blade, so I tend to like a thumb-hole myself. That said, I do carry and use knives with thumb-studs, I'm fine with them but I just prefer a hole.
 
Probably need to start another thread asking about favorite way/lock release to close the knife. I voted Spydie hole for opening but for closing I will say I was enjoying the simplicity and the talk of my slip joint today. (not that I didn't enjoy my compression lock today . . . I did.)
 
I stated the same speed or within 0.25 seconds, that is a range. SO it may on average be slightly slower, however the 0.25 or less is the range I gave just to show how small of a different there truly is. I didn't just say when blade was opened, I said when blade was open & your have a proper grip. Look at how you wave a knife? Your fingers are far back on the handle and you need to adjust your grip if you were to do anything with the knife. When you use a flipper, you (or I) don't have that problem. This was just one of the many reasons I prefer a flipper vs other methods. I do agree with how speed isn't important in majority of situations, so why did you focus on a small part of my post? Before responding to my comments, please read carefully so you can at least get what I said correctly.

No need to get argumentative.
I was referring to the part of your post where you said “just as fast as wave.” Then you said or sometimes slightly slower. You mentioned finger position in relation to flipper knives but nothing about finger position when waving a knife.

As to that point, it depends, if you regular wave then the knife comes out in sort of an awkward pinch grip. However if you reverse wave the knife comes out in a much more secure grip where just closing your hand causes it to roll into reverse grip.

I personally find that the position you need to have a knife in your hand to use a flipper or thumb studs or even hit an auto button is a fairly weak grip just like when doing a regulsr wave. This is because in order to have your hand out of the way of the blade path so it can open you can’t take a full grip on the knife.

Anyway there is no right or wrong way or method for opening a knife. Everyone should do whatever works best for them. That was the reason for the thread I thought.
 
My favorite way to open a blade is to grab it and pull it open, I don't like the ergonomics or looks of an EO notch though so I don't mind nail nicks if the blade is easy enough to open.

Properly done thumb studs or disks are fine when I feel like carrying a one handed folder.
 
What I actually said was "in my testing it just as fast as an emerson wave, or within 0.25 seconds including having a proper grip on the knife"... so did you just stop reading mid sentence? I got that data from an experiment i did awhile back, saying the time varied from 0.00 seconds - 0.025 seconds on average, which is very different from what you said clearly from a statistical science perspective, in fact what you said would be incorrect. I do agree that this thread was about what people preferred opening method, which is why you commenting on my posts offer no input to this thread or was useful. You never even said what your preferred method of opening so why bring this up when you're the problem you speak of lmao. My original comment was explain what method I prefer and why, none of your comments have have been about what method your prefer? Just arguing a small point in my original, ironically slightly hypocritical wouldn't you say?
I would assume the times would vary between someone who's practiced waving in the way lapedog mentioned for years vs. someone who hasn't. Hardly empirical...but thats cool, apply your standards to everyone.
 
What I actually said was "in my testing it just as fast as an emerson wave, or within 0.25 seconds including having a proper grip on the knife"... so did you just stop reading mid sentence? I got that data from an experiment i did awhile back, saying the time varied from 0.00 seconds - 0.025 seconds on average, which is very different from what you said clearly from a statistical science perspective, in fact what you said would be incorrect. I do agree that this thread was about what people preferred opening method, which is why you commenting on my posts offer no input to this thread or was useful. You never even said what your preferred method of opening so why bring this up when you're the problem you speak of lmao. Very hypocritical.

Once again, no need to be argumentative or get so emotionally invested in a conversation about personal preferences.

I’m not telling you how it goes for you, which I have no way of knowing. I am only stating how the opening methods work for me. I don’t know why that seems to be such an issue. I never said anything about your findings being invalid that is why I started “I don’t see how” because in my experience I can’t see how. Waving (even reverse waving) is still three steps to firm grip, grab knife, pull knife out (knife opens here), close grip. Flipper is 4 steps. Grab knife (finger can be in position ready to flip), pull out knife, flip knife, close grip. That is why I said I can’t see how flipper can be as fast. You can help me to see what you’re saying without taking it as a personal attack.

If you couldn’t guess my favourite opening method is the wave. Unfortunately I can’t use it often because it isn’t appropriate around most people and eats pants pockets.

So in terms of a method that I find most practical I like front flippers. They allow the knife to be opened fast or slow depending on your environment and company. Thumb studs do too but often obstruct the blade cutting path. Spyderholes too but often make for a very high blade. I also like that front flippers contribute to a minimalist design.

Regular back flipper tabs can be opened slowly too. I hit the flipper and catch the blade with my fingers stopping it before it opens the whole way. Then I put my thumb on the side of the blade and thumb it the rest of the way open.

Of all I dislike nail nicks the most. On traditionals I prefer blades you can pinch open or even better the wave of the traditional knife world, the one armed jack opener.
case-xx-6205-r-one-arm-man.jpg

It works sort of like a wave. You have the knife in your hand and catch the cut out at the end of the blade on something like the seam of your pants and pry the blade open.
 
Out of all the threads over the past week to get nasty, I wouldn’t have picked this one!

For me, it’s the middle finger in the hole. Just hate when I can’t quite get it in like on the Slysz Bowie...
 
Since most of my knives have thumb studs, I'm gonna say thumb studs. As long as I can get it open, it really doesn't matter what's on the blade to help make it open.
I will say this, if you carry a flipper and a knife that has thumb studs, if you're not paying attention, you look silly trying to flip open a knife with thumb studs. :eek:
Ask me how I know :D
 
Out of all the threads over the past week to get nasty, I wouldn’t have picked this one!

For me, it’s the middle finger in the hole. Just hate when I can’t quite get it in like on the Slysz Bowie...

Me either, I hope this thread doesn’t get shut down.
 
Back
Top