Beware of user Toyknife..

Feedback: +108 / =0 / -0
Joined
Jan 2, 2009
Messages
3,143
I've had a terrible transaction with a user here on Bladeforums I felt people needed to be warned about. The meat of the issue is detailed in this thread in the Busse forum which I hope you take the time to read. the gist of it is that I sold him an unused "Mint" knife I had received from Busse two weeks previosly. He said after "washing" it he discovered a bunch of scratches in it. Not true... Please read this thread for all of the info...

http://www.bladeforums.com/forums/showthread.php?t=707950

The issue is still not resolved. I refunded his money at the suggestion of other Busse Forumites, and even though I received the email from Paypal last Thursday telling me the refund had feen completed. In the last communications from ToyKnife yesterday by PM, he stated he still had not received the refund.....

I urge every user here on Blade Forums to beware of getting into any transaction with this user....

Best regards, Les.
 
When dealing with a relative unknown the best you can do is to take superb photos in case there is a claim such as this. Why would someone "wash" a knife if he/she is not "sure" they want it. Washing/cleaning goes far beyond inspection.
A deal is not a deal unless both parties are happy BUT if I shipped a mint knife to someone and they washed it and then decided they did not want it I don't think I would be quick to refund the money. If I ship you a knife and you wash it, use it, carry it, sharpen it, do anything to it; YOU OWN IT.
But at this stage in my life my reputation is established and engraved in stone, if the buyer takes delivery and upon inspection is not happy I will undo the deal. Anything other than inspection and the buyer is SOL.
For many others, your mileage may vary..............................
 
Immediately notify PayPal that the reversal they confirm was made, he says was not. They should return your money unless he's removed it, in which case, they should ban him from their system.
 
This is why I'm always reluctant to do dealings online. I have little reputation on here so people have no reason to trust me, and I have no reason to trust most of them either... The few deals I have done have been on good faith and gone over well. Sorry to hear this man!! Good luck and I hope it works out for you! If it does, you can send the knife my way, it'll get good use!

If Paypal can't get your money back you could go as far as getting the law involved. If her fails to return your knife and you sent if via US Mail isn't that tipping into mail fraud territory?

Thanks for letting people know about this! This is the 1st place I came when I did my trades! If they aren't listed here it's one more + in their favor!
 
I would imagine the scratches happened during the washing, did he say what he washed it with ?

My satin Busses were all mint when they arrived but it didn't take much for those litte scratches to show up.
 
I would imagine the scratches happened during the washing, did he say what he washed it with ?

My satin Busses were all mint when they arrived but it didn't take much for those litte scratches to show up.

Either that or he is seeing the grain in the steel that is there on all satin blades.
 
Washing a satin finished knife before calling the deal done is bad business, period. This guy needs to get on the horn pronto and pipe up about his side of this deal...

Refunding his money without getting a confirmation that the knife was en route was not a good idea either.

Give this guy til Monday to post, email him then start getting the postal inspectors involved. You have gone above and beyond with this joker.
 
This is why I'm always reluctant to do dealings online. I have little reputation on here so people have no reason to trust me, and I have no reason to trust most of them either... The few deals I have done have been on good faith and gone over well. Sorry to hear this man!! Good luck and I hope it works out for you! If it does, you can send the knife my way, it'll get good use!

If Paypal can't get your money back you could go as far as getting the law involved. If her fails to return your knife and you sent if via US Mail isn't that tipping into mail fraud territory?

Thanks for letting people know about this! This is the 1st place I came when I did my trades! If they aren't listed here it's one more + in their favor!


Do your homework on the person you are dealing with and you should be safe.
It is hard when a person has little feedback or no feedback to be trusted, but on the other hand we were all there at one time.
Most people on here are good, honest people. Unfortunately every once in awhile a bad one comes through....


To the o.p, I hope you get your knife or your money back
 
This is interesting. Hold on everyone. I hope I don't miss a part because there has been about 30 emails and various PMs sent about this. And frankly, it gets interesting.

I don't want anyone to get the wrong impression of myself or Les, so let me explain my view of the situation.

I posted an ad and Les sent me a PM with stated the following, "I have an Active Duty. New with Black Micarta & satin blade. It is a bit thicker than a BAD I think about .170, let me know if your interested."

Various PMs and emails later about me wanting to know if he had anything else I maybe interested and pictures of the knife. The knife looked lightish gray in the pictures, a bright white satin blade (the flash hit it and you can't see much of anything) and as he stated in the first PM. Les informed me that he brought it new from Busse and has not used it but has lubed it with a Tuff cloth, rubbing it down with oil.

This took about a week after the intial message and at that time I sent out funds via PayPal.

The knife was shipped and received one day later at the USPS. I picked it up the day after, went home and emailed Les that I received it. I then looked over the knife and washed it with soap and water, like I have done with multiple knives. After exmaination under bright light, I noticed scratches which would appear happened from a sheath and/or use. Plus, the edge is not the normal "factory" edge from Busse. It appears sharpened. I emailed Les, at that time informing him of my findings and questioned if the knife was new, if he has a Kydex sheath for it and if he sharpened it. I got another opinion from a friend of mine. He noticed the same as I.

Here is my email and his replies;

Les,

After washing and drying it appears you must have used it a bit? or do you have a Kydex sheath for it?

Regards,

-Nick.



Awesome, thanks. I will leave feedback on the transaction. Hopefully you can as well.

Best, Les.​


It is exactly as received from Busse. Why?​


Les,

The satin finish has clear signs of use and it appears it has been sharpened, it doesn't have the normal Busse "factory" edge. The finish has horizontal scratches on all areas of the blade (from the spine to choil to edge) as if it was used. Plus, there are marks around the choil area as well.

-Nick.



Nick, you are obviously not describing the knife I shipped to you. If you look at the pictures I sent, there is none of the use you are describing.....

That knife was MINT condition as shipped to you..​

I really don't know what your trying to pull. I sent a MINT Busse to you. Obviously your not happy with it, and have likely "invented or added" some use to it.

What do you want from me? Do you want your money back? I would need the knife sent back to me.....

Let me know,

Les.​


As soon as you confirm you will return the knife, I will refund your paypal money.

Les.​


Les,

Easy now, no the knife is great and I didn't invent or add something to it.

I understand your point about the pictures. The pictures you sent had heavy flash, hence the reason you couldn't see the scratches.

I washed the knife with soap and water. I'm betting that the oil that was on the blade covered up the fine scratches. I'll see if I can get some pictures of the blade in the light so you can take a look.

Regards,

-Nick.



I didn't see any scratches on it at all (other than the vertical grind lines), but I have been advised to refund your money. Obviously your not happy with it.

As another member of BF stated, one persons Mint as received from Busse is another persons 98%. Or one persons 110% is equal to your 100%.

Needless to say, you need to be happy with it.

I apologize for my comments earlier. Lets get this straightened out. What do you want me to do? I will give you a full refund now, and refund your shipping costs if the knife is in the same condition as when I shipped it when it is returned to me.

You can then look for one your happy with...

Les.​


Les,

See attached pictures. The pictures aren't great but hopefully gives you an idea. It looks like the knife was used and maybe slipped in and out of a Kydex sheath, plus a sharpening. The edge definitely looks polished with a fine grit stone.

I was under the impression that the knife was New as stated in your PM.

Thanks again,

-Nick.



I sent out pictures showing the problem at hand. If anyone wants to see them let me know.

More replies from Les.


I can't see very much in those pictures, but that is NOT the way I shipped that knife. There is absolutely no way I could have missed those HUGE scratches. You would have seen those in my pictures.

The only thing that was done with that knife by me is it was wiped down with a TUFF cloth, it didn't have a quarter inch of grease which is what it would have taken to hide scratches like those. And the edge was as shipped by busse. It wasn't dull and it wasn't sharp, it was a normal Busse edge.

I really don't know what to do at this point, as there is no way I want that knife back like that.

I will refund you a portion of your money back, and I will make it as high as 50.00 dollars just because.

Let me know what you want to do...

Les.​
_____________

8 minutes later I get an email stating a deal or options.

_____________

NO, take that back.

I said I would take it back, and I will. I will give you a choice.

A. I will refund your full amount, you return the knife.

B. You keep it, and I will refund you 50 dollars of the cost.

Let me know if you would prefer A or B.

Les.​


At this point in the transaction I had to go back to work and don't have a access to my personal account. I informed Les of this in a PM....

"Les,

I'm back at work and cannot access my personal email account. The best I can do right now is use the forum and PM.

With that said, are we still choosing between the two options? $50 or full refund? Depending on what your input is will depend on my pick of the options.

The knife was new and unsharpened when you sent it to me?

Regards,

-Nick. "

To make a long story short. I was informed that the knife was NEW, I received the knife and it was not. I questioned the shipper about use, sheaths and sharpening and I didn't get an anwser besides it was, now, MINT when it was shipped out. I even told Les that I would ship out the knife today, Monday the 25th, because it was taking a week for PayPal to process the refund to my credit card. And this I told Les in a PM,....

"Les,

I checked my PayPal account yesterday and today and the status still stands, "...". I assume that means it is processing from the PayPal to the bank. I called the bank and they can't view anymore then I can. I bet anything that it will show up in one or two business days.

I hope to ship out the knife on Monday. I'll keep you up to date.

Sorry the transaction didn't work out. The knife a great little knife and damn near perfect. Hopefully, I can find another one someday.

Regards,

-Nick. "

Today is the first day I could accesss a computer since then. I went to check my status of my credit card and the system is down, so I called my bank and they stated that there has been a refund of the amount. I will be shipping out the knife today has I stated.

If anyone has questions let me know. I'll be happy to clear anything up.

Yes, my replies to his questioning or requests was not fast as FedEx but there is a reasoning behind that. I have either A) limited time at work to reply to PMs or B) limited access or time to sent out emails from home.


Regards,

-Nick.
 
I will hold saying much until pics of the knife are posted.
I am still willing to bet the scratches you were seeing if running from spine to edge are the grinding-steel grain marks.I have the same thing on every satin blade I have.Busse knives are also shipped in cardboard sheaths,that in its self can put very light scratches on the blade.
 
All,

Intial pictures from shipper. Les sent out spine shots too but I figured there is enough pictures below. And I can't see any problems with it.

ad2%20002.jpg


ad2%20004.JPG


Pictures as received. Not the best pictures but I'm not professional. As you can see why there is an misunderstanding.

100_4350.JPG


100_4355.JPG


100_4356.JPG


100_4358.JPG


100_4359.JPG


100_4360.JPG


100_4361.JPG


100_4362.JPG


The last two are of the edge but I can't upload more than 10.

http://lh5.ggpht.com/_WuCEcibJKwQ/S138jcwW07I/AAAAAAAAFmo/3WhWG06eJ00/s800/100_4363.JPG

http://lh3.ggpht.com/_WuCEcibJKwQ/S138jgmzJ0I/AAAAAAAAFms/ymJTETbOkX4/s800/100_4364.JPG

Regards,

-Nick.
 
Gents,

Don't get me wrong it is one hellva knife! The grip, handle, etc. are great. I like the thickness of the BAD.

I'm just thrown off with the difference between New, then Mint and offers, then full refund. I informed Les that depending on the options (A or B), will depend on what happens with the knife. If I keep it or get a full refund.

Regards,

-Nick.
 
My Lord, that is not some freaking Art knife that belongs in a safe, that is a user knife that belongs in a freaking sheath!!!

It is new, and the edge looks great, oh wait oh wait oh wait!!! Under BRIGHT light you see some scratches.

They look like the kind of scratches that happen when one WASHES a knife with soap and water with maybe some gritty crap on the sponge/rag/your hand.

All this bright light examination should have taken place BEFORE you washed it. If I were the seller and you washed my knife upon delivery, the deal would be sealed.

Send the man his knife back, he refunded your money. If you have your money back then you have no right to photograph the man's knife.

That's why I rarely sell...............................................
 
Back
Top