The BK15 30 day EDC challenge

Small entry...

USE FROM THE DAY:

Cut a few loose threads from clothes, and a tag off of a shirt. Went to lunch after church and cut up a steak. Cut open a pack of water bottles, cut a couple sacks open.

CONCLUSION:

Still love it. It's a pleasure to sharpen it, too. :thumbup:
 
I've just been touching it up on a 1000 grit stone.

You're doing it right. Honing like that is really the best way to go about keeping any cutting implement in good working order. :thumbup:

It's like the old saying, "an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure". A few minutes spent honing or stropping at the end of a long workday is much easier than 30 minute's actual sharpening at the end of a long week. Some butchers and chefs steel their blades several times throughout a shift to maintain their edges, rather than ever letting them get really dull. I feel strongly that most people who find sharpening difficult simply wait too long, until the knife is very dull and requires a lot of stock-removal to bring it back to good edge geometry.

However, for the purposes of this challenge, you may find it interesting to not hone your 15 at all for the last week. Then for your last test, cut up a whole bunch of cardboard. Just to see how dull it really gets, in what way does it get dull (micro-chipping, rolling, flat-spots from wear, a combination of all three?) and how difficult it is to go back to a coarser stone and actually sharpen it. That will give you a real good idea of how the steel/HT holds up, what you need to watch for, and therefore how often you need to put a little preventive maintenance into it.
 
However, for the purposes of this challenge, you may find it interesting to not hone your 15 at all for the last week. Then for your last test, cut up a whole bunch of cardboard. Just to see how dull it really gets, in what way does it get dull (micro-chipping, rolling, flat-spots from wear, a combination of all three?) and how difficult it is to go back to a coarser stone and actually sharpen it. That will give you a real good idea of how the steel/HT holds up, what you need to watch for, and therefore how often you need to put a little preventive maintenance into it.

This is what I was thinking. To actually put the edge through some abuse. I use a strop to touch up my edges. If I need to go to the stones I go all the way.
 
Noswad0208

Great thread. i really enjoy the photos. Looks like where I grew up. Guess I better get my 15 out and find something to cut. :)
 
Keep up the good work :)

Ummm, no... that's by invitation only :eek:

:02.47-tranquillity:

Noswad0208 said:
CONCLUSION:

Still love the 15. Takes a great edge, easy to sharpen. Handles are even better than full size Becker handles (IMO). Just wish the choil was bigger. I have fairly fat fingers and they touch the blade a little bit when I'm using the choil.

Long term ownership is the goal, and a choil mod is easy.

Good thread, keep up your chores. :thumbup:
 
You're doing it right. Honing like that is really the best way to go about keeping any cutting implement in good working order. :thumbup:

It's like the old saying, "an ounce of prevention is worth a pound of cure". A few minutes spent honing or stropping at the end of a long workday is much easier than 30 minute's actual sharpening at the end of a long week. Some butchers and chefs steel their blades several times throughout a shift to maintain their edges, rather than ever letting them get really dull. I feel strongly that most people who find sharpening difficult simply wait too long, until the knife is very dull and requires a lot of stock-removal to bring it back to good edge geometry.

However, for the purposes of this challenge, you may find it interesting to not hone your 15 at all for the last week. Then for your last test, cut up a whole bunch of cardboard. Just to see how dull it really gets, in what way does it get dull (micro-chipping, rolling, flat-spots from wear, a combination of all three?) and how difficult it is to go back to a coarser stone and actually sharpen it. That will give you a real good idea of how the steel/HT holds up, what you need to watch for, and therefore how often you need to put a little preventive maintenance into it.

Thanks. I'll probably try that. If it gets too dull during the week I'll sharpen it, but I'll go at least three days without sharpening, more if it still has a fairly decent working edge.

Noswad0208

Great thread. i really enjoy the photos. Looks like where I grew up. Guess I better get my 15 out and find something to cut. :)

Thanks!

Long term ownership is the goal, and a choil mod is easy.

Good thread, keep up your chores. :thumbup:

True. Might do it some time. Not sure yet though.

Thanks!

Entry..

USE FROM THE DAY:

Spread some mayo for sammiches, cut some duct tape and posed for pics. Yep. That's it for the day.

All pics were taken on my Uncle's and his girlfriend's farm. The big hill I was standing on taking the pics is a now inactive volcano.

AbVGlD7.jpg

KBkE9zX.jpg

KB09Lk7.jpg

rTMTdsb.jpg

dCnQadX.jpg

9LPb3we.jpg

Teph8ud.jpg

BHIzDBw.jpg

wFk416n.jpg


"The Devil's Backbone"

DSMIfQK.jpg


CONCLUSION:

It spreads mayo real nice... :D
 
It spreads mayo real nice... :D

If that's the rep it gets, no wonder it doesn't get more love.

As for honing, does anyone use a standard kitchen steel on their non-kitchen labeled knives? I've been using the 15 more and more in the kitchen, but never considered using the steel on it.
 
If that's the rep it gets, no wonder it doesn't get more love.

As for honing, does anyone use a standard kitchen steel on their non-kitchen labeled knives? I've been using the 15 more and more in the kitchen, but never considered using the steel on it.

I don't see how it's any different than saying it's "the worlds greatest steak knife."
 
I ran my 15 on a steel A Lot considering I was cutting meat in a commercial plants at the time and it was my go to boning kmife.
The 15 reacts nicely to a steel, but it also helps to have the edge thinned at the shoulder to ease steel usage. Regarding the results that you will see from damage repair, it will smooth burs and rolls, but won't do much in the way of metal removal aside from tearing off a roll if it is thin like a wire edge. Also, depending on how proficient you are with a steel, it may end up rounding the edge where the edge hasn't been used much and touch up where the board has rolled it, since most people naturally tend to run a steel at an obtuse angle near the heel and acute near the tip.



The steel will also mark up your knife like the photos above.

Noswad: sorry for the derail, but I thought it may prove interesting to you as well considering your width and breadth of usage.
This thread is one of my current favorites on the forum atm. Keep it up!
 
Noswad: sorry for the derail, but I thought it may prove interesting to you as well considering your width and breadth of usage.
This thread is one of my current favorites on the forum atm. Keep it up!

No problem, very interesting.

Thanks!
 
USE FROM THE DAY:

Cut a few things not worth mentioning, took some pics, cleaned a trout.

2IyBW6Z.jpg

kwYANHc.jpg

A3UytAm.jpg

fn4sZMZ.jpg

rJTpRUG.jpg

BspPqm7.jpg

4hnyPka.jpg


CONCLUSION:

Great knife. It was excellent at cleaning the fish. Gonna strip it soon. I won't sharpen it this week so we can see how the edge holds up.
 
USE THE PAST FEW DAYS:

The 15 hasn't gotten much use the past couple days. Cut some zip ties, cut some paper, cut some cardboard. Stripped it yesterday.

CONCLUSION:

It's edge is holding well. Still very pleased with it.
 
USE FROM THE DAY:

Used it a lot today. Cut some thistles, cut some paper, cut up a foam plate, cut a plastic bottle in half, cut up an apple, made a couple sad feathersticks, cut the plastic holder thing from around a pack of Cokes, cut some other stuff not work mentioning.

mZRzFRb.jpg

FzmFFyD.jpg

QbXYhpR.jpg

ZqxynPr.jpg

iqvVfRh.jpg

zEnMcWc.jpg

hXJz2hZ.jpg

rkeTLdM.jpg


Practiced my Mumbleypeg skills. :D

CGu1kND.jpg


It caused a mini earthquake, just by looking at the ground.

nOb68vb.jpg


Oh, and it held up the moon when it started to fall from the sky.

YcCGbGa.jpg


CONCLUSION:

Six days into not sharpening it for a week, it's still going strong. It no longer shaves, but it will slice paper well. It has a couple small flat spots on the blade from use, but no chipping. Still love the knife. After putting a little bit of a patina on, but then scrubbing most of it off, it's started to take a bit more of a natural patina.
 
Btw, I'm going to strip mine now. [emoji106]

DO EET. :D

Very small entry.

USE FROM YESTERDAY:

Cut a piece of onion for a hamburger, and cut a couple other little things.

CONCLUSION:

Still love it. It's been a week since I've sharpened it, edge is holding well, no chipping or anything, just a few flat spots near the belly. I'm gonna try to get a video of how sharp it still is today or tomorrow.
 
Back
Top