Most of what can be said on this subject has already been argued by one side or the other; but while I may just be hauling more coal to Newcastle, I can't help but comment on this thread.
I haven't had any direct dealings with MS or Bark River for a couple of years. I used to be a distributor of them, but haven't dealt any in a while for reasons that have nothing to do with either Mike or the product. I don't have a dog in this fight. But, while I understand that Mike Stewart has a colorful and controversial history in the knife business, my own personal experience with him was always postive, and he went out of his way a couple of times to make alterations to knives that I requested. I don't know of another company that gives as much personal service as Bark River does. Some of this models I like better than others -- I'm partial to the A2 models, but I've seen a lot of his knives, and think they are well made and a quality product.
I don't say that Mike is perfect, but I have nothing to complain about with any of my dealing with him. Some of y'all have apparently had different experiences, and I respect your opinions. I just know that he makes some damn good knives, and that, to me, counts for something.