I was reading another thread on this forum, and someone made a comment saying something like : People are worrying too much about survival, and not enough about just enjoying the outdoors. I've been thinking a lot about that post, and I think the poster is right. Don't get me wrong, I enjoy talking about, reading and practicing "survival" skill, as well as all of the cool survival gear. It just seems that TOO much emphisis is placed on survival. It seems like there must have been a point, before all of the survival shows and forums, when a survival course, and a PSK were things that would benifit someone who spent a lot of time outdoors (ie. hunters, mountain bikers, fisherman) in case something happened while they were doing what they do. It seems that now survival itself IS the hobby for a lot of people. Reading, posting, watching videos, buying gear, and even going out and practicing. But why do you need to worry about survivng in the first place if their isn't some other reason that you are outdoors in the first place? Are you learning to survive in case the next time you're out practicing survival skills, something happens? I know this doesn't apply to everyone here. I'm sure a lot of you were outdoors people before you got into survival. I'm also not trying to down anyone, it was just a thought I had after reading the post mentioned earlier.
It's funny you say that. For about 15 years or so I didn't even know what I was doing was called "survival", for me it was just stuff we learned as kids that was fun. It even embarassed me in highschool because I thought it made me too "hick." (Now I realize it's something slowly fading away into obscurity) To me it was just
stuff: like when some guy knows how to tie a fisherman's knot, where another guy couldn't tell you a bobber from a sinker.
I didn't even know it had a real name until I was about 23 (I'm still not convinced that "survival" is anymore than some guy's term used to make money some way), then a guy I worked with brought a Tom Brown, Jr. book to work and I thumbed through it. "I'm learning survival," he said. Which suprised the hell out of me. But, then I figured "the guy who wrote this Bible looking book had a Grandpop that was a certified Indian something-or-other and mine wasn't, so maybe I really didn't learn survival inasmuch as just stuff."
Then I saw "Survivorman" on Science Channel when we got our first satelite dish (I was 26, I think). I saw all the stuff he did and thought -- yeah, okay, boil water to kill germs. Duh. Mamaw did it everytime it flooded. Tinder, kindling, fuel. Yeah, Pop taught me this when I was seven; you can't set a log on fire with a match and green wood doesn't burn.
Now, I see people making thousands, even millions, on videos, tv shows, and classes on how to raise a garden, or can food for winter, or make fire without a match, or how to sharpen a knife, the lastest gizmo or super-duper Rambo knife, or telling people the common sense knowledge about getting wet and cold, etc. -- and I think "Now, I
KNOW "survival" is just a made up term to sell a product. Most of it is common sense, some of it might be a bit specialized, but for the most part it's just jerry-rigging." Up until I was 22 I thought everybody had a Grandpop that taught them trees, or made a leaf collection every year in school as a mandatory project.
And then there's this whole "bushcraft" set, where some guy carves a lawn chair with a steak knife, and preaches about the pristine majesty of the "wilderness" (which I've never seen, the wilderness I know kicks baby birds out of nests and has mothers that eat their own children). So far, all I've seen is just a slight modification on the "Stuff" with some "SURVIVAL" thrown in.
I never learned all the fancy knots (I think I know about three, and I've NEVER found a use for that Sheepshank). I don't own a closet full of wool and none of my knives cost more than $150 (which is still too much, IMHO -- especially since my $30 pocket knife sees more use than they do.). I have one t-shirt that says "Northface" -- it was a gift. I play around with traps and snares, but have only used them once -- to keep a troublesome cat from underneath my house (it was tearing my insulation down). I never knew "hobo stoves" and Coke can reels (We always used a fat stick), and safety pin hooks were anything other than just stuff us poor "holler" kids did to pass the time.
So, no, you aren't alone. I'm starting to think survival is a gimmick term -- especially here lately with all the "credential" arguments.