Yea... sorry Matt! This thread was so consuming that I ended up just walking away from the computer for awhile because it was killing too much time.
As far as block size---- somewhere along the line 1.5" X 1" X 5" became the magical size that everybody decided knifemakers wanted. Unfortunately, 90% of the designs I come up with won't fit on that size of a block. Many of them can be squeezed onto a 1-3/4" wide block, but if I have my pick, I prefer 2"
width so I can do a lot of drop/curve in the handle along with the sculpting stuff. 1"
thick works just fine for me to get all that stuff in. This particular block of Koa was something like 1-5/8" thick, so there was a L-----O-----T of Koa dust coming off the 36 grit belt!!!

Edited to add: And at least 5" long... but preferably 6" so I can place the handle where I want it on the rough block.
As per the design process--- it was sort of "crazy mountain bike guy meets snooty knife maker."
Lorien sent me the pattern he had envisioned. I was torn at first because I liked the feel of the pattern, but it just didn't look like "my stuff." Once you dink around with this stuff for awhile, you come up with processes in the shop as well as a personal preference for line and feel. Now I know a lot of guys say (and I'm sure I have at one point or another) that their techniques help to achieve their style. For me, I realized it was what I was after for line and feel, that ultimately shaped my techniques. (and I actually think this is true for most other folks as well).
So when I saw his pattern, it wasn't that I thought, "Well, shoot, I can't make a knife the way I normally do and come up with that in the end." I looked at it and just felt like it wasn't what my eye would ultimately want to be seeing in the end. Or quite what I would want to sign my name onto for
the life of the knife. So I sat down with the paper and pencil, just like in the first photos in this thread, and drew up a design based off of Lorien's pattern for what I felt would look like "my stuff"
and feel good in the hand.
Luckily, Lorien realized what a pretentious boob I am, and ultimately let me make it the way I drew it.
