I agree that this thread should have ended long ago. However, the cost of the knife is irrelevent. If a knife is described as NIB, then it should be that. If it's NIB but has scratches, those should be described. Otherwise, what's to keep a person from doing it on a more expensive knife? Now, Bladechick did a follow-up and went about things politely and cooperatively, so I thank you, Bladechick. I just have issue with the fact that people continue to site the price of the knife as a reason to not complain.
Well, might as well chime in again. Here is an analogy.....You just finish up grocery shopping and walk up to your car. Your antenna has been bent. It will cost you $35 to fix it. Now technically, you could call the police to file an accident report, file a claim with your insurance company (although your deductible is higher than that), wait around for 2 hours for police to come, when the policy finally arive they get furious because you called them about a broken antenna, etc. No. You are going to suck it up and go buy a new antenna. Now on the other hand, if you walk out of the grocery and see that your $20,000 car has been absolutely totaled...well of course you are going to call the cops, call your insurance company, etc., etc. etc. Why? Because it's $20,000....
So why wouldn't you go through all that trouble with the $35 antenna? Because it's not worth it! Spending your time waiting on the cops, calling your insurance company, getting yelled at by the cops, etc. Just go buy another antenna and be done with it (e.g., just use your $35 knife).