Deja Vu all over Again!!

[Fodderwing]

Rhidian and Charlie
Thank you so very much for getting together to make these fantastic Knives!

Outstanding in everyway, the Quality of this Knife is unreal, I absolutely love it! The Workmanship is extremely High Quality and I feel honoured to own this wonderful piece ....

What they said above me Duncan. That has to be one of the coolest sweetest knives I've ever seen my friend. I might carry it but I'd guard it with my life. If anyone should have it along with Charlie you DA MAN TO HAVE IT. Congratulations brother.

 

[Campbellclanman]

Thank you for the kind words Harry and Mark and Dwight ( made me laugh matey ).

I appreciate them so much, truth be told there are so so many people here who deserve this and more-
The last couple of years I haven’t had the time to really dedicate myself here and I’m a bit ashamed of that - but if life works out ok - I should have a bit more soonish.

Not only do so want to thank Rhidian again, but also Charlie- he does so much to help others, and also all of the Traditional gang - and you all know who you are.

Thank you to absolutely everyone in Traditionals- and to our cool mods - Their work is so important and they do it well.

 

[waynorth]

Enjoyed reading this thread again - such memorable journeys!!

 

[Rhidian]

How about another WIP?
I'm making a Barlow with a "Long Beak" blade for a longtime BF member in France, with the design guidance of Mr. Campagna. Here are some progress pics. This will be similar to the GEC Ancient barlows with long beak blades inspired by the third from top knife in this photo of Charlie's collection. The knife will be a little bigger at 3 & 3/4" closed, ebony covers & A2 high carbon tool steel.

I draw my pattern on the computer. Decided to go with a stove pipe kick instead

Cut out and profiled

Cutting nail nicks

After heat treat, fine tuning and liner fit up so everything is flush

 

[Johnnythefox]

Its all quite amazing,I missed one bit.

Who was the genius came up with the final etch name?

 

[Jack Black]

How about another WIP?
I'm making a Barlow with a "Long Beak" blade for a longtime BF member in France, with the design guidance of Mr. Campagna. Here are some progress pics. This will be similar to the GEC Ancient barlows with long beak blades inspired by the third from top knife in this photo of Charlie's collection. The knife will be a little bigger at 3 & 3/4" closed, ebony covers & A2 high carbon tool steel.
View attachment 1907898
I draw my pattern on the computer. Decided to go with a stove pipe kick instead
View attachment 1907891
Cut out and profiled
View attachment 1907903
Cutting nail nicks
View attachment 1907905
After heat treat, fine tuning and liner fit up so everything is flush
View attachment 1907906

Incredible! Do you mean 'Short Beak'?

 

[waynorth]

How about another WIP?

Always ready for a Work In Progress!!

 

[waynorth]

Incredible! Do you mean 'Short Beak'?

If there is a mistake in the nomenclature, it is mine!! Long Beak or Short Beak!!??
I plead old age!!
Either way, I look forward to this build, Rhidian!! Great pictures of progress!!
Rhidian

 

[Jack Black]

If there is a mistake in the nomenclature, it is mine!! Long Beak or Short Beak!!??
I plead old age!!
Either way, I look forward to this build, Rhidian!! Great pictures of progress!!
Rhidian

LOL! Short Beak Charlie

 

[Johnnythefox]

Its all quite amazing,I missed one bit.

Who was the genius came up with the final etch name?

I cant find where the decision for the name was made, just interested to see who's idea it was .
It seems very fitting to me.

 

[Jack Black]

I cant find where the decision for the name was made, just interested to see who's idea it was .
It seems very fitting to me.

It's a historic name, took 2 years of research! Simon Moore was the most knowledgeable source.

 

[Âchillepattada]

THAT'S JUST AMAZING

A wip is always a pleasure but being able to watch a collaboration between Charlie waynorth & Rhidian is just GREAT !

Â

 

[Johnnythefox]

It's a historic name, took 2 years of research! Simon Moore was the most knowledgeable source.

Thanks I thought it was asked for an idea for an etch and someone was chosen.

 

[waynorth]

Now that we have the name of the blade cleared up, let's get down to the real issue here!!
Rhidian has agreed to do a riff on my older "Ancient" Barlow design!! I am honored that one of my Barlows has received so much love over the years!!
On the GEC produced knives, the one thing I would have changed, would be the
kick - to a stovepipe!! I am happy to see Rhidian has done the change!!
The idea I had was to produce the knife as the early Barlows had been done - cheaply produced, and sketchily finished - not so appropriate in a modern custom knife!!
But we will see what the artist conceives in this one!!

 

[waynorth]

It's a historic name, took 2 years of research! Simon Moore was the most knowledgeable source.

"SHORT BEAK" !
Thanks again for all the research, Jack!! A noble quest in my book!!
(Even though I muffed it!!)

 

[euroken]

Not the same Ancient that waynorth is showing, but to show my appreciation for his SFOs...

This custom run is going to be epic!

Yes, more pictures please!

 

[Campbellclanman]

Stovepipe all day long Charlie!

 

[Jack Black]

Thanks I thought it was asked for an idea for an etch and someone was chosen.

No, there was a bit more to it than that (this thread has veered way off its original course!) Goes all the way back to when Charlie's first Ancient Barlow run was in the pipeline, but as yet unannounced. Charlie asked if I knew what the blade was called, and I set off to find out. Took longer than I'd anticipated!

Now that we have the name of the blade cleared up, let's get down to the real issue here!!
Rhidian has agreed to do a riff on my older "Ancient" Barlow design!! I am honored that one of my Barlows has received so much love over the years!! View attachment 1908346View attachment 1908347View attachment 1908349
On the GEC produced knives, the one thing I would have changed, would be the
kick - to a stovepipe!! I am happy to see Rhidian has done the change!!
The idea I had was to produce the knife as the early Barlows had been done - cheaply produced, and sketchily finished - not so appropriate in a modern custom knife!!
But we will see what the artist conceives in this one!!

It was an incredibly imaginative project, very bold, but the stovepipe kick will be the icing on the cake

"SHORT BEAK" !
Thanks again for all the research, Jack!! A noble quest in my book!!
(Even though I muffed it!!)

I thought I'd better correct the name before it passed into usage Charlie! Thank you for these wonderful knives my friend

 

[Johnnythefox]

No, there was a bit more to it than that (this thread has veered way off its original course!) Goes all the way back to when Charlie's first Ancient Barlow run was in the pipeline, but as yet unannounced. Charlie asked if I knew what the blade was called, and I set off to find out. Took longer than I'd anticipated!

It was an incredibly imaginative project, very bold, but the stovepipe kick will be the icing on the cake

I thought I'd better correct the name before it passed into usage Charlie! Thank you for these wonderful knives my friend

View attachment 1909209

View attachment 1909201

View attachment 1909200

View attachment 1909206

View attachment 1909207

View attachment 1909208

View attachment 1909203

View attachment 1909204

View attachment 1909205

Thank you for the reply, I am clearly way out of my depth and struggling to understand.

I searched for stovepipe kick but all the photos have gone so have no idea what it is, further google turns up spyderco.

A question on kicks

As I was examining my newest Ryu K knife and comparing it to a similar Bose model, I noticed the kick was different. Not sure I've seen this before (except other Ryu knives). Does anyone know what this style kick is called? Here's the 'traditional' kick found on the vast majority of...

www.bladeforums.com

 

[5K Qs]

Its all quite amazing,I missed one bit.

Who was the genius came up with the final etch name?

Johnny, I don't think folks understand that your question refers to the original knife in this thread, not the recent Barlow WIP.
Here's part of the original post in the thread, with a couple of relevant sentences in boldface.

...
There is an etch, "Young's Sheep Dips"!! I'd like to put a similarly-'flavored' etch, on the reproduction, and would like some inspiration from my peers here, if You'All are willing!!
"CHARLIE'S FOLLY"
...
Poor examples, but I hope you get the idea!
Here's the best part!! If i use your etch idea, I will send you a nice Knife!!
A surprise worth your while, I guarantee!!
Please just put one or two in each post - don't flood me out!!
I hope this is fun for you!!

Actually this is a GA of sorts!! Ha Ha!!
...

If I understand Johnny's question, he's asking who actually came up with the etch that was used on that original knife (and won a knife, as per the preceding quoted post).
And I think the answer is in this post.

First Sacto came up with this (out of left field??), and then Jack Black came up with the clincher; the actual pattern in print!!
From YOUNG'S SHEEP DIPS, to SHEEP'S LAST DIP gets to the history, and the ridiculous humor I've been looking for!!

I think Charlie came up with the final etch himself, once he knew the blade shape was known as a castrator blade!

- GT