I do not have the technical expertise to critique a photograph other than what is pleasing to my eye. Layout, lighting, background all have to be judged by me within that very limited ability.
I do think, however, that a personal interaction up to and including friendship with the photographer tilts me one direction or the other as easily as anything else. Therefore, I naturally tend to lean toward the offerings of Jim Cooper, Buddy Thomason, and Chuck Ward in no particular order. In regard to who is the best among them, it would boil down to a particular photo here and there, as I have seen work from each that based on MY opinion is the "best"
Now having said all that, I have not had the opportunity and/or pleasure of becoming acquainted with either Eric Eggly or Francesco Pachi, and therefore they fall by default to positions 4 and 5 on my list as it pertains to this thread. The work of any of the five is adequate to convey the image and make us appreciate or not appreciate the subject of the photo while all the time realizing it cannot replace the subject in hand.
The fact that someone did, in fact photograph the knives so we could at the very least have a very good idea of what they look like is enough for me, and I thank the contributors.
Beyond that, this thread is taking on the character of an argument looking for a place to happen.
In the words of my good freind.....
Best Regards,
Paul