Really...

Which blade is better in YOUR opinion?

  • Black

    Votes: 22 16.5%
  • Polished (Aka silver)

    Votes: 111 83.5%

  • Total voters
    133
You could do a Chive from Kershawguy. Small, easy to carry, spring assisted. I like the Chive alot, and a Blem is $25.

Then you could add a Victorinox Classic SAK for another $15-ish. It's the most non-threatening knife on the planet, yet useful as hell.

$40 for both of those. You'll be the envy of Freshman Home-Room.
 
He meant the are each under $50.

Also, if a SAK is on the table...I’d go for the VIC Alox Electrician...why? Cause it works for me. Haha.
 
Last edited:
I agree with the guys recommending Spydercos. They have so many models of varying features, there is something for every size and use and every budget. Mow a couple extra lawns and you can get a really quality knife from them. I have a couple grand in knives probably, and plenty of others that have passed on through my hands, but I could most likely live the rest of my life with a Spyderco Delica or two for pocket carry and get along just fine.

For assisted openers the ones I had that were decent were SOG Twitch models, but I would agree that a manual folder is a better choice. When you get old enough you can buy some real automatics which are way more fun than assisted openers anyways.
 
Since your parents are the deciding factor in all of this, ask em for a blade length limit. There are plenty of options in any range they stipulate. Plenty of options under $50 too.

If you give em the old puppy dog eyes they might let you get a Tenacious, an Ontario Rat in D2, or Utilitac (one of the most overlooked affordable folders ever made, IMO).
 
SAKs are awesome no doubt, but it sounds like you wouldn’t enjoy one at this point. You can always get one down the line. The knife journey never really ends once you start, lol.

Any knife from the Tenacious line (Tenacious, Persistence, Emphasis, Resilience) will serve you well. Don’t think about it too hard. Just pick a design that appeals to you. I just love my Resilience.

At some point as well, you may want to consider some means of maintaining your knives. Consider a Sharpmaker.
 
I am going to throw my opinion in here again.:) I have had 4 Swiss army knives, that is the first knife I was allowed to own. Once I was able to upgrade to a Gerber para frame I never really carried them much. The tools on a SAK can be nice sometimes. In my experience the blades are not that great even in the Victorinox ones. If you want to cut an occasional box it will get the job done fine. I just prefer more modern styles personally with better steels. If I was given the option between the budget spyderco line and the SAK I would get the spyderco. Use it responsibly and try and paint it in the light as a tool not a weapon and hopefully they will let you put the pocket clip back on after awhile.

Also there is no right or wrong answer to this question! In the end many different styles and types of knives would get your jobs done fine. If you like one better than the rest get it! Knives are mostly about your preferences. That is why you will hear lots of conflicting opinions on what you should get because lots of people have different tastes in styles and different user preferences as to how they use them and what they use them for.
 
You could do a Chive from Kershawguy. Small, easy to carry, spring assisted. I like the Chive alot, and a Blem is $25.

Then you could add a Victorinox Classic SAK for another $15-ish. It's the most non-threatening knife on the planet, yet useful as hell.

$40 for both of those. You'll be the envy of Freshman Home-Room.

That would be a nice combination of knives.:)
 
Just have to say, “love that WH!!”
$50 you say? Ahahaha!! JK ;)
My first post was an array of miscellaneous functional value knives I carry and use daily from the $20 to $50 range.
Second post was more, “come on down the rabbit hole youngster“ :D
Between us yeah the WH was over $50:eek:
Should have posted the Brend
image.jpg
 
Since your parents are the deciding factor in all of this, ask em for a blade length limit. There are plenty of options in any range they stipulate. Plenty of options under $50 too.

If you give em the old puppy dog eyes they might let you get a Tenacious, an Ontario Rat in D2, or Utilitac (one of the most overlooked affordable folders ever made, IMO).
Ah, yes. The Ontario Utilitac. Great knife for the money.

If I was enlisting and wanted a folder, the Utilitac would be on my short list for consideration. Thank you for reminding me of that gem.
 
My first post was an array of miscellaneous functional value knives I carry and use daily from the $20 to $50 range.
Second post was more, “come on down the rabbit hole youngster“ :D
Between us yeah the WH was over $50:eek:
Should have posted the Brend
View attachment 1401228

I’d definitely give you half a bill for the Brend... :D Love that freaking knife - been drooling over it since you posted the first pic.
 
One good thing about being a kid living with his parents and having to follow their rules.

It's not a permanent condition. Before long you'll get to do what you like.
 
You can get some really nice looking swiss army knives. The orange SAK Farmer below cost me $42. A nice coloured Cadet or Pioneer will last a lifetime of use, look great and be well within your budget.

farmer_4.jpg


There are options out there which although they might not tick the 'cool' box, are 'classy' in the way that most modern knives cannot begin to match.

buck_2.jpg


I have a feeling that classy trumps cool when it comes to standing out from the pack and impressing both the older crowd and the opposite sex. In addition being classy will both last a lifetime and take you far further and higher in said life.
 
Last edited:
Talked to my parents last night, they said they would think about it.

However, they said if they did let me get one, I wouldn’t be able to clip it to my pocket, because I’m “showing off” and “letting everyone know I have a weapon”. They think I don’t respect it as a weapon... I do. :(

They also claim the reason why knife manufacturers put the clip on the knife in the first place, is so people can show off. That is SO not true.

You guys have any words that could help me here? Some examples of why a clipped knife is better?

The main benefit of a clip is controlling orientation in the pocket. If left loose, the knife will rest at the bottom of the pocket. This usually means the knife will be horizontal, which can be less comfortable against your leg over the course of the day. Keeping the knife vertical tends to make carrying it much more comfortable. (The same is true for pens with clips in my experience.)

The clip also keeps it out of the way of other things that you might have in your pocket. If you have a loose knife and other loose objects in your pocket, they will rub together over the course of the day. This can put unwanted scratches, wear and tear on those objects. At least in my experience, I also tend to get more pocket lint (etc.) into a loose knife than I do a clipped knife.

This may be overstated but there can be a safety benefit to clipping your knife. Ideally, a strong detent will keep a knife closed. However, banging around loose in a pocket could cause some types of folding knife to open slightly. Carrying a knife clipped such that the back of the blade is against the vertical seam of the pocket ensures that it stays closed.

There can also be a benefit in terms of one-handed use. With flipper tabs, I prefer tip-up in my right pants pocket or tip-down in my shirt pocket. The reason is that the natural way I grip them to remove them from that pocket naturally puts my finger on the tab.

I mentioned the "folding knife as a weapon" mindset previously. It is largely based on misinformation or a few bad apples making waves but perception matters. The reality is that people rarely notice a clipped knife, especially when it has a deep-carry loop-over clip. In many cases, that doesn't look much different than a clipped pen. This is based on decades of carrying pocket knives and knowing other people who do. Manufacturers generally include clips for the reasons I've discussed here, not to foment mass intimidation.

Now, there is a chance that someone who is hypersensitive and has that misinformed view of folding knives or why people carry them could feel uncomfortable if you're wearing a more obvious knife and they notice. That's exceptionally rare in my experience. Of course, I'm usually carrying knives with a deep-carry loop-over clip such as on those Civivi knives I mentioned. I'm older and dress "business casual". I don't look threatening and that can matter. I also think those particular people could be just as freaked out by almost anything so I don't worry about them. Of course, some people work in fields where they have to care. For instance, I know a guy in customer service who goes the extra step. He carries a Civivi Elementum clipped to one of those pocket organizers inside his pocket to get the benefits of a clip without any show whatsoever.

Again, I recommend communication and the promotion of understanding. Feel free to share what I've written here. Look for other resources to share with your parents. As always, do everything you can to demonstrate that you will be both responsible and helpful with a cutting tool. Be there to open packages for your parents or do any necessary cutting tasks around the house.
 
Last edited:
You can get some really nice looking swiss army knives. The orange SAK Farmer below cost me $42. A nice coloured Cadet or Pioneer will last a lifetime of use, look great and be well within your budget.

farmer_4.jpg


There are options out there which although they might not tick the 'cool' box, are 'classy' in the way that most modern knives cannot begin to match.

buck_2.jpg


I have a feeling that classy trumps cool when it comes to standing out from the pack and impressing both the older crowd and the opposite sex. In addition being classy will both last a lifetime and take you far further and higher in said life.

I would have to agree.

Very well said by the way.
 
You know, now you guys have me thinking about how many SAKs I have.

My wife has one on her keychain, another in her car.

I have one in my Cherokee, another in the 72 hour bag, plus one in my daypack.

Another in my work bag, and then a Cadet if I want to carry one.
Then I have a Spartan plus with a leather sheath if I choose to carry one on my belt.

How many is that? Eight? And to think I consider a SAK as a knife for secondary carry.

The scary thing is I have not even counted the limited run and Soldier models I have. My guess is eight to ten more if I count those.

That is quite a few for someone that prefers modern knives like Benchmade, Spyderco, and Kershaw.
 
Since your parents are the deciding factor in all of this, ask em for a blade length limit. There are plenty of options in any range they stipulate. Plenty of options under $50 too.

If you give em the old puppy dog eyes they might let you get a Tenacious, an Ontario Rat in D2, or Utilitac (one of the most overlooked affordable folders ever made, IMO).
Good idea, I will ask them what the maw blade limit is. I really like the Tenacious Carbon Fiber, so it would be good if they allowed me to get it.

I talked to my mom, and she looked like she was starting to agree with me. (I said the things you guys suggested I say, it seems like it may have worked!)

I have decided the SAK is going to be my second purchase, but I will/am going to get one - not sure which model yet, because there are so many options.

These are my top 3 choices:
https://www.bladehq.com/item--Victorinox-Swiss-Army-Knife--25448
https://www.bladehq.com/item--Victorinox-Pioneer-X-Swiss-Army--64507
https://www.bladehq.com/item--Victorinox-Swiss-Army--4042

Here is the plan - I am going to get a Spyderco knife. If they let me, I will get the Carbon Fiber Tenacious. If not, I will get the Persistence. (As it’s pretty much just a mini model)

(Still not sure on no clip or clip, I talk to them again today...)
https://www.bladehq.com/item--Victorinox-Swiss-Army-Knife--25448
 
Back
Top