Jamie and Sarah. I grin...broadly.
These are all the "traditional style farmers jacks". I couldn't hardly have magically envisioned a better "rooster comb" than the one Ken made for me.As I said,except for the shield on uncheckered handles.
OK JL hear goes.
Pruning blade .
This Remington shows the proportional aspect I like,although in person it is more robust than the NYK made for Hibbard Spencer Bartlett (OVB Our Very Best) on the left below.
Either of these but the NYK HSB OVB on the left,with the little swelled end (and the extended point) gives it that little extra.The Ulster on the right has a very nice blade too.The pruning blade in the Wostenholm I will show also has a great blade and one of my favorite frames.
The spey.
These show the best look to me,being made without a catchbit.having a nice swedge on a heavy spey. The Cattaraugus' cut on the spline being less at the tip,which I like,but the Wester Bros is good.The Ulster in the last picture shows the type of spey that was typical for all the very early ones.The Ulster is probably from the 1890s. I would would not abject to any of the three shown .
Cattaraugus
Wester Bros
Ulster
The frames and bolsters.
This Wostenholm's frame and bolsters are great,maybe my favorite,but this is tough. A little more manly than the NYK I'll show. As said before,4" is the typical length of these,with little exception.
The NYK made frame and bolsters.This knife has a unique spey that the 38s were somewhat patterned after.I really like it's uniqueness and would like one like this sometime also.It shows the pruning blade,but not as easily seen are the nuances of it,as stated above.
Regarding the bolsters. the Wostenholm and the NYK are very similar.The added threads that Ken Erickson did on mine made the bolsters special. The rat tail being a little less than the normal traditional,except Schrades,who used a thin rat tail.
Best I could do JL,this is kinda like picking which of your children you like best.