Just saw this.....Bark River is no more?

Status
Not open for further replies.
Never a good thing when your knife has a spontaneous disassembly.
mtice1 said:
One thing that has not been mentioned in this thread is thoughts on whether Bark River Knife sales on the secondary market through BladeForums Knife Exchange will be permitted? Given many dealers have pulled them down from their websites but DLT & KSF continue to sell them it is a fair question where does Bladeforum stand on this? Certainly circulating these potentially fraudulently marked blades in the secondary market through BladeForums is also a concern.
Click to expand...
I’d say that maybe a sticky post in the knife exchange section might not be a bad idea. Just an announcement of what happened, the pertinent details, and buy at your own risk.
 
mtice1 said:
One thing that has not been mentioned in this thread is thoughts on whether Bark River Knife sales on the secondary market through BladeForums Knife Exchange will be permitted? Given many dealers have pulled them down from their websites but DLT & KSF continue to sell them it is a fair question where does Bladeforum stand on this? Certainly circulating these potentially fraudulently marked blades in the secondary market through BladeForums is also a concern.
Click to expand...

StuntDouble said:
Never a good thing when your knife has a spontaneous disassembly.

I’d say that maybe a sticky post in the knife exchange section might not be a bad idea. Just an announcement of what happened, the pertinent details, and buy at your own risk.
Click to expand...

I agree with StuntDouble. As long as there is disclosure then let people make their own decision.

I have had both good and bad knives from BR - one had a catastrophic edge failure from doing what Mike Stewart said the knife was ideal for, and yet the one that I still have performs as advertised. So anything sold on the exchange should be viewed in that light - it's a crapshoot and buyers should go into it with full knowledge of the situation. A link to this thread would be a good way for the disclosure to be made.
 
madcap_magician said:
I love Matt and Jenna, and also Jason and Tara. I may talk to them privately about this because I am still a little bothered that everyone had these experiences with BRK and yet everyone also... Mostly just said nothing, and then more people got burned.

But then I think about it, and I did more or less the same thing.
Click to expand...

People tend to look the other way unless they are directly affected. I mentioned Strider previously, but plenty of makers have had low moments like Dustin Turpin, Will Moon, Frank Fischer, Tony Marfione, Elija Isham, etc… all while continuing to have a following within this community despite their personal issues.
 
  • Like
Reactions: DMG
Every 10-15 years there is a Big "I TOLD YOU SO" in the knife business. Strider, Stewart, there is always a common there-murky military or secret past, association with real life heroes or industry celebrities, lots of money taken and lots of excuses....and the old "If I tell you, I have to kill you"...buyer beware. Knives are great, enjoy them-buy great knives that you love because they are well made and speak to you, don't buy into the hype and hero worship.
 
Bladeandbarrel said:
Every 10-15 years there is a Big "I TOLD YOU SO" in the knife business. Strider, Stewart, there is always a common there-murky military or secret past, association with real life heroes or industry celebrities, lots of money taken and lots of excuses....and the old "If I tell you, I have to kill you"...buyer beware. Knives are great, enjoy them-buy great knives that you love because they are well made and speak to you, don't buy into the hype and hero worship.
Click to expand...
And yet, for a fact, there are dishonest makers (and companies) that should be outed for unethical and / or criminal behavior...and who should not, (in my opinion), be supported regardless of how nice their work might appear to be.

This is information which should be available to every potential customer...and then they can decide for themselves what to do with it.
 
Maybe I'm off base here, but it seems one thing a lot of these brands that get caught doing fraud have in common is "Made in America" is part of their marketing. I know some folks won't buy anything unless it has that printed on the box, but I think focusing on that causes a lot of people to have blinders. It's almost like they're more willing to buy into a brand that makes those claims, rather than have more scrutiny. "Well they're made in America, so they must be the best!".

Like I said, I could be way off base, and I'm not trying to blame the buyers, but I just think it's one aspect of why these scams are able to rope so many people in and go on for so long.
 
A lot of these American companies weasel word the connection to the USA with a variety of methods.

You can have words to the effect of "Proudly Built in the USA", which leaves room for "with parts sourced globally" and such, which are not always stated but might be inferred. (Assembled in the USA is another.)

I'm not at all against quality knives which are built abroad, (by reputable people in countries which are not our enemies), but I do find it offensive when a company tries to weasel word a patriotic theme by implying something which is not, in fact, true. Just be straight with the customers.
 
Conmen will try to exploit any kind of “movement”, for lack of a better word, like made in America or veteran owned or we support animals or save the whales, etc. It’s frequently lucrative to exploit people who are trying to do some good with their money.
 
StuntDouble said:
Maybe I'm off base here, but it seems one thing a lot of these brands that get caught doing fraud have in common is "Made in America" is part of their marketing. I know some folks won't buy anything unless it has that printed on the box, but I think focusing on that causes a lot of people to have blinders. It's almost like they're more willing to buy into a brand that makes those claims, rather than have more scrutiny. "Well they're made in America, so they must be the best!".

Like I said, I could be way off base, and I'm not trying to blame the buyers, but I just think it's one aspect of why these scams are able to rope so many people in and go on for so long.
Click to expand...

I admit to making positive assumptions about US made knives and makers. I think we also have higher expectations when we do business with US based makers. I am never surprised to hear that a Chinese brand has substituted a lesser than advertised steel or done a poor HT, for example.
 
Like Jared west of qtrmstr or whatever it is. Buy from China and sell as usa made. They should stiffen the penalties significantly for capitalizing on people's intent to support American businesses while funding an enemy. In my opinion.
 
StuntDouble said:
Maybe I'm off base here, but it seems one thing a lot of these brands that get caught doing fraud have in common is "Made in America" is part of their marketing. I know some folks won't buy anything unless it has that printed on the box, but I think focusing on that causes a lot of people to have blinders. It's almost like they're more willing to buy into a brand that makes those claims, rather than have more scrutiny. "Well they're made in America, so they must be the best!".

Like I said, I could be way off base, and I'm not trying to blame the buyers, but I just think it's one aspect of why these scams are able to rope so many people in and go on for so long.
Click to expand...

Implied patriotism is a real selling point. The EDC culture is the strongest in the US mainly because of our laws that allow most of the knives that we collect.
 
shinyedges said:
Like Jared west of qtrmstr or whatever it is. Buy from China and sell as usa made. They should stiffen the penalties significantly for capitalizing on people's intent to support American businesses while funding an enemy. In my opinion.
Click to expand...
Qtrmstr was so bad it was almost funny, though. Super Secret Texas Knaf Museum in a shed!
 
shinyedges said:
Like Jared west of qtrmstr or whatever it is. Buy from China and sell as usa made. They should stiffen the penalties significantly for capitalizing on people's intent to support American businesses while funding an enemy. In my opinion.
Click to expand...
There are plenty of customs laws regarding international trade and labeling, and only a portion of what comes into the country can be examined by proper authority. Then, on top of that, there is the problem of packaging and labels which can be easily removed and swapped after the fact.

Add to this, that criminal behavior has to rise above a certain threshold to be considered for prosecution because of simple manpower limitations.

But yeah, even fines and penalties which don't require courtroom proceedings "can" be a deterrent...to those who aren't committed to operating outside of the law.
 
Blues said:
There are plenty of customs laws regarding international trade and labeling, and only a portion of what comes into the country can be examined by proper authority. Then, on top of that, there is the problem of packaging and labels which can be easily removed and swapped after the fact.

Add to this, that criminal behavior has to rise above a certain threshold to be considered for prosecution because of simple manpower limitations.

But yeah, even fines and penalties which don't require courtroom proceedings "can" be a deterrent...to those who aren't committed to operating outside of the law.
Click to expand...
Don't ask me how it could be done or even if it would work, but it seems the knife industry would benefit from some sort of oversight committee, at the very least for companies claiming to be completely made in the US. Again, I'm not sure if that's even a realistic solution, but it doesn't seem right putting all the responsibility on the consumer.
 
StuntDouble said:
Don't ask me how it could be done or even if it would work, but it seems the knife industry would benefit from some sort of oversight committee, at the very least for companies claiming to be completely made in the US. Again, I'm not sure if that's even a realistic solution, but it doesn't seem right putting all the responsibility on the consumer.
Click to expand...
I think there is some basic oversight in the form of labeling laws for every product.

Reminds me of when Ford tried to enter one of their new products in some magazines domestic car of the year competition. They were told that since it was made in Canada, it could only compete in the import car of the year comp.
 
For me, the sad part about this happening, as well as others we've experienced, has made me jaded in regards to knives all together. When we buy a knife or any product for that matter, we have to have faith that what we're buying is what it's supposed to be. Without that belief, our enthusiasm wanes, and cynicism takes over, as we can't trust anything. 😡😡
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top