Pro-Tech knives what say you?

So for auto's are there any brands which are comparable or better than Protech even if they may cost more than Protech?
 
Dddrees said:
So for auto's are there any brands which are comparable or better than Protech even if they may cost more than Protech?
Click to expand...

I don't believe so, no. Some people might say Microtech, but in my experience ProTech's quality has been better, and besides, the former specializes in OTFs while the latter is geared more toward side-openers, so they cater to different markets.
 
Dddrees said:
So for auto's are there any brands which are comparable or better than Protech even if they may cost more than Protech?
Click to expand...

Spyderco made one called a Citadel - but I think it was around the same price.

Ya... I'm not coming up with anything, production build wise.. Definitely some customs out there, but you're probably in the $1,000+ price.
 
Spyderco also had the Embassy which is discontinued like the Citadel. I believe their new auto model is the Autonomy.

Usually hear good things about Spyderco autos as well as Benchmade autos.

I've always liked the looks of the Citadel it just never happened it's way in my possession. I doubt I would own a Benchmade auto because it's my opinion that an auto or assisted AXIS takes away the soul and true meaning of the AXIS.
 
Traps said:
Spyderco made one called a Citadel - but I think it was around the same price.

Ya... I'm not coming up with anything, production build wise.. Definitely some customs out there, but you're probably in the $1,000+ price.
Click to expand...


Thanks, so in your opinion is the Spyderco worse, comparable, or better than Protech?
 
brancron said:
I don't believe so, no. Some people might say Microtech, but in my experience ProTech's quality has been better, and besides, the former specializes in OTFs while the latter is geared more toward side-openers, so they cater to different markets.
Click to expand...


Thank you sir.
 
benchwarmer380 said:
Spyderco also had the Embassy which is discontinued like the Citadel. I believe their new auto model is the Autonomy.

Usually hear good things about Spyderco autos as well as Benchmade autos.

I've always liked the looks of the Citadel it just never happened it's way in my possession. I doubt I would own a Benchmade auto because it's my opinion that an auto or assisted AXIS takes away the soul and true meaning of the AXIS.
Click to expand...

I have no idea what the term Axis stands for, but it seems from many here anyway they prefer Protech over Benchmade.
 
Dddrees said:
I have no idea what the term Axis stands for, but it seems from many here anyway they prefer Protech over Benchmade.
Click to expand...

I mean Benchmades AXIS lock. It is a lock bar that sits parallel and just behind the stop pin. It has two sort of "O" shaped springs (called Omega springs) that are attached on each side of the bar and each sides respective liner. Open the blade and the bar rests in a cavity on the tang. Pull the bar back and the blade will swing freely and close. Or pull the bar back and swing the blade open then closed. Very easy to manipulate and a true ambidextrous design.

The reason I dislike the idea of auto & assisted AXIS lock knives, is that they add a natural resistance when closing. IMO, the AXIS is meant to swing free and true.

Many may prefer Protech over Benchmade for autos. I do. The question was which brands are comparable or better, I think they are at least worth mentioned in the comparable category.

Edit to add: Benchmades do have side opening push button autos in addition to their AXIS autos. Those are much more intriguing to me.
 
I really want a left handed doru but they are out of stock everywhere. Guessing they quit making them.
 
benchwarmer380 said:
I mean Benchmades AXIS lock. It is a lock bar that sits parallel and just behind the stop pin. It has two sort of "O" shaped springs (called Omega springs) that are attached on each side of the bar and each sides respective liner. Open the blade and the bar rests in a cavity on the tang. Pull the bar back and the blade will swing freely and close. Or pull the bar back and swing the blade open then closed. Very easy to manipulate and a true ambidextrous design.

The reason I dislike the idea of auto & assisted AXIS lock knives, is that they add a natural resistance when closing. IMO, the AXIS is meant to swing free and true.

Many may prefer Protech over Benchmade for autos. I do. The question was which brands are comparable or better, I think they are at least worth mentioned in the comparable category.

Edit to add: Benchmades do have side opening push button autos in addition to their AXIS autos. Those are much more intriguing to me.
Click to expand...

Thanks for taking time to explain the Axis lock, I appreciate it. So you said the Benchmade side autos are comparable. Would you say however that the Pro-tech in your opinion are still better, worse, or about the same?
 
I meant Benchmades as a brand are comparable and are worth mentioning. I've owned 3 Protech autos and don't think I've ever held a Benchmade auto. May or may not have at a gun show some years ago, just cant recall for certain. I can't honestly make true comparison either way.

I know Benchmade products are quality and they are backed with a good warranty. I have also seen enough people on the forums praise them and use them for years sometimes more than a decade. That's good enough for me to at least throw them in the mix.

Hopefully others can share their personal experience.
 
benchwarmer380 said:
I meant Benchmades as a brand are comparable and are worth mentioning. I've owned 3 Protech autos and don't think I've ever held a Benchmade auto. May or may not have at a gun show some years ago, just cant recall for certain. I can't honestly make true comparison either way.

I know Benchmade products are quality and they are backed with a good warranty. I have also seen enough people on the forums praise them and use them for years sometimes more than a decade. That's good enough for me to at least throw them in the mix.

Hopefully others can share their personal experience.
Click to expand...


Ok, thanks for the clarification.
 
Well made, if you play with it, the coil springs(bad habit) may give out. Took Dave awhile too send extra springs, not trying put down them but they are excellent Co. for the $. Well made product. Gary
 
GaryC said:
Well made, if you play with it, the coil springs(bad habit) may give out. Took Dave awhile too send extra springs, not trying put down them but they are excellent Co. for the $. Well made product. Gary
Click to expand...

So by giving out your talking quite a bit I would imagine? Also are these easy to replace, will they do it, and is it covered under their warranty?
 
Traps said:
Yes, I believe you are correct - sub $300 ProTech's appear to all have aluminum handles.

Feel/look cheaper than stainless steel and /or titanium..I guess that would be a matter of personal opinion..? maybe others can chime in..

But, check out the Microtech Ultratech, and the Scarab, Troodon (and their respective prices)... those knives use the same material for the handle. I think the premise was to save on weight.
Click to expand...

The TR-3 is under $300 and has a Ti frame lock......that is tough as nails and smoother than snot!!
 
I have 3 Pro Techs.....TR-3 manual, Ti frame lock, a Sprint, small auto a and a black ash burl Godfather. Between my 3 sons and I that Godfather must have been deployed a gabillion times....still deploys like a rocket!
I have dealt with Mapi, CS chick extraordinaire, a few times for clips and a blade swap. CS couldn't be better IMO.
Excellent company that stands behind their product!
Give her a call with any concerns you have.
Good luck and let us know what you decide.
Joe
 
Last edited:
You must log in or register to reply here.
Back
Top