Hey GW, just noticed meant a comparison from larger to the smaller. Man missed the boat on that, so lets redo that real quick
Looks..well the Avid just knocks the Select outta the water. I mean the small one looks nice enough for a utilitarian knife and fit and finish are good but I really think that Dymondwood on the Avid gives a little character to it. Granted am new so those may be a dime a dozen but even my wife commented that the Avid looked way more expensive then it was.
Clip, same just smaller. So far works just as well and seems just as sturdy.
Hardware seems to be the same type on both so not the adjustable versus pins Ive read about on other different levels of the same knife. The screws do seem to sit a little higher on the Select then the Avid. Not a defect or sloppy, just can feel the screw heads on the select where they are fully flush on the Avid.
The frame on both seems sturdy but the Avid has noticeably less give to it. Never had a G10 or whatever Ive read about that is on the Pro version but for a EDC for MY needs the Avid is great. And I suppose due to smaller mass and shorter spans even the frame of the Select appears to be more then sufficient for routine use.
The action on the Select is very good on mine, but still the Avid is a little smoother though not as smooth as my Alpha folder. When saying smooth am meaning either with thumb or 2 handed opening slow I can notice a smoother feel on the Avid. However, on the flicker I have to really flick it very smartly to have enough momentum to swing fully open without wrist assistance. No problem at all with wrist snap along with flick, but if just flick it casually it will fall about 30 degrees short of fully open. Am assuming this is due to extra mass of blade without any additional leverage on the flicker as the Select always flicks open easier.
On mine, the Avids blade is slightly off center but not rubbing where the Select is dead on center.
Blade design same just different size and holds the same proportion to frame in feel. Lockup on both feels the same and both are near edge of tang.
For carry, the Select can go anywhere with me where the Avid is more dependant on pocket size and or material. Ive not had the Select slip out of slacks where the Avid did if not clipped which I assume is due to the less grippy texture of the Avids handle and higher weight. In Jeans or similar pants/shorts not an issue. Thickness appears identical.
If you line the bottom/clip of both side by side with both closed the end/top of the closed Select is a little further then the end of the Avids thumb cutout towards the pivot screw. If you line up both closed the other direction the bottom/clip of the Select reaches the C in the Buck stamp on the Avids handle.
For height if you sit side by side with blades closed the Select back of blade (spine?) sits the height that the Avids liner lock appears next to its thumb cut out.
In use, the Select is obviously easier to do more detailed small work and around town stuff with while the Avid cuts thicker rope and everyday around the woods chores easier. Am new to knives in general so not sure which is function of blade steel in addtion to just size. However I believe it would be easier to choke up and use the Avid for detail work then to try and do the harder stuff with the Select.
So the Avid will be my routine carry between these two with the Select being when I need a smaller blade due to what am doing or wearing.