Is Jesus God?

Status
Not open for further replies.
He can and does whatever he wishes.
True but he cannot go against his own nature which is righteous, just, and holy. He cannot render an unjust judgment for instance. He cannot and will not be deceitful among many other things that humans and even angels can become. He will not break his promises.
I'm sure others with more knowledge than me could go on but you get the point.
 
This whole "Jewish leaders that plotted Jesus death" thought is the road that leads to bad internet. There's a chance that idea could be discussed logically and respectfully, but most of the time it gets emotional and a fustercluck ensues.

I want it known I do not hold that belief myself, for I was not there. It was stated earlier by another poster and I had a question about it's legitimacy altogether. How could the "jewish leaders" "plot his death" when it was his manifest destiny to die that way according to their own religion ? and God made the plan so he was the "plotter" then. Catch my drift ?
 
I want it known I do not hold that belief myself, for I was not there. It was stated earlier by another poster and I had a question about it's legitimacy altogether. How could the "jewish leaders" "plot his death" when it was his manifest destiny to die that way according to their own religion ? and God made the plan so he was the "plotter" then. Catch my drift ?

I understand now as I did when I posted before. I wasn't looking askance at you earlier, I was just thinking how this thread could splode.
 
Wow.... 2400 views and counting! Hope these people are checking out Aunties knives while here!!
 
-- "I heard Allah and Buddha were singing at the Saviors feast - and up in the sky and Arabian Rabbi fed Quaker oats to a Priest, pretty good not bad, they can’t complain, cause actually all of them gods are just about the same"

John Prine
 
A man - he is a buddhist jumps out of a plane, pulls his ripcord and the chute don't open,
he pulls the backup and it don't open either!
'Oh Buddha' he implores 'please open my parachute and I shall follow your teachings always!'
Nothing happens, the ground is rushing to meet him.
'Please most Holy Buddha I will give away all my worldly possessions to the poor!' he says.
Nothing.
'For a third time Buddha I beg you to save my life!'
With a whip and a snap the parachute bursts open and the man is saved.
'Thank God for that!' he says in relief...
...the parachute folds back up again and he plunges to his death
 
Last edited:
bennyB unknowingly hit on an interesting point. He wrote that he heard that the Jews have a 30 page book about what is work. I don't know for sure, but I suspect that there are many more pages then that.
The Mishnah, Talmud and other books were commentaries on the law as written in the 5 Books of Moses. These were edited over hundreds of years. Picture a bunch of old bearded men arguing over whether or not throwing dishwater on the ground constitutes work. If a plant grows because of the water, was it work? Why is turning a light switch on work? My nephew got religion and became an orthodox Jew. (Later, a rabbi) He put locking switch covers on the bathroom light switches because non-Jewish visitors would turn the light off on Friday evening and he wouldn't be able to turn it back on until sundown on Saturday. You are allowed to cook on the Sabbath, but are not allowed to turn on the stove, so orthodox Jews would turn the oven on before sundown on Friday. Jews have gotten tickets for J-walking because they couldn't push the button at the stop light. That one almost started a riot in Los Angeles.

I suspect that the same goes for Catholics, and other Christian sects. Did Jesus and/or Peter ever envision the likes of the Vatican? I doubt it.

I have dozens of examples about how ridiculous religions can get when they take a simple phrase or sentence out of the bible literally. The Jehovah's Witlesses are a prime example.:rolleyes:
 
A little something from the Age of Reason:

"Let us strangle the last king with the entrails of the last priest." (1784)
Denis Diderot (b.1713), French philosopher, critic, and encyclopedist

I'll vote that Jesus wasn't god. The best book I've read on all that was Misquoting Jesus by Bart D. Ehrman. Very easy to read and entertaining. Explains what Diderot probably knew about the bible that you may not 300 years later.
 
Last edited:
bennyB unknowingly hit on an interesting point. He wrote that he heard that the Jews have a 30 page book about what is work. I don't know for sure, but I suspect that there are many more pages then that.
The Mishnah, Talmud and other books were commentaries on the law as written in the 5 Books of Moses. These were edited over hundreds of years. Picture a bunch of old bearded men arguing over whether or not throwing dishwater on the ground constitutes work. If a plant grows because of the water, was it work? Why is turning a light switch on work? My nephew got religion and became an orthodox Jew. (Later, a rabbi) He put locking switch covers on the bathroom light switches because non-Jewish visitors would turn the light off on Friday evening and he wouldn't be able to turn it back on until sundown on Saturday. You are allowed to cook on the Sabbath, but are not allowed to turn on the stove, so orthodox Jews would turn the oven on before sundown on Friday. Jews have gotten tickets for J-walking because they couldn't push the button at the stop light. That one almost started a riot in Los Angeles.

I suspect that the same goes for Catholics, and other Christian sects. Did Jesus and/or Peter ever envision the likes of the Vatican? I doubt it.

I have dozens of examples about how ridiculous religions can get when they take a simple phrase or sentence out of the bible literally. The Jehovah's Witlesses are a prime example.:rolleyes:

This is something that created a great deal of "tension" (an understatement) between the pharisees/sadducees and what Jesus was preaching/teaching.

For example, the pharisees/sadducees interpreted certain verse to mean things that Jesus said were not intended. Not "working" on the Shabbat is one example [Wiki]"The word Shabbat derives from the Hebrew verb shavat. Although frequently translated as "rest" (noun or verb), another accurate translation of these words is "ceasing [from work]...".

What does "ceasing [from work] mean? Keep in mind that the pharisees/sadducees interpreted certain verse AS a command to "cease work". [Wiki] "Shabbat is given special status as a holy day at the very beginning of the Torah in Genesis 2:1-3. It is first commanded after the Exodus from Egypt, in Exodus 16:26 (relating to the cessation of manna) and in Exodus 20:8-11 (as the fourth of the Ten Commandments)." (and others). Genesis 2:1-3 describes God's creation of the earth, and that on the 7th day God rested. Is that a commandment to men that they should also rest? Further, does "rest" mean perform no work? Further does putting on your shoes and tie the laces qualify as "work"? The Pharisees/Sadducee's said "yes", wearing shoes/sandals would require work to tie the laces, and since "work" is forbidden, no shoes/sandals could be worn on the Shabbat.

It is these sorts of "laws" (God rested, so no work=no shoes/no elevator buttons on Shabbat) that Jesus challenged so vehemently, threatening the power and control held for so long by the Pharisees/sadducees. There are many, many examples in the New Testament where Jesus made such challanges... so many that the Pharisees/sadducees wanted Him removed so that He could no longer challenge their authority.

(as an aside, there is a little village near where I live named Bethlehem. It is known locally for two things, a couple of great mountain golf courses, and a large population of Hasidic Jews. When I was young I worked for a landscaping company and had the fortunate opportunity to talk with many of these people. The were hesitant at first, but once they realized that I was truly interested in their beliefs (and didn't mock them), they freely told me about the Shabbat and how they observed it and why (among other things). They are a very devout, admirable people and I admire them greatly, even though we disagree.)
 
TO BHF444:

bhf444 says: "so Benny believes there is no work required or asked of him as a Christian"

Benny says: Please don't put words in my mouth. I did not say that. You don't know what I believe. That is your interpretation of what I said. If you want to quote me, quote me. Don't twist my words.

bhf444 says: well benny what happened to "just believe and you are saved and a Christian"?

Benny says: Thats another thing I didn't say. Again its your interpretation of what I said. I also didn't appreciate your tone very much.


For the record I do believe that faith without works is dead. The bible clearly states that saving faith bears fruit. The fruit being patience, kindness, love, etc. So what I believe is that if a christian is not bearing fruit than he must not truly be saved. If a christian truly believes and the holy spirit is working within him, he will bear fruit.. See here's the difference. We do do something. We love the Lord Jesus with all our hearts, soul and mind. Jesus said this when asked what was the greatest commandment. If we truly believe in and love the Lord Jesus, HE gives us the holy spirit which begins the process of sanctification. That is, we begin to change with the spirits help. What many people think is that they need to clean up their act and then Jesus will accept them and give them the holy spirit. Scripture clearly states this is not how it works. Our part in this is to fully accept christ as our saviour and turn from sin. If we have done this, the holy spirit is in us and as the bible says "he who has begun a good work in you will bring it to completion". To Jesus, our hard work and righteousness are nothing but "filthy rags". That's what he said.
It may seem like we are actually not doing much in this process. Jesus says this is how it works to that "no one can boast". We believe totally in Jesus, he gives us the holy spirit which changes us (not overnight, but increasingly over time). And Jesus says that we must "abide in his word". We must read the word and meditate on it. That is key. Jesus says so many times. And when our lives begin to change, and things we could never change ourselves improve Jesus gets the glory, because we know that HE did it, not us. Actually, this is a lot of work, because for most people to "die to self" as Jesus says we must do, we need to relinquish our pride. Our sense that we are masters of our own destiny. We have to fully trust in Jesus and abide in his word.

Im sorry that I don't have the time to include scripture references but I work full time and have 3 small kids so I barely have enough time to write this.
 
TO BHF444:

bhf444 says: "so Benny believes there is no work required or asked of him as a Christian"

Benny says: Please don't put words in my mouth. I did not say that. You don't know what I believe. That is your interpretation of what I said. If you want to quote me, quote me. Don't twist my words.

bhf444 says: well benny what happened to "just believe and you are saved and a Christian"?

Benny says: Thats another thing I didn't say. Again its your interpretation of what I said. I also didn't appreciate your tone very much.


For the record I do believe that faith without works is dead. The bible clearly states that saving faith bears fruit. The fruit being patience, kindness, love, etc. So what I believe is that if a christian is not bearing fruit than he must not truly be saved. If a christian truly believes and the holy spirit is working within him, he will bear fruit.. See here's the difference. We do do something. We love the Lord Jesus with all our hearts, soul and mind. Jesus said this when asked what was the greatest commandment. If we truly believe in and love the Lord Jesus, HE gives us the holy spirit which begins the process of sanctification. That is, we begin to change with the spirits help. What many people think is that they need to clean up their act and then Jesus will accept them and give them the holy spirit. Scripture clearly states this is not how it works. Our part in this is to fully accept christ as our saviour and turn from sin. If we have done this, the holy spirit is in us and as the bible says "he who has begun a good work in you will bring it to completion". To Jesus, our hard work and righteousness are nothing but "filthy rags". That's what he said.
It may seem like we are actually not doing much in this process. Jesus says this is how it works to that "no one can boast". We believe totally in Jesus, he gives us the holy spirit which changes us (not overnight, but increasingly over time). And Jesus says that we must "abide in his word". We must read the word and meditate on it. That is key. Jesus says so many times. And when our lives begin to change, and things we could never change ourselves improve Jesus gets the glory, because we know that HE did it, not us. Actually, this is a lot of work, because for most people to "die to self" as Jesus says we must do, we need to relinquish our pride. Our sense that we are masters of our own destiny. We have to fully trust in Jesus and abide in his word.

Im sorry that I don't have the time to include scripture references but I work full time and have 3 small kids so I barely have enough time to write this.

Christianity, like most religions, is at its core a death cult. Almost all religions throughout history have attempted to do two things - explain the unexplained, and more specifically, explain death.

Humans belong to the only species which we KNOW OF, which understands mortality. And so, Humans have spent much time trying to come to grips with mortality. Religions throughout history have attempted to address the issue of death, what it is, what it means, and what comes after, if anything.

Christianity is no different. Most religions require some form of sacrifice in barter with death, or in barter with the deities. Christianity allows for a very different form of sacrifice than many, in the form of the deity itself "dying" ostensibly to pay our way into the afterlife.

The catch of course is the requirement that we individually acknowledge this deistic "sacrifice". In the end, we are still expected to sacrifice for the deity, but in the form of thought, action, and word. No more blood, no more offerings, no more ritual. But sacrifice we must, if we want to get into heaven and the afterlife which the Christian god offers.

For myself, I cannot perform obeisance to a Human, let alone to a god that can't bother to show up without being conjured. I cannot worship, I will not spend time contemplating or reading about or meditating on that which has no existence without the actions of Man.

IMO, Humans are wholly to blame for all the bad we do and completely responsible for all the good we do. Not god, not the devil, not spirits or angels or demons or whatever. I see absolutely no evidence for the supernatural or the spiritual (which is by definition supernatural). And I challenge anyone to provide any scrap of evidence for anything supernatural, which does not involve the actions of a Human.

Andy
 
IMO, Humans are wholly to blame for all the bad we do and completely responsible for all the good we do. Not god, not the devil, not spirits or angels or demons or whatever. I see absolutely no evidence for the supernatural or the spiritual (which is by definition supernatural). And I challenge anyone to provide any scrap of evidence for anything supernatural, which does not involve the actions of a Human.

Andy

An understandable position. If I knew all of the knowledge that is knowable, I might accept your challenge. If you knew all of the knowledge that is knowable, you might be certain that your challenge would hold up. Unfortunately, we both know so little (relatively speaking).;):)
 
IMO, Humans are wholly to blame for all the bad we do and completely responsible for all the good we do. Not god, not the devil, not spirits or angels or demons or whatever.
Andy

yep freewill - Christian or Atheist either way freewill all the way

Benny - it seemed like in your post you were saying all you have to do is confess and believe and then everything is fine in fact the word was amazing. I was not trying to offend or criticize you. Just clarifying.
 
Our souls are supernatural and life is a gift from the Creator.

1 Corinthians 13:12 "For now we see through a glass, darkly; but then face to face: now I know in part; but then shall I know even as also I am known."
 
Our souls are supernatural and life is a gift from the Creator.

1 Corinthians 13:12 "For now we see through a glass, darkly; but then face to face: now I know in part; but then shall I know even as also I am known."

How wonderfully obscure.

Andy
 
So is thinking you can explain away the amazing miracle that is life. Life has a well deserved reputation for being sacred. If you think science has or can ever answer the big questions, you will be seriously disappointed.
 
The important question is what kind of swords did the disciples bring Jesus.
And when he said two is enough, did he mean per person? Or is that a group total?
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top