Would you buy this?

Sharp & Fiery said:
I would pass too, just based on the lanyard hole position.
Click to expand...

I also think the lanyard hole position is awkward, and don't like the gigantic hex bolt head on the pivot. Also wondering of the blade couldn't be a little bit longer.

That's all expensive knife details, though.

I mean if that thing was $20 at a gas station and made of cheap materials it would definitely sell like hotcakes as-is!
 
Bigfattyt said:
I like it. I've owned cheap kershaw needs work, and enjoyed the design.

I don't typically use a lanyard on clipped folders. So the position of the lanyard hole is not offputting to me at all.

I had a period where I was on a no liner lock kick, but then I had a few well designed liner locks with great/ solid lock up.

A partially concealed/covered frame lock seems like a nifty feature. It would be a built in over travel limiter, I believe.

I say, run with the design.
Click to expand...

Thank you! My knife designs have a lock bar insert with over travel protection anyways but you're right the inserts would serve that purpose too!
 
Mecha said:
I also think the lanyard hole position is awkward, and don't like the gigantic hex bolt head on the pivot. Also wondering of the blade couldn't be a little bit longer.

That's all expensive knife details, though.

I mean if that thing was $20 at a gas station and made of cheap materials it would definitely sell like hotcakes as-is!
Click to expand...

I've managed to move the lanyard hole to the butt of the knife. Multiple people at Blade including Nick Shabazz complimented the hex pivot on my other knives due to it's uniqueness. Way the internals and clip etc sit, no room to increase blade length. Appreciate the feedback, not so much the comparison to a gas station knife.
 
Damneddesigns said:
I've managed to move the lanyard hole to the butt of the knife. Multiple people at Blade including Nick Shabazz complimented the hex pivot on my other knives due to it's uniqueness. Way the internals and clip etc sit, no room to increase blade length. Appreciate the feedback, not so much the comparison to a gas station knife.
Click to expand...

By "gas station knife" I meant inexpensive knife. To clarify, I think that based on the design, a cheap/affordable version would sell like crazy, but an expensive version would be a harder sell.

Not sure why the hex pivot head was seen as unique, as that is what the most common of bolts look like. When I see it, all I see is an automotive or machine bolt head, proportionally large to the thing being bolted.

Another thing: if there was a big emoji "meh" face with a black eye on the knife, I would DEFINITELY not buy it, and that is without even considering that it looks like a direct ripoff of those infamous single-finger knucks with the two black eyes and a frown face.
 
Mecha said:
By "gas station knife" I meant inexpensive knife. To clarify, I think that based on the design, a cheap/affordable version would sell like crazy, but an expensive version would be a harder sell.

Not sure why the hex pivot head was seen as unique, as that is what the most common of bolts look like. When I see it, all I see is an automotive or machine bolt head, proportionally large to the thing being bolted.

Another thing: if there was a big emoji "meh" face with a black eye on the knife, I would DEFINITELY not buy it, and that is without even considering that it looks like a direct ripoff of those infamous single-finger knucks with the two black eyes and a frown face.
Click to expand...

I hope you're just trolling and not serious
 
Last edited:
Damneddesigns said:
Direct rip off of a logo that's seems like it's ripped off from a Nirvana album cover or an Emoji? I hope you're just trolling and not serious
Click to expand...

So far this thread has helped you. :) Watch your responses, so it doesnt turn into a crapshow like the last one. :) Just friendly advice. So far you have shown growth in your character and your designs. :)
Keep your eye on the target.
 
Damneddesigns said:
Direct rip off of a logo that's seems like it's ripped off from a Nirvana album cover or an Emoji? I hope you're just trolling and not serious
Click to expand...

The context is the world of knives / EDC stuff, and in that arena the single-finger knuck guy has clearly established dominance with his double black eye and frown face emoji. Nobody will ever look at the one in your avatar without thinking of the single finger knucks made by the other guy. It's like trying to start a car company with a big "H" as a logo. Sorry, but that's a Honda.
 
I do agree with Mecha Mecha . Im not a fan of the emoji. But to each their own. If you like it, you do it.
I personally would not buy this based on a number of things, mainly the lanyard hole (which has been moved). :)
I dislike flipper tabs, and I think it is very similar to a ZT. But that doesnt mean I wont help you out with design features that will sell to the hundreds of guys who still like this style of knives.
Trying to keep it civil and helpful.
I hope this view can be respected.

ETA: im not here to “make fun” of your knife, but to help with options that you ultimately will decide on.
FYI: also, i am NOT accusing anyone in this thread for “making fun” of this knife. I think everyone has been very respectful with their opinion.
 
Sharp & Fiery said:
I do agree with Mecha Mecha . Im not a fan of the emoji. But to each their own. If you like it, you do it.
I personally would not buy this based on a number of things, mainly the lanyard hole (which has been moved). :)
I dislike flipper tabs, and I think it is very similar to a ZT. But that doesnt mean I wont help you out with design features that will sell to the hundreds of guys who still like this style of knives.
Trying to keep it civil and helpful.
I hope this view can be respected.
Click to expand...

My products have an XO logo with or without an underline, pretty simplistic imo. It's subjective and I appreciate the different opinions on it. Thanks for stepping in.
 
Damneddesigns said:
You're absolutely right, Thank you!
Click to expand...


I'm just tryin' to help you out here. Take a look at these, and realize that these have been around, all over the place, for a while now:

cALhmPH.jpg


A63ZHNN.jpg


SBpgFej.jpg


iVO80ld.jpg


9eklxQG.jpg




Even if it wasn't imagery that is already so recognizable as Andy Frankart's stuff, I think the big emoji face on that knife would be a major turnoff towards buying it.
 
Mecha said:
I'm just tryin' to help you out here. Take a look at these, and realize that these have been around, all over the place, for a while now:

cALhmPH.jpg


A63ZHNN.jpg


SBpgFej.jpg


iVO80ld.jpg


9eklxQG.jpg




Even if it wasn't imagery that is already so recognizable as Andy Frankart's stuff, I think the big emoji face on that knife would be a major turnoff towards buying it.
Click to expand...

I appreciate the feedback. Here’s what my logo looks like. While I’m sure it’s not everyone’s cup of tea, on product it’s not similar to AFK imho. Off product I see similarities cause they’re both emojis sure.

Not disagreeing with what you’re saying but can’t change it so let’s move on from the logo conversation.

341EF664-6EE2-4762-BC4D-BF558C270FED.jpeg
2131909D-3945-4D11-B9E5-B2C1AFF7150B.jpeg
 
Damneddesigns said:
I appreciate the feedback. Here’s what my logo looks like. While I’m sure it’s not everyone’s cup of tea, on product it’s not similar to AFK imho. Off product I see similarities cause they’re both emojis sure.

Not disagreeing with what you’re saying but can’t change it so let’s move on from the logo conversation.

View attachment 1247468
View attachment 1247470
Click to expand...


Well that's not so bad! :)
 
Nope. Not even if I had the funds or it was free.
Not the kind of knife I like. I'd never use it or carry it.
I'd be ashamed to be seen with something like that on me.
Just looking at it hurt my eyes. :(

(Which means there is one more available for those of you who would or will buy one.:) )
 
I like the design. I agree with others about moving the lanyard hole even though I don't really use them myself.
That handle definitely reminds me of a sinkevich zt.
What would the blade steel be?
Price?
Country of manufacturing?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top