First because I don't think it can be said enough when this guy is brought up; This is not the Chris Williams of Wilmont Grinders! Man I feel for that guy having a heel like this with the same name
and making shit knives...
Wow this guy seems to pop up every so often. I first heard about him when I had stencils made for my logo, the person that made them told me he gets his done at the same place so I googled him and found the notorious thread where he threatened to sue spark and everyone else on this forum. It was comical and this guy has some serious issues. I would look that thread up, it may be useful to show a pattern of psychotic behavior. I don't have time but remove the ()'s and put this into google to help narrow it down ("chris williams" sue spark site:
www.bladeforums.com) if I recall it was something about "hand made" oyster knives that were actually blanks.
Also don't be too hard on yourself. I google and research everything, as a technology specialist its second nature and I have two thoughts on it. One is no matter what you try there is simply not enough time in the day to research everything you do. Second, despite my attempts to research everything or just do it myself, I still get burned from time to time because; see reason #1. You have gone above and beyond to get justice and I commend you for that, not enough people do and it allows scum bags to continue ripping people off. Just read this sub forum...
My last comment is on the damascus in your photos. I actually think that is real damascus based on what looks like cold shuts in your photos (weld not taking all the way). Hell one of them looks so bad it looks like its about to crack in half. I'm not expert in damascus but I do forge and have made some so that is my assessment based on your photos. As others have said its probably cheap offshore damascus so many of these crooks use and call their own.
However if you want to confirm they are actually dasmascus of some sort the easiest way to prove this in my eyes is to sand the pattern off, its only going to be a few .001"'s deep, and once it looks like plain shiny steel dunk it in ferric chloride. If its real damascus the pattern will come back. If its a fake pattern etched you will just darken the steel. Honestly I doubt this guy is doing that, its so cheap to buy garbage damascus I doubt he would bother. Sorry if someone already mentioned this, I only read the first few pages.
And one last thing for you. Don't post anything that would be considered private about this guy. There is a "cyber" crime known as doxing and if you post his phone number or his wife's name or something along those lines you could get in trouble. Redact that stuff and keep it to publicly available info and you should be fine.
Sorry for the book, I'm just fascinated by this stuff. I just can't understand how guys like this can sleep at night. It must be easy bouncing through life as a bobble head with no conscience... Well maybe not so easy now
Good Luck
-Clint