Knife Gallery in Orange, CA...thumbs down!!!

I feel your pain. I learned the hard way with a custom and on a production serrated knife. Two different shops. One with a belt Sander and the other on a paper wheel. No matter what is used, it doesn't take much to do alot of damage. Now if something needs sharpening I do it or back to the maker.

It is a lesson we need to learn, unfortunately some of us learn it the hard way. I was in high school. I had my first larger fixed blade with me while camping with some friends. I good buddy of mine saw my knife and said he had a way to make it super sharp. Before I knew what was happening he was pulling it through one of those horrible pull-through sharpeners. Not only did it not make the knife sharp but it left ugly deep scratches on the whole length of the flats. Not considered an expensive knife to me now but it was then. Still have the green handled USA Schrade oldtimer. Man that knife was a big deal back in the day. Now I let knives 4x as expensive through my hands on a weekly basis. Lesson learned. I sharpen it or no one sharpens it, though I would trust some of the folks around here (razor edge, etc...). I sure pay a lot better attention now as well.

And yeah, there is no rule on what collecting is and there is no reason to expect others to know you are a collector unless you tell them you are a collector.
 
It is a lesson we need to learn, unfortunately some of us learn it the hard way. I was in high school. I had my first larger fixed blade with me while camping with some friends. I good buddy of mine saw my knife and said he had a way to make it super sharp. Before I knew what was happening he was pulling it through one of those horrible pull-through sharpeners. Not only did it not make the knife sharp but it left ugly deep scratches on the whole length of the flats. Not considered an expensive knife to me now but it was then. Still have the green handled USA Schrade oldtimer. Man that knife was a big deal back in the day. Now I let knives 4x as expensive through my hands on a weekly basis. Lesson learned. I sharpen it or no one sharpens it, though I would trust some of the folks around here (razor edge, etc...). I sure pay a lot better attention now as well.

And yeah, there is no rule on what collecting is and there is no reason to expect others to know you are a collector unless you tell them you are a collector.

To me, this is the take-away from this thread. What happened to the OP sucks, but it is an all too common occurrence. To me, learning to sharpen has been fun, and I am happy to have this valuable skill.

Also, Josh at Razor Edge is a true craftsman that does great work. I don't hesitate to send him my knives when I cannot or don't want to do something to them.
 
Lol, I tend to learn the hard way. Im sending the BM in for a blade replacement and will be purchasing either an edge pro or a wicked edge. Josh does do amazing work though, he took great care of my Xm and put a nice mirrored edge on it.
 
To me, this is the take-away from this thread. What happened to the OP sucks, but it is an all too common occurrence. To me, learning to sharpen has been fun, and I am happy to have this valuable skill.

Also, Josh at Razor Edge is a true craftsman that does great work. I don't hesitate to send him my knives when I cannot or don't want to do something to them.
Yea Josh does do amazing work...here's a pm2 s110v he just sharpened for me.. Bevels set with a belt grinder and micro beveled on the wicked edge to 1k grit.

lBWVlqG.jpg
NKROi9X.jpg
nS238gx.jpg
 
You are going to freakin love that edge Bobby!!!
He put that one on my 710-1501 and it cuts like a pissed off demon!!
The only problem......after seeing a couple of your knives with his edge you wanna send them all to him!!
Joe
 
You are going to freakin love that edge Bobby!!!
He put that one on my 710-1501 and it cuts like a pissed off demon!!
The only problem......after seeing a couple of your knives with his edge you wanna send them all to him!!
Joe
He does do amazing work, and if I get another used knife in a super steel with a really jacked up edge I wouldn't hesitate to send it to him...but other than that I like sharpening my own knives, I find it relaxing..

I'd sharpened s110v before and it wasn't bad just sharpening, but reprofiling was a pita...and the edge that came on this used one I wasn't prepared for...figured it's easier to let him do the heavy work and I'll maintain it from there lol. It's my edc so didn't see a need for a high polished edge done on the wicked edge, so he just reprofiled on the belt approx 30° inclusive bevel with 40° 1k micro bevel.
 
Lol, I tend to learn the hard way. Im sending the BM in for a blade replacement and will be purchasing either an edge pro or a wicked edge. Josh does do amazing work though, he took great care of my Xm and put a nice mirrored edge on it.
You should send your pm2 into Josh to fix it....you ain't gotta go all fancy with the expensive mirror polish..just have him reprofile it on the belt grinder and micro beveled on the wicked edge..you need not be concerned with him using the belt grinder. As you can see in pix mine came out fine and cost $12.
 
No that is impressive.
Especially considering what it looked like before, wish I'd taken a before pic...I got it used and it looked like the previous owner used some sort of machinery to try reprofiling it and then attempted to micro bevel but at an angle almost matching the bevel, so there wasn't anything micro about it lol. I took one look at it and decided I didn't feel like messing with it, and it needed professional help.
 
Considering the price it seems well worth it. I can reprofile just fine but have never done it with such a steel, highest end has been S35vn. Sending a steel like that to Josh for $12 is a bargain. You'll likely never have to reprofile it again. Just some touch ups and sharpening.

And considering the nature of this thread.......no-brainer.
 
Considering the price it seems well worth it. I can reprofile just fine but have never done it with such a steel, highest end has been S35vn. Sending a steel like that to Josh for $12 is a bargain. You'll likely never have to reprofile it again. Just some touch ups and sharpening.

And considering the nature of this thread.......no-brainer.
Exactly, $12 + shipping to avoid the headache myself = big win.

I sharpened my buddy's s110v and that wasn't bad, but was timely and that was just matching the factory grind removing a few small chips
G1JSid7.jpg

.I knew for kinda reprofile it needed I'd rather let someone with the expertise and proper equipment handle it, and for $12 at that.

Now granted had I opted for a complete wicked edge reprofile it would be an added expense ( +$6 per inch on top of the $4 per inch regular fee if I remember correctly filling out the form) but the optional reprofile via belt grinder was complementary. And having seen the work that man can do with a belt grinder (regrinds and such) I wasn't hesitant at all to go for it.

And you're right with this reprofile in this steel it'll be a very long time before it needs anything more than maintaining that micro bevel.
 
Considering the price it seems well worth it. I can reprofile just fine but have never done it with such a steel, highest end has been S35vn. Sending a steel like that to Josh for $12 is a bargain. You'll likely never have to reprofile it again. Just some touch ups and sharpening.

And considering the nature of this thread.......no-brainer.

Totally true! I have had Josh re-profile a few super steel blades to 15DPS. The quality of his work was incredible. I also had him do a regrind, and was blown away by his skill and understanding of blade geometry. He is not just a knife sharpener, but a true craftsman
 
Where's the pix of the hack job they did..still curious to see...You should seriously send him your pm2 for correcting it.
 
To the OP,
Its not how its sharpened as much as WHOM is doing the sharpening. Stones, Belt sander, Paper wheels, Some people can ruin an edge on anything while other can make a sweet, Keen & even edge on most everything.

Ask to see some work first. A proud sharpener will show it to you.
 
To the OP,
Its not how its sharpened as much as WHOM is doing the sharpening. Stones, Belt sander, Paper wheels, Some people can ruin an edge on anything while other can make a sweet, Keen & even edge on most everything.

Ask to see some work first. A proud sharpener will show it to you.
I did not mean to say belts are bad, I apologize if it came out that way. However, the edges I brought to him while lightly used they did not require a belt in my opinion. I don't know I never owned a knife business. I just assumed that since the individual owned a knife shop he knew what he was doing. All Im saying is that I would have handled someone else's belongings with more care. Maybe by taking off the thumbstuds first and using a finer belt? He did not bother to show me them either which I though was rather peculiar. I tend to show off when proud too.
 
I assumed too, unfortunately. I just about cried when my lightly used serrated knife came back out unserrated and not much blade left. The custom I won't get into, I almost passed out. :unconscious::unconscious:
 
Back
Top