Any SURVIVOR!s have any experience with a Buck Vantage? I'm looking for something cheap with a manual flipper.
I have owned 3 large and two mini Vantages.
The larges included a G10-scaled 420HC-bladed vantage that is currently at Buck for warranty work (I need to call and make sure it's coming back

) Blade was centered but the grind was uneven and there was a rattle from the cuff being loose in the spine. The blade finish is "machine" meaning obvious grind-markers - not polished or anything like that - which i think is standard on their 420HC economy models. Edge was nice and sharp. The G10 scales and full liners make it rather heavy...
This one is the 13C26 Avid model. Lock-up is a little farther on this one, with a hard flick i can get it to touch the far liner. Lock-up on Buck Vantages seem to be hit-or-miss, regardless of select/avid/pro, probably true for the Vantage Force series as well. The blade finish was a bit nicer on this 13C26 blade, whoever did the grinding seemed to be paying closer attention?
I also had an avid with 420HC blade and the charcoal dymondwood scales. I MUCH prefer the dymondwood to the G10. It is slicker for easy in/out of the pocket and also noticeably lighter (though I haven't confirmed this on a scale). I ended up selling this one unfortunately... beautiful scales it had, nice lock-up and blade centering, good action:
https://picasaweb.google.com/109675974399787025312/Sale#6066898326782974738
The large vantage rests nicely in the hand, carries well in the pocket:
The mini was too small for me but might make a good EDC for someone else, much like the Spyderco Dragonfly2. The two I've owned were both sold to colleagues who love them. The paperstone one shown here is actually less comfortable for me than the Select which has more rounded scales
https://picasaweb.google.com/109675974399787025312/Sale#6066899125077545810
One thing i didn't like is the open-back design, so I contacted Buck and they sent me a back-spacer for a Vantage Force! I've heard that the newer Vantages are riveted-construction rather than screwed together, so you might not be able to do this with a newer one:
Anyway, sorry for the dearth of pics. My summation of the Vantages is that:
1) The QC is hit-or-miss - you might get decent lock-up or you might not, the grind may be even or WAY off, centering may be alright or not, etc.
2) I'm not a fan of the G10, I prefer the plastic or dymondwood:thumbup: scales, and I also prefer a back-spacer.
3) it carries very discreetly :thumbup:
4) Flipping action was great on 4 of the 5 I've had, one of the mini's just wouldn't flip without being too loose and uncentered, but those suffer from such short thick blades it isn't easy for them to flip. All of the larges have been fine flippers.
5) thumb-hole doesn't work too well - it works, just not well.
6) there are better USA-made liner-locks and flippers available for the money... For example, a number of Kershaw's flippers can be de-assisted (e.g.
Link, though Kai is not a USA company, the knives are USA-made).
7) I am happy with the dymondwood Vantage :thumbup: inexpensive, pretty, easy to carry, flips great :thumbup: Someday i may try a Kershaw Link or step it up to the higher-end flippers, but for now I am happy with this and i really don't much like liner-locks anyway
