Here it is directly from a retired special forces vet and M1 nut,not to mention the most articulate man i know! Here it is directly from a retired special forces vet and M1 nut,not to mention the most articulate man i know!
Quote:
You have to be VERY careful when you hear people speak of an "original" Winchester Garand (M1).
Here's the deal: Although they exist, they are VERY rare. Here's why. At the conclusion of World War Two all Garands were recalled by the military and sent to Springfield Arsenal for the purposes of inspection and rebuild. And here's how they did it: strip all rifles; gauge all parts. "Go" parts get put in bin "A"; "no-go" parts get shit canned. Now parkerize all old "go" parts, add new parts as necessary, and re-assemble from Bin "A".
So, one might get a "Winchester" receiver, TRW barrel, Singer bolt, Springfield Arsenal stock, and odds and ends from any other manufacturer that made one of the 5 million Garands that were recalled, rebuilt, and re-issued; to every damn Army in the free world. Therefore, it is distinctly possible to have a "Winchester" Garand, which ain't . . .
It is also possible to have one that was a Winchester original and never recalled. Rare - very rare, but possible. A "true" Winchester Garand (M1) would easily be worth a thousand dollars, maybe two thousand, depending on condition and serial number, etceteras. It would require what is called in the collectors trade, a "provenance" - proof from Winchester of originality. Not likely any more . . .