i wholeheartedly agree. when it comes down to sheer performance, a well-made carbon steel is great to have --very keen edge, long-lasting, easy to sharpen. too many knife steels carry a gazillion additives (chromium-vanadium-tungsten molybdenum! surgical steel! space age steel! ) of course, the question is what are all this elements doing there in these highly alloyed steels -- apart from letting people shove the knives in a dishwasher without a second thought. and the question is nothing much. extreme wear-resistance DOES NOT necessarily translate into a longer-lasting edge, and as to ease of sharpening...but i digress. in any case, as a knifemaker and a guy who spends a lot of time in the kitchen, i love the carbon blades, and if rust is an issue i can always make a laminated blade: stainless on the outside, high-carbon on the inside. best of both worlds.