I got a Spec's (Texas liquor retailer) gift card for my birthday, and went by the store to see if they had any good holiday gift packs (I'm always on the lookout for free Remy glasses). No luck there, but right next to the 10YO Laphroaig, they had a Lonach 2005 10YO (2005 distilled) Laphroaig. And right below the Lonach was a sign that said something like $26 off, which made it a little over half the price of the $48 a bottle 10YO Laphroaig.
How could I pass that up?
And how could I not do a side-by-side comparison?
I read on Reddit that Lonach is bottled by Duncan Taylor, an independent bottler, using whiskies from various distillers. Lonach is said to be a Spec's exclusive (in Texas at least) for overproof and underproof barrels that were tough to work with in Duncan Taylor's other blends.
You probably can't read it on the bottles, but the Lonach is 46%ABV compared to 43% on the Laphroaig.
In the glass, the Laphroaig appears to have a slightly richer color. I have a bit of a stuffed-up head and couldn't smell a difference. It probably impairs my ability to taste too.
On the first taste, the Laphroaig had a richer mouth-feel. The Lonach seemed thinner, with less peat flavor, and maybe a bit of iodine aftertaste. Not really a huge difference, though, and one that became less pronounced after a few times back-and-forth.
I can't see buying the Lonach at it's regular price of $53, which is about $4 more than the stuff bottled by Laphroaig, but for about half the price, I think it's quite a bargain. (Maybe not so much of a bargain if you're in Houston, where Spec's Downtown Store has Laphroaig 10YO for $10 less a bottle than the East Podunk store.)
The sale at
Spec's runs through the end of December, in case there are any other Busse-owning Scotch drinkers in Texas who might want to get some before this deal goes away.
You can read someone else's review
here. I don't disagree with anything that guy wrote.
Still trying to decide whether to go back for that lone bottle of Batch 53 A'bunadh hiding among a bunch of 64s.