"Cheaper Than Dirt" Rough use knife

I just got one of these from SMKW today, which is apparently out of stock right now.

Initial impression: It's a large-ish fixed blade knife. No real identification marks. Tang says "China" on one side, "Stainless" on the other. Blade and guard are finished in black crinkle plastic-y paint. Handle is rubbery plastic, with what seems to be a aluminum grommet in the lanyard hole. Weighs about 12 1/2 ounces. Blade is about 8 5/8" long, .200" thick at the tang, with a full flat grind. OAL is 13 7/8". Doesn't feel too bad in the hand. The edge out of the box is thick (about .045"), angle about 60 degrees inclusive, with a large burr. Not a terribly good formula for cutting out of the box.

Sheath is... a sheath. Lightweight nylon with a plastic sheet insert giving it some rigidity, and a snap keeper.

First thing it went to the belt sander. New edge bevel is slightly convex and approximately 26 degrees inclusive. Chops OK for it's size. It's not very massive or long, so it's performance is expected. Once sharpened, it's an OK slicer. The crinkle paint seems to offer noticeable resistance when slicing through materials. Unfortunately, I'm not going to give it the Noss treatment. But so far, performance isn't bad, considering it's humble origin.

It might be interesting to compare it with the clip point and bolo/kukri versions. Both of those seem to have saber grind. And S&W versions, too.
 
I received the two I ordered. They don't look bad for under 10 bucks each. They were dull but I sharpened them up on a DMT to see how easy I could do it. It didn't take much to put a decent edge on them.

I like the handles on them. They feel very comfortable and they have a rubber feel to them.

obj1620geo1331pg77p9.jpg

obj1619geo1330pg77p9.jpg

obj1213geo1329pg77p9.jpg
 
El-stink-o. Don't buy it. Trust us. You really do get what you pay for and nothing more. There is no such thing as a free lunch (old saying).
 
I will be laughing for a long time if they do better than the overpriced name brand knives when Noss does his destruction tests. They certainly look comparable to some of the higher priced ones.
 
I received the two I ordered. They don't look bad for under 10 bucks each. They were dull but I sharpened them up on a DMT to see how easy I could do it. It didn't take much to put a decent edge on them.

I like the handles on them. They feel very comfortable and they have a rubber feel to them.

obj1620geo1331pg77p9.jpg

obj1619geo1330pg77p9.jpg

obj1213geo1329pg77p9.jpg

Interesting bro.
The bowie I got from cheaperthandirt a few years ago has different markings and much larger tubing.
 
Update: So far, so good. Functionally, I'm finding the spear point version to be a bit like a small machete. It swings well, feels good in the hand. Actually takes a good edge. Don't care for the double guard. Steel is pretty soft...machete soft. Very easily filed and sharpened. Batoning a knotty piece of pine resulted in some lateral distortion of the edge about 1/64". Chops well for it's size, comparable to the 12" Tramontina machete. The tip bent while stabbing about 1/2" into some wood and prying out chips.

I kinda like it so far. It'd be great for garden use and general grubbing about in the dirt. The full flat grind actually makes it behave like a knife once sharpened. I have no doubt it would take a permanent bend if some serious lateral weight were applied. Fortunately it's made from thick enough stock that it would take some effort to do.
 
Notorious Noss has posted the test on the Bowie styled Cheaper Than Dirt knife.

My own spearpoint model is still holding up as a backyard grubbing knife. I did manage to ripple the edge when batoning through some knotty wood using a clawhammer. Spine got dented up, too. But it still works. Despite the steel being quite soft, I find it takes a very keen edge quickly and easily. Seems to be softer than the one Noss tests.
 
Yup. I had a suspicion they would out perform some of the other big buck names. Now if I can just come up with a use for such a big knife.. Sure wish CTD would offer those in 6 inch..
 
Like Noss said, sometimes you get more than you pay for. The results didn't really surprise me too much, I was expecting the knife to perform well. I know most equate China with cheaply made but this isn't always true. China wants our business and they know the way to earn it is to offer good quality at low prices. I, as well as many of you, have to hope things improve for the workers there but before you boycott it remember low pay is better than no pay and you are still filling a families rice bowl.

I haven't gotten one yet, everytime I get ready to order I find a deal elsewhere I can't pass up but I do plan on getting a couple of these when I order my Suomi mags from CTD. Hopefully they will be in stock when I do. If you do order from Cheaper Than Dirt make sure to ask for a Master Catalog, it is huge and filled with far more than the web site shows.
 
Yup. I had a suspicion they would out perform some of the other big buck names. Now if I can just come up with a use for such a big knife.. Sure wish CTD would offer those in 6 inch..

No reason why you couldn't just grind it down to whatever size you prefer, if you like modding. It's not like it would cause a financial disaster if the attempt failed. :) Shouldn't be difficult, either, since the steel is very soft. That, of course, is also why it's tough. Won't hold an edge very well at all, but will take a beating and keep going. Whether this is the kind of performance one wants from a knife rather depends on the individual, I'll say.
 
hehehehe, so after Noss's work on the blade, we might be able to say, that its a very nice blade for the price.

this thread was a blast.
 
put this in your pipe! Strider!

What does this comment have to do with anything:confused:

First off Noss did not rate this knife he let the viewers on his forum rate it. Secondly he only tests for toughness, and god knows there are things like Wear resistance, Strength, Stain resistance, and Edge holding that are not even taken into consideration with his test (he openly will admit that ask him). Striders use S30V a great compromise in all these areas.
 
Back
Top