I vaguely remember the original thread, but I figured it would take a while to get it all worked out when I originally saw your ideas. I love these, the Blade/handle ratios, overall designs, and finishes look great! Most important in my mind is that they are different than anything else. They don’t necessarily share that “handmade” look that GEC produces, they are much more subdued than most of Case’ new offerings, and I love the “darker color scheme” that is different than modern slipjoints I’ve seen from Italy.
I think there is a demand for modern slipjoints, however I also think in the future you may find it beneficial to look into offering a more traditional Carbon steel. Simply because of the rationale that it seems like most “traditional knife guys” like a traditional steel as well. Just think of how nice that gunstock would look with weathered bolsters, worn down micarta AND patina!!
As far as the maker, I think it’s easy to get hung up nowadays because we have the internet, and can research every decision a manufacturer has ever made much easier than in the past. I’m always surprised when I find an older product without any sort of manufacturer label, just the branding. I also think that a certain point, the product has to stand on its own, regardless of country of manufacture or which company built it. If the fit and finish of the actual product is close to those of the prototypes- I’d be thrilled. Well built traditionals are getting harder to find, thus I would not put so much stake into where it was made as I would if there were a flurry of options.
As far as the actual Knives are concerned, I would offer this advice- with the caveat that I don’t have a knife business and this observation is completely anecdotal- it seems like lately small knife producers are swamped with demand as soon as they are “discovered”. Especially if they have a strong social media influence (photogenic, hard to get, etc.). As soon as the next big thing comes out they are kind of pushed to the side. So In short, understanding the difficulties with working with a manufacturer and the limits that may place, I’d recommend that you keep looking ahead and trying to innovate as you go. Think of GEC- it seems to me that they are pushing the envelope more and more on what they will produce. These knives look great, and I’d hate to see them take off only to fall by the wayside once everybody’s gotten one!