I am not a knifemaker, but I have made knives.
I have bought and sold knives, for a portion of my life, as a professional.
Ed, I hate disagreeing with you in public, but as long as it is civilized, let the games begin.
"Dues ? My thoughts are that they are earned by seeking to know the soul of lady knife and caressing her from start to finish in complete control and understanding of each and every stage of her development. "
Paying dues is a long and complex process. It begins with the commitment of time, something that you understand. There is very little by way of substitution for the investment of time.
This is time invested on the art and craft of a knife, but it is also time at shows, eating crappy food for days, making your back hurt on the concrete floor, and knowing the feeling of a light income, or none at all.
This is time spent at hammer-ins, swap meets, like-minded people's houses, it is called building and adding to the community. Butch might be a swell guy, but is he going to go the distance, or is he going to (God Forbid) die tomorrow, physically or spiritually, never to make a knife again? If the time commitment is not made, the knives do not hold a REAL value, irrespective of maker. There may be a commensurate asking price, but who will bite? Butch made his first knife, and sold it for $1,200. Great!, and I mean it.
He can do that a few times, but it is not sustainable by copying the style that you created. I do not believe the market will support it. I have written my opinions of Audra's adoption of the Ken Onion Style of Ed Fowler Bladesmithing, but at least, it is not boldface copy, or unimaginative emulation.
There are far too many expressing a truly unique voice in this medium to have the cloning that has occurred in the past, and continues now. I make jokes, frequently, that Jerry Fisk should hand out kit knives for entry into the JS and MS ranks, that is how some of the knives are looking, coming out of the ABS these days.
For someone who speaks SO eloquently and intelligently about Art and the internal voice of emotion, allowing your proteges' to become carbon copies is a disservice to yourself, them, and the rest of us. Paying dues is finding out who you are, singing with your own voice, what value you offer to the world, and never being satisfied with "good enough".
Best Regards,
STeven Garsson
(PS, I also find it quite ungentlemanly that Shane(bein' ANOTHER Ed Fowler protege', put the statement out there like he did, it FEELS like a shill in a game of three-card monty)