Society is breaking down, ya have to move on...what knife ?
- Thread starter pitdog
- Start date
- Joined
- Nov 19, 2008
- Messages
- 3,337
it always was foolish to take a knife to a gun fight. 
assuming only ONE knife: a Fallkniven S1.
if i'm allowed multiple blades: Fallkniven S1, Fallkniven WM1/TK6, a hatchet, Leatherman Wave and a Mora Clipper 860.
- Joined
- May 29, 2008
- Messages
- 938
Becker BK 2.
- Joined
- Jun 8, 2010
- Messages
- 3,723
Right now, I'd say this one:
I could always grab more thhen 1 blade, they are mostly all in the same place.
In my pre packed maxped kodiak set up for a retreat into the woods, a swisschamp, and rc-4. If I could choose any blade setup, it would be this:
Busse Ak-47- cant beat that for chopping and self defense
rc-4- for woods tasks
also a variety of light blades for barter and equipping others
Folder of choice: Kershaw Titanium framelock Junkyard Dog 2 with the sg2 blade. I would trust it with my life, in a defense situation or in the woods.
Other wepons would include, Ar-15 with .22 bolt as well, dual kimber 1911's with black talons for ammo.
In my pre packed maxped kodiak set up for a retreat into the woods, a swisschamp, and rc-4. If I could choose any blade setup, it would be this:
Busse Ak-47- cant beat that for chopping and self defense
rc-4- for woods tasks
also a variety of light blades for barter and equipping others
Folder of choice: Kershaw Titanium framelock Junkyard Dog 2 with the sg2 blade. I would trust it with my life, in a defense situation or in the woods.
Other wepons would include, Ar-15 with .22 bolt as well, dual kimber 1911's with black talons for ammo.
Gaurdian_A1
Gold Member
- Joined
- Jul 28, 2009
- Messages
- 836
ESEE Junglas and ESEE 5...either one.
- Joined
- May 22, 2010
- Messages
- 984
but you never know how long it's going to remain a gun fight...it always was foolish to take a knife to a gun fight.
as for me, if the the shtf; first, I'd have my edc knives on me, but I would grab the tote that has all my hunting gear in it (minus firearms or bow) and take that; it has a Colt fixed blade, a frost cutlery green beret folder (really good folder), a tomahawk/hatchet, a folding saw, a pruner (and I think thats about it for bladed items)
- Joined
- Apr 14, 2008
- Messages
- 1,810
Whether it's pick what you want, or "grab one and run, no time to pick", my choice would be this rig:
It has my 20" CAK and R-10 knife, both from Himalayan Imports.
It has the distinction of being the rig I almost always choose for camping/hiking, so it has the most dirt time, and it really is the fastest to grab, as it hangs off the corner of my bookshelf closest to my door.
Nice rig there. I have always liked your gear. Like the duluth canvas bag. I have the green shell bag with the leather trim. The leather on the Kukri looks very well made. I will have to try to make a sheath like yours for kukri one of these days.
- Joined
- Jun 23, 2008
- Messages
- 1,428
My belt knife piggied on a Laredo Bowie. That counts as one right?
mymindisamob
Platinum Member
- Joined
- Feb 1, 2005
- Messages
- 15,094
My Busse Combat Badger Attack TAC.
- Joined
- Jul 29, 2009
- Messages
- 1,707
From what I own I would have to choose my Swamp Rat waki. 17.5" blade differentially heat treated SR-101 steel. Pretty much indestructable and still holds an edge better than most knives. Pretty versital tool, and a great weapon.
Of course in reality I would grab a few smaller back-up blades to compliment it. For instance I would probably choose my Leatherman Wave, and BRKT Bravo Necker for starters. ...pluss it would be simple to lash the BRKT to the sheath of the waki :thumbup:
...If I could design my own "perfect" one blade, it would be a similar to, but modified version of this or a Busse AK.
Of course in reality I would grab a few smaller back-up blades to compliment it. For instance I would probably choose my Leatherman Wave, and BRKT Bravo Necker for starters. ...pluss it would be simple to lash the BRKT to the sheath of the waki :thumbup:
...If I could design my own "perfect" one blade, it would be a similar to, but modified version of this or a Busse AK.
I actually enjoy these threads as a good mental exercise and everytime we have one of these my choice seems to change slightly depending on a number of factors including what scenario I envision, what time of year and what locale I've decided to bug out to and what others have posted that made sense at the time. I've been to enough war torn and disaster ravaged countries to know better than to think that it couldn't happen here, or it couldn't happen to me, so I do think about these things (probably a little too much).
This is Bladeforums so of course we all have waaaay too many knives (as if there is such a thing! I have 4 folders on me right now, and 4 fixed blades sitting on my desk in front of me that I've been toying with), but Pitdog wanted to know which ONE knife.
For this envisioned scenario I think I would want a larger blade that could do more. A smaller knife is more handy, easier to conceal can be used for a wide variety of chores, etc, but I think I would prefer a larger blade for shelter making and as a good deterant. I would prefer something lighter if possible, ruling out many of the big blades (most Busses, most khukris, and most of the well-known big choppers like a BK9, RC9, and some of our fine custom makers wares, etc.). It needs a sharp tip to aid in gutting and cutting (leaving out most goloks, parangs, bolos, etc.). I would want it blade heavy so that it's a big knife in a small package (probably in the 10-14" range to keep it handier and somewhat concealable). I would want it thinner stock to save weight and to make it a more effective slicer. That leaves some sort of machete. I personally would probably go for a barong because I grew up using them when I lived in The Philippines and the Marianas Islands as a kid, they have a sharp and very usable tip (better than a Latin pattern machete), they're relatively light for the size of them, they're lively for self-defense use, they're typically made of very easy to sharpen and repair leaf spring steel and in the hands of somebody skilled with their use (not me, but I've seen some who really know what they're doing) it can be used for everything from shelter building and firewood prep, to skinnin and gutting. I would prefer one with a lanyard hole and a strong synthetic ergonomic handle made of G-10 or micarta and a 10-12" blade, which probably means custom. So I would have David Farmer make a custom one for me or if Busse Custom would do it I would have them make it for me so that I could have the advantages of INFI. I would then have a good custom kydex rig made for it so that it could be carried in a variety of ways, including on the hip with a dangler, strapped to a pack and on a baldric. Then I would use it daily until I became truly proficient with it to use it for finer woodwork and gutting small fish and skinning small game (not an easy task but very doable by those who know what their doing).
Of course in reality, I'll be carrying a multi-tool, a SAK, a folder or 2 and a variety of fixed blades and maybe even an axe or hatchet for serious chopping. Who needs food when I can distract myself with all those toys? Besides, can you imagine if you had to use one knife if you were stuck in a long term survival situation? I wouldn't want to use a SAK or a Mora to build a serious shelter, if I had to. Possible yes, easy no.
This is Bladeforums so of course we all have waaaay too many knives (as if there is such a thing! I have 4 folders on me right now, and 4 fixed blades sitting on my desk in front of me that I've been toying with), but Pitdog wanted to know which ONE knife.
For this envisioned scenario I think I would want a larger blade that could do more. A smaller knife is more handy, easier to conceal can be used for a wide variety of chores, etc, but I think I would prefer a larger blade for shelter making and as a good deterant. I would prefer something lighter if possible, ruling out many of the big blades (most Busses, most khukris, and most of the well-known big choppers like a BK9, RC9, and some of our fine custom makers wares, etc.). It needs a sharp tip to aid in gutting and cutting (leaving out most goloks, parangs, bolos, etc.). I would want it blade heavy so that it's a big knife in a small package (probably in the 10-14" range to keep it handier and somewhat concealable). I would want it thinner stock to save weight and to make it a more effective slicer. That leaves some sort of machete. I personally would probably go for a barong because I grew up using them when I lived in The Philippines and the Marianas Islands as a kid, they have a sharp and very usable tip (better than a Latin pattern machete), they're relatively light for the size of them, they're lively for self-defense use, they're typically made of very easy to sharpen and repair leaf spring steel and in the hands of somebody skilled with their use (not me, but I've seen some who really know what they're doing) it can be used for everything from shelter building and firewood prep, to skinnin and gutting. I would prefer one with a lanyard hole and a strong synthetic ergonomic handle made of G-10 or micarta and a 10-12" blade, which probably means custom. So I would have David Farmer make a custom one for me or if Busse Custom would do it I would have them make it for me so that I could have the advantages of INFI. I would then have a good custom kydex rig made for it so that it could be carried in a variety of ways, including on the hip with a dangler, strapped to a pack and on a baldric. Then I would use it daily until I became truly proficient with it to use it for finer woodwork and gutting small fish and skinning small game (not an easy task but very doable by those who know what their doing).
Of course in reality, I'll be carrying a multi-tool, a SAK, a folder or 2 and a variety of fixed blades and maybe even an axe or hatchet for serious chopping. Who needs food when I can distract myself with all those toys? Besides, can you imagine if you had to use one knife if you were stuck in a long term survival situation? I wouldn't want to use a SAK or a Mora to build a serious shelter, if I had to. Possible yes, easy no.
- Joined
- May 25, 2007
- Messages
- 15,113
NWA Sierra Scout
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2009
- Messages
- 2,692
There are OUTSTANDING kitchen knives that will serve you well in the out of doors and a multitude of tasks. Then again, if (as the op stated) society is breaking down. Worrying about knife laws will be the least of your issues. Water purification is something you can order online if you cannot find it locally (before the apocalypse that is).
If it must be a kitchen knife this one may do the trick:
Out of all my knives ? Just one ?
Fallkniven S1 -
Reasoning ?
Stainless , no muss or fuss.
Convex edge for multiple uses.
Sturdy as heck but lightwieght and concealable.
Proven steel by a proven company.
Big enough for most uses I can think of with a clip point for delicate work.
So yea if I could just grab one it would be the S1.
I think the S1 backed up by a good multitool and prybar like the ones sold by Countycomm would make a good package.
Tostig
Fallkniven S1 -
Reasoning ?
Stainless , no muss or fuss.
Convex edge for multiple uses.
Sturdy as heck but lightwieght and concealable.
Proven steel by a proven company.
Big enough for most uses I can think of with a clip point for delicate work.
So yea if I could just grab one it would be the S1.
I think the S1 backed up by a good multitool and prybar like the ones sold by Countycomm would make a good package.
Tostig
I would grab my Fox 691 since it has a pouch attached to the sheath that has everything I need to survive with antil I can get to or aquire more gear. I always carry a SOG seal pup or TOPS CSK and a Spyderco folders or two at all times with me so those would be already with me to add to the Fox kit.